3 ms·
Galileo's problems weren't due to his findings and theories going against the current consensus. Galileo's problems were a combination of: 1. His heliocentric
by tzs 5y ago
Galileo's problems weren't due to his findings and theories going against the current consensus. Galileo's problems were a combination of:
1. His heliocentric theory wasn't actually noticeably better at explaining observations than the current geocentric theories. Galileo, like the Church, believed in a universe intelligently designed by an all-powerful God, and he believed that said God would of course choose laws of physics that were mathematically beautiful and elegant. He had to hand wave away things that didn't fit with his notion of mathematically beautiful and elegant as optical illusions or observational error, which is not very convincing.
2. His ego. He was a celebrity who was frequently invited to hang out with the rich and powerful, which he loved.
3. He was an asshole. He was very intolerant of and rude to those he considered to be his rivals or his inferiors (and because of his big ego "inferiors" included pretty much everyone else).
4. He had a very poor sense of politics. He failed to realize or ignored that some of those rivals or inferiors that was a major asshole towards either were politically powerful or had better connections than he did to politically powerful people, and they could cause that power to be used to make his life miserable if he kept being a major asshole to them.
There's a great detailed look at the road to replacing geocentricism with heliocentricism here [1].
[1] http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/10/the-great-ptolemaic-smackdown-table-of.html http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/10/the-great-ptolemaic-smac...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 5y agoGalileo observed the phases of Venus and the moons of Jupiter, which provided strong evidence that contradicted geocentric theories.
- tzs 5y agoThose were problems for the Ptolemaic system, but were not a problem for Tychonic system. Tychonic cosmology had a stationary Earth with the Sun and Moon orbiting Earth, and the other planets orbiting the Sun. In Galileo's time there really wasn't good evidence to pick between Copernicus and Tycho. The new evidence only knocked out Ptolemy. The debate between fans of Copernicus and fans of Tycho was still largely philosophical and religious.