7 ms·
Whatever consensus you wish to call it, it was the consensus of those in power in society at the time that believed they knew the truth. Galileo was a scientis
by WalterBright 5y ago
Whatever consensus you wish to call it, it was the consensus of those in power in society at the time that believed they knew the truth.
Galileo was a scientist whether scientist was a recognized term at the time or not. He made observations, and developed theories based on those observations. That's science.
George Washington's death was hastened by doctors who bled him, 200 years after 1600.
And how about Darwin's theories, Lysenkoism, Phrenology, etc.?
- dlivingston 5y ago> Whatever consensus you wish to call it, it was the consensus of those in power in society at the time that believed they knew the truth. Your definition here is an apt one, and your examples demonstrate this particular effect well. My beef is that you framed them as 'examples of when the scientific consensus was wrong' when they do not demonstrate 'scientific consensus.'