3 ms·
Where is the line between banning and just not caring about a book? I have written a book of my own. No library in the world has it. No publisher chose to pick
by paxys 5y ago
Where is the line between banning and just not caring about a book? I have written a book of my own. No library in the world has it. No publisher chose to pick it up. Does that mean I am the most "banned" author in the world? Or maybe people have deemed that what I wrote is just not worth their time?
- ALittleLight 5y agoThe line is drawn by what you think the underlying motive is or would be. If you asked the BPL to host your book our shared assumption is that they would decline because they don't have infinite space and there are a large number of books out there. If their reasoning was that they thought your content was offensive or would inspire bad things in your audience then we would consider them to be "banning" your book.
- paxys 5y agoSo then how do you know which one of these it was when you apply your test?
- ALittleLight 5y agoI don't know. I just guess. It's not a completely random guess. Context informs the guess. For example, all the examples they give, and the books I saw when I scrolled through the underlying list their article is based on, seem to be about and banned for having gay sex, sexual abuse of children, sex with children, and racism. If they were equally interested in all banned books I think it would be an odd coincidence for all of their examples to be in that narrow range of topics. There are no books about how to run drug labs, commit genocide, or burn heretics among their examples? Odd...
- caslon 5y agoMost of the latter... aren't banned? Like, at all. They aren't so popular, but you can definitely find books on chemical synthesis in libraries.
- QuarterReptile 5y agoJust a guess, but I suspect a book gets banned because it's well known; it has content judged as immoral, unnecessarily sexual, etc.; and parents in an area suspect that teachers or librarians will try to convey the book to their children against the parents wishes. They thus take action through their school boards to draw a perfectly clear line. BPL is not subject to any of those jurisdictions, so they're legally untouchable as they do the same work of trying to undermine those parents.
- vincent-manis 5y agoI'm glad you didn't use loaded language there.
- QuarterReptile 5y agoI'm guessing that you're being sarcastic, though I'm not sure which language you're pointing out.
- moralestapia 5y agoWhat? Those two things are on complete opposite poles! When you ban something, you care about it so much that you take a hard stance against it, thus the ban.