3 ms·
This is only about books banned from some public school libraries. Not books banned in the US. The fundamental issue is, public schools are run by the governme
by WalterBright 5y ago
This is only about books banned from some public school libraries. Not books banned in the US.
The fundamental issue is, public schools are run by the government. Hence, the government makes the decision about what is to be taught, and how it is taught. The government schools cannot allow any teacher to teach whatever they feel like teaching. No school can work that way, unless it is a one person private school.
For example, public schools cannot teach creationism. Nor can they teach religion. Nor can they teach eugenics. Because the government decided what the curriculum would be.
It's not a free speech issue.
Now, if a non-government library decided to make these books available, and the government tried to stop it, that would be a free speech issue.
Also, if a private school made these books available in its school library, and the government tried to stop it, that would also be a free speech issue.
Note that many private schools teach creationism. It's their right to.
- pksebben 5y agoSo, these libraries should then also avoid stocking things like the bible, in your opinion. Do I have that right?
- WalterBright 5y agoI didn't suggest they avoid stocking anything. I said the government gets to decide what goes into the government school library.
- pksebben 5y agobut you mentioned creationism, specifically. and religion. I meant specifically by those terms.
- SauciestGNU 5y agoI guess the question here is whether having material available in a library is the same as promoting or teaching that material per se. I don't believe that's the case, I think libraries (even in public schools) are basically repositories of information, and how that gets used is the responsibility of the user and not of the library.
- WalterBright 5y agoYes, I did. The government banned them in the public schools. I didn't.
- pksebben 5y agoright, so, if we assume that the rule is "if pubic school cannot teach x subject, then books about x subject ought not to be in their library" (which is the inference in your comment) then you must mean that's for both books relating to gender non conformity and books like the bible. The point here being that there appears to be a double standard. "not taught in the curriculum" and "banned from the library" are different standards.
- WalterBright 5y agoThere's no double standard. The library is part of the public school. Therefore it is subject to the government's decision on what goes in it. If you are inferring that I am advocating that government ban books on X and supply books on Y in the school libraries, that is a serious misreading.
- WalterBright 5y agoThere's always going to be a fundamental tension between a publicly funded school and the ideals of a free society. The school will have 51% of the people deciding on what notions are taught, and the other 49% are forced to pay for it. While that tension will always be there, the public schools should try to minimize teaching political opinions and stick to teaching skills like readin ritin and rithmetic. History, too, although sadly history is very much politicized. I don't see a solution.