6 ms·
The scientific consensus used to be that the sun revolved around the earth, and you were put under house arrest if you published anything contradicting that. T
by WalterBright 5y ago
The scientific consensus used to be that the sun revolved around the earth, and you were put under house arrest if you published anything contradicting that.
Then there was that scientific consensus that margarine was good for you and eggs caused heart attacks.
Or that scientific consensus that disease could be cured by draining the bad blood out of your body.
Or that scientific consensus that if you sailed west too far, you'd fall off the edge of the world.
Or my favorite scientific consensus that in order to ensure a good harvest, it was necessary to chop the hearts out of your enemies and offer it to the gods.
- yongjik 5y ago> The scientific consensus used to be that the sun revolved around the earth ... Ever thought about why it took so long for this particular "scientific consensus" was reverted? Because geocentrism could explain the motions of planets pretty accurately, and the easiest actual evidence of heliocentrism was that apparent locations of stars should move very slightly following the motion of the Earth (i.e., parallax) - the effect was so small that the first measurement was made in 1838, about 200 years after Galileo's death. Until then, the apparent absence of parallax was a scientific evidence against heliocentrism. The lesson to draw is that it's not sufficient to have its proponent put under house arrest in order for a new theory to be accepted by the scientific community. Your new theory has to first explain all the things explained by the existing theory, and then some more that can not be explained by the existing one. I'll leave it to readers to conclude what that means in the context of global warming. Honestly I'm depressed by the level of discourse here. Otherwise mostly intelligent people are basically resorting to "Well some groups of people have been wrong about various things before, which proves that this particular (unrelated) group of people can be wrong, so instead of addressing the problem they say we have, let's debate for the umpteenth time whether the problem is real, again." It's a classical stalling tactic, and IMHO the only proper response is "Get out, adults are talking."
- WalterBright 5y agoI'm sad you've entirely misunderstood my point. I thought it was obvious. The point is, no matter how sure you are that you're right, you might still be wrong. If you suppress opposing viewpoints, you're also suppressing any evidence that you might be wrong. There are also people who know they're wrong - they suppress dissent because the truth will remove the power they enjoy. Nobody likes being wrong. It's soooo much easier to just suppress any hint of being wrong. The only way we'll know the truth is to allow dissent. Suppression of dissent is what tyrants do.
- tuwtuwtuwtuw 5y ago> If you suppress opposing viewpoints, you're also suppressing any evidence that you might be wrong. So what is your proposal? Twitter should continue spending their money on promoting something which may lead to millions of people dying? Or is it something else? My viewpoint is that your reasoning is incredible naive, well into the area of stupidity.
- kurupt213 5y agoI don’t think there is any evidence against the last one.
- WalterBright 5y agoEvidence against it is not needed. It needs evidence for it.
- kurupt213 5y agoThat’s much easier and less conclusive. The Catholic still confirms miracles and beatifies saints
- nso95 5y agoThese things you're listing happened before the scientific method was even developed
- driverdan 5y ago
- WalterBright 5y agoWhat's bad faith about it?
- dlivingston 5y agoSeveral things, but to name one, none of those examples are actually representing “scientific consensus” (except for the margarine example, and medical science is notoriously tricky and subject to lots of noise and false signals). Science didn’t even “exist” until the 1600s - well after the timeframes of nearly all of those examples. [0] Your examples demonstrate “social consensus”, “religious consensus”, “proto-medical consensus”, but not “scientific consensus.” [0]: a note that to say “science started at time X” is subjective, of course, but the modern formal framework of science is relatively new and putting it around the time of Isaac Newton’s Principia is probably a good rough guess. I would not consider Galileo to be a representative of modern science, more of a precursor.
- WalterBright 5y agoWhatever consensus you wish to call it, it was the consensus of those in power in society at the time that believed they knew the truth. Galileo was a scientist whether scientist was a recognized term at the time or not. He made observations, and developed theories based on those observations. That's science. George Washington's death was hastened by doctors who bled him, 200 years after 1600. And how about Darwin's theories, Lysenkoism, Phrenology, etc.?
- dlivingston 5y ago> Whatever consensus you wish to call it, it was the consensus of those in power in society at the time that believed they knew the truth. Your definition here is an apt one, and your examples demonstrate this particular effect well. My beef is that you framed them as 'examples of when the scientific consensus was wrong' when they do not demonstrate 'scientific consensus.'
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoTo be fair, those models were overturned by other scientists publishing their findings. Not randos taking out billboards.
- WalterBright 5y agoCheck out what happened to Galileo when he published his findings. Want more? How about Lysenkoism? Or the rejection of "jewish science"?
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoNone of which is relevant to a social media company restricting ads.
- tzs 5y agoGalileo's problems weren't due to his findings and theories going against the current consensus. Galileo's problems were a combination of: 1. His heliocentric theory wasn't actually noticeably better at explaining observations than the current geocentric theories. Galileo, like the Church, believed in a universe intelligently designed by an all-powerful God, and he believed that said God would of course choose laws of physics that were mathematically beautiful and elegant. He had to hand wave away things that didn't fit with his notion of mathematically beautiful and elegant as optical illusions or observational error, which is not very convincing. 2. His ego. He was a celebrity who was frequently invited to hang out with the rich and powerful, which he loved. 3. He was an asshole. He was very intolerant of and rude to those he considered to be his rivals or his inferiors (and because of his big ego "inferiors" included pretty much everyone else). 4. He had a very poor sense of politics. He failed to realize or ignored that some of those rivals or inferiors that was a major asshole towards either were politically powerful or had better connections than he did to politically powerful people, and they could cause that power to be used to make his life miserable if he kept being a major asshole to them. There's a great detailed look at the road to replacing geocentricism with heliocentricism here [1]. [1] http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/10/the-great-ptolemaic-smackdown-table-of.html http://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/10/the-great-ptolemaic-smac...
- h2odragon 5y ago> chop the hearts out That's where we went off the rails. It was the livers we were supposed to offer up. No wonder everything since then is so screwed.
- TedShiller 5y agoConsensus is the business of politics. Science, on the contrary, requires only one investigator who happens to be right, which means that he or she has results that are verifiable by reference to the real world. In science consensus is irrelevant. The greatest scientists in history are great precisely because they broke with the consensus. There is no such thing as consensus science. If it’s consensus, it isn’t science. If it’s science, it isn’t consensus. Consensus is invoked only in situations where the science is not solid enough. Nobody says the consensus of scientists agrees that E=mc2. Nobody says the consensus is that the sun is 93 million miles away. It would never occur to anyone to speak that way.
- 8note 5y agoScience relies heavily on a consensus of observations and a consensus on the analysis of those observations. Reproduction is creating aa consensus Plenty of scientists have broken with consensus without a new consensus forming around their models. "Scientists have consensus about X" is something science communicators say. It's about how easy it is to describe the evidence to laypeople than what the evidence is.
- BryantD 5y agoHeck, scientific consensus used to be that airborne diseases were transmitted by droplets. Whoops. The interesting thing about every single one of these examples is that consensus was able to change without anyone having to advertise on Twitter.
- iamthemonster 5y agoGenuine question: are airborne diseases not spread by droplets? I always assumed that it was the water droplets that carried viruses and bacteria, rather than them just floating freely in dry air.
- BryantD 5y agoExcellent question! The distinction here is between droplets and aerosol transmission. As I understand it, droplets are relatively large chunks of water (or whatever), and aerosols are particles in suspension in a gas. At the beginning of the pandemic, most scientific professionals assumed that COVID-19 was transmitted by droplets; the 6 foot distancing advice comes from that assumption, since droplets don't have much range. (Which is not to say that increasing distance didn't help, but 6' wasn't a magic number.) This article goes into useful depth on our new understanding: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abd9149?url_ver=Z39.88-2003&rfr_id=ori:rid:crossref.org&rfr_dat=cr_pub%20%200pubmed https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abd9149?url_ver=...
- vl 5y agoBut it's different this time.