2 ms·
Except that if there is a way to do the experiment, it can only be found by doing theory. Push the symbols around until something new falls out. Maybe it will.
by jfengel 5y ago
Except that if there is a way to do the experiment, it can only be found by doing theory. Push the symbols around until something new falls out.
Maybe it will. Maybe it won't. But it seems weird to dismiss it as fundamentally unsolvable.
I happen to agree that it's not likely to be solved, and even if it is won't be terribly useful. It gets funding only because it captures people's attention, for being "deep".
I'd love it if science funding were more rational, but that's hardly confined to fundamental physics. If it were up to me we'd fund theoretical physics AND a lot of other things, and stop funding a lot of expensive things I dislike. But plenty of people disagree, and the resulting process is inevitably irrational.
I see no value in shaking my tiny fists at one particular set of scientists over that.