4 ms·
I'd rather have more CSS posts personally, because they are in a way still tech related, than seeing the site turn into a generic news aggregator, or as I've sa
by sph 5y ago
I'd rather have more CSS posts personally, because they are in a way still tech related, than seeing the site turn into a generic news aggregator, or as I've said other times, a slightly more techy version of Ars Technica.
The guideline that "we should post things hackers [users] would find interesting" was good a decade ago, now we've good a ton of people that post their favourite long form articles and Twitter posts. I don't care for history, commentaries on society or personal philosophy musings with my code.
Honestly, I'm not really complaining, at least the quality of the discussion is still higher than elsewhere on the Internet.
- krapp 5y ago>The guideline that "we should post things hackers [users] would find interesting" was good a decade ago, now we've good a ton of people that post their favourite long form articles and Twitter posts. I don't care for history, commentaries on society or personal philosophy musings with my code. Do you believe the only thing hackers should find interesting is "code?"
- sph 5y agoNo, but that kind of leeway is what kills sites during an Eternal September. And no one ask for proof you're an hacker to open an account here (thankfully I might add). Hacker in the guidelines is just a synonym for user. Again, I don't want to force HN to limits its discussion to tech _only_, I'm just saying that I think it's getting more and more diluted.
- spoils19 5y ago
- sph 5y agoPersonally, I would like to see any political flag-waving and finger-pointing like yours banned with extreme prejudice. It certainly doesn't make for interesting discussion.
- naoqj 5y agoIn other words you want to freely spread your political beliefs without anybody complaining.
- sph 5y agoI just said I'm not a fan of _any_ politics on a tech forum. I do not spread my political beliefs on HN. Talking politics is, together with discussing your favourite football team or religion, the lowest form of intellectualism: if you agree, it's an echo chamber, if you don't, we're just talking past each other.
- erik_seaberg 5y agoYeah, the ideal HN post should be fascinating for hackers and deathly boring for everyone else. Ragebait draws masses who could easily swamp the signal:noise of any thread here.
- IgorPartola 5y agoNo, but I am with the person you are replying to that if a higher percentage of the content had to do with hacking it would make HN a more interesting place.