3 ms·
Seasoned engineers go for simple and effective tech. You can find a good amount of those on here. A few might browse the site from lynx or Emacs. The other "fa
by sph 5y ago
Seasoned engineers go for simple and effective tech. You can find a good amount of those on here. A few might browse the site from lynx or Emacs.
The other "fancy" tech forum full of new tech and slow as molasses (Reddit) is mostly frequented by the younger, more inexperienced generation of hackers.
- krapp 5y agoNo, the only reason HN uses flat files is that the forum is a MVP for Arc Lisp, and pg just wanted to implement everything in Arc. Seasoned engineers understand the drawbacks and benefits of different forms of technology and choose the right tool for the job rather than simply assuming the simplest solution is always the best. I'm not insulting HN here but it is what it is, one person's side project that took off. Also, Reddit is able to handle millions of users and over a million subreddits while Hacker News nearly collapses if a single thread gets too much traffic. Comparing the two and deciding Reddit was built by less experienced developers with inferior, poorly thought out technology is just ridiculous.
- sph 5y agoI get more issues with Reddit breaking that HN, and of course the first one has more users, but also brings much more revenue and has more SRE than HN has. HN is remarkably stable for its size.
- threeseed 5y agoHN is one of the simplest and inherently scalable web apps you can get. Of course it's stable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- krapp 5y agoHN is neither simple nor inherently scalable. Dang recently asked people to log out so he could manually deal with a thread whose traffic was slowing down the entire site[0,1]. As a framework HN has fundamental architectural flaws and scalability has always been one of them. That would never happen even on a small forum with a relational database and proper load balancing/caching etc (in other words, with all that "fancy" modern stuff HN often considers unnecessary.) [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?shownew&id=31026659 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?shownew&id=31026659 [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31027882 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31027882
- mhh__ 5y agoReddit is really bad though. Of all the tech companies I think they must be up there for the worst technology. Buggy on mobile, slow, user-hostile etc. As a company I'm not sure whether that means they're doomed or whether they've built a userbase so strong they couldn't kill it if they tried.
- mschuster91 5y agoReddit mobile being bad is intentional. They want you to use the official app because they can run more analytics there.
- mhh__ 5y agoI meant the app. On Android at least it's slow, unreliable and recently had even started to open the wrong thread when I click on things. This is not on an old phone either.
- pessimizer 5y agoReddit was built on Rails and used to shit itself constantly. I'm pretty sure the primary reason why it's more stable now is a lot of work, improvements in how Ruby runs, and that they throw a billion servers at it. I can't remember where I got this idea, but I think HN just runs on one or two machines.
- dcx 5y agoReddit was never built on Rails - it was Lisp and then Python. Aaron Swartz wrote web.py for Reddit. But your core point is probably true!