3 ms·
That's all fine and I don't necessarily take issue with what you're saying, but now we're talking about implementation details. > but show me what a system lik
by sbuttgereit 5y ago
That's all fine and I don't necessarily take issue with what you're saying, but now we're talking about implementation details.
> but show me what a system like that would look like.
I'm guessing not so much more wacky as the lidar based cars I see driving through my neighborhood. The accident in the original link may well have been caused by an inadequate vision based system (I don't know), but just because an accident happened with a single vision implementation doesn't mean that somehow Lidar/Radar would necessarily be superior. That conclusion, tossed off by the original comment, is just wrong as it stands.
> A human that is parking somewhere ambiguously often gets out of their car to inspect the area with their binocular vision from multiple angles;
In most cases, but not always. I have an old friend that was completely blind in one eye: still legally licensed to drive and successfully navigated the environment better than a lidar/radar/artificial vision system still can. Even in bad weather conditions such as snow and rain (and night). Will that hold true over time? Hard to say, but I'd bet right now that the larger problem is processing the received information regardless of how the information was acquired.
The problem with the original statement is that it reminded me of the line of reasoning that goes, "there are aspects of the world that science has no answer for, therefore God." or "there was an abnormally cold day in spring, therefore no global warming" Tesla hasn't implemented a sufficiently robust visual driving system to avoid running into parked airplanes, therefore Lidar/Radar. It simply doesn't follow. Much more is needed.
Ultimately, to date, the only sufficient input for fully independent driving that we have is vision based. Lidar/Radar may ultimately be superior, but a vision based system is so far the only generally accepted method for driving... even if it is biological vision rather than computer vision.