3 ms·
>You missed the important point: an artistic object is a concretion of a structure of meanings. It takes a proper intelligence to build that - you need conceptu
by krapp 5y ago
>You missed the important point: an artistic object is a concretion of a structure of meanings. It takes a proper intelligence to build that - you need conceptual depth, reflection etc.: you have by definition wait for a GAN.
I didn't miss the point, i'm arguing the point is debatable. There are entire artistic movements whose thesis is to deny the necessity of "meaning" in art, apart perhaps from whatever meaning the viewer imparts to it. If you didn't know some of these works were done by an AI, you would see the 'conceptual depth, reflection, etc.' in them, but that emotional, empathetic connection one has with a work of art is entirely fabricated. These AIs respond to natural language requests in ways that can be indistinguishable from human effort, they pass the Turing Test for creativity without intelligence.
So I think it's valid to question whether art necessarily requires any such thing on the part of the "artist" at all, or if we just believe it does because we're afraid that if creativity can be generated by an algorithm, it's just another sign that we're nothing more than deterministic machines ourselves.
- mdp2021 5y ago> There are entire artistic movements whose thesis is to deny the necessity of "meaning" in art If such thesis founds the artistic production, then this will be the «concretion of a structure of meanings» around the «den[ial of] the necessity of "meaning" in art». There's "a whole world" of bodies of knowledge and "persons" (individual expressions of the possible forms of being in a supposedly organic - consequential - relation to the richness of being) founding an artistic expression. Have a creature experience being and react to it in proper senses, then the expression may start being artistic. > These AIs respond to natural language requests in ways that can be indistinguishable from human effort, they pass the Turing Test for creativity without intelligence So the artist - provided that the quality is actually there - in that case is the reader. That is already part of art ("If I put in my books everything people read in them I'd be a genius", someone said - I cannot recall who). It does not mean that the original product is artistic, that "it has what it takes". Also: Turing Tests are far from objective, with reference to length or time (etc.) measurements. They surely may pass in front of some Turing Test/ers/. Surely some students pass, after some professors. It is even recorded that some professors managed to have a career and be illiterate. > or if we just believe it does because Even if the creator were a «deterministic machine», there would be a complexity in play and the presence or absence of modules to make the difference. Without them, easily the system will show to be brittle - take for example the visual classifiers that were at some point shown to "recognize" textures but not shapes, that will change response upon the change of an actually irrelevant pixel etc. > to question whether ... or There is no question in that false dichotomy: proper human creation has grounds through modules that current AI does not have. All modules must be in place. Anything can "create" - "unintentionally", "unawarily" etc.: with limited depth.