3 ms·
However pleasant a thought experiment that might be - the US's long experience with prohibiting alcoholic beverages eliminating alcohol-related crimes and socia
by bell-cot 5y ago
However pleasant a thought experiment that might be - the US's long experience with prohibiting alcoholic beverages eliminating alcohol-related crimes and social problems (oops, it didn't), and the War on Drugs(tm) eliminating drug-related crimes and social problems (oops, it didn't) would seem to suggest that "ban all guns" is not the great idea that one might wish.
- altacc 5y agoThis is false equivalence. There are many things that used to be widespread in the USA but today are non-existent or greatly reduced. Just pointing to examples of different things is not a coherent argument.
- Throwawayaerlei 5y agoI seriously doubt you're referring to anything people have been willing to kill for to get access to throughout the ages like alcohol or weapons. Alcohol and firearms are intimately intertwined in US history, from what sparked our revolution into a hot shooting one as the British attempted to destroy arms and ammunition stored in Concord, Massachusetts to the Whiskey Rebellion which started 16 years later. One should not consider forcing a major social change without considering the consequences, the example of the lasting to this day damage done to the social order of Prohibition of alcohol being an excellent example. For example all but extinguishing the local tavern and replacing it with the speakeasy derived bar, massively damaging respect for the law, giving organized crime it's greatest period to entrench itself in the nation, etc.