65 ms·
“Multiple personality disorder” probably doesn't exist
- devwastaken 5y agohttps://youtu.be/LkeeoKWj2i8 https://youtu.be/LkeeoKWj2i8 It's dissasociative identity disorder. It's caused due to trauma and we don't particularly know how to treat it or do much about it. One thing to be aware of is that diagnostically there is no way to know "real" from "fake" diagnosis. Anyone can walk into a clinic and say the right things to get whatever diagnosis they want. There are a lot of real cases of did that go untreated largely because how unknown this disorder is to the majority of psychs. That said I know a number of fakes that treat disorders as fads for attention, they treat it like it's a drama play. The internet makes it too easy for them to have a megaphone.
- 0xbadcafebee 5y ago> I am truly worried for online youth culture, and for that I’ll be called a reactionary. The fastest way to get everyone to ignore you is to preemptively complain of conspiratorial repression by the ignorant. If you have something useful to contribute, do. If people disagree, then retort. But don't sit here moaning about how nobody's going to believe you. Science requires evidence and persistence, not the immediate acceptance of conjecture.
- kixiQu 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scrupulosity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scrupulosity <-- Cultural influence of religious faith has always shaped how what-we-would-now-definitely-class-as-mental-disorders look, too. Reminds me of the discussions about young women presenting with tics clearly influenced by particular Tourette's influencers. A person would definitely not have had those symptoms in those ways if they weren't seeing that content ("fake" rather than simply innate), but can still be experiencing the root of it all as real compulsions and anxiety... but can then also seek attention w/r/t the whole thing, play up their experiences, etc. It's not actually useful to put "real" and "fake" binary labels on everything, because brains are complicated, society is complicated, and brains in society, well. I am not an expert but have enough, uh, relevant medical histories in my life and my family that I feel pretty confident in the following: trying to draw a bright line between "serious and pathological" and "just get over yourself", whether in physical or mental health, is an exercise based in wanting to bestow or deny validation, not in pragmatic utility or fundamental nature. Debating how that line should be drawn is maybe helpful in terms of navigating US insurance billing, but rarely reflects Deep Essential Truth in the way people hope it will. Staying flexible in your thinking is really useful to actually figuring out how to best treat yourself and others, especially where people tend to consider their loci of control way too far inside or outside themselves.
- frereubu 5y agoThis is a great article on the Tourette's influencers scene, which I had no idea existed: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/02/social-media-illness-teen-girls/622916/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/02/social-med...
- tus666 5y ago> DID is often presented as a kind of get-of-accountability-free card, as someone who claims to have it can always say that past bad behavior was caused by another personality and is thus not their responsibility. Isn't that basically mental illness in general? > fabrications shaped by therapists who insist that traumatic events must have happened It seems that the idea of trauma (especially childhood) itself remains highly controversial in psychiatry. Why? There appears to be this nexus or intersection between personally responsibility in the legal/social context and our willingness to acknowledge the affects of trauma. The connection between psychiatry and the demands of the legal system are probably underappreciated.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> Isn't that basically mental illness in general? I’m puzzled by this question. Are you suggesting that all mental illness allows the one suffering to abdicate “past bad behavior”?
- tus666 5y agoI was saying it often is used as an excuse in legal proceedings. I don't really have an opinion if that is right or not.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago“According to an eight-state study, the insanity defense is used in less than 1% of all court cases and, when used, has only a 26% success rate. Of those cases that were successful, 90% of the defendants had been previously diagnosed with mental illness.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insanity_defense https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insanity_defense
- tus666 5y agoMental illness is still widely used as a mitigating factor in sentencing, even if insanity is not plead.
- chasing 5y agoMildly interesting article until he starts whining about "lefties" and straw-manning what he thinks their reactions to all of this will be. To which: No. Humoring people who make up mental disorders for social media clout is not "woke." "Woke" is being aware that people with mental disorders exist and that our society should be accepting and inclusive.
- vintermann 5y agoSelf-interpretations can't really be right or wrong. Science can't tell you how you should see yourself. That said, there are self-interpretations that seem pretty self-destructive, and seeing yourself as having multiple identities seems like one.
- jahewson 5y agoSure they can. There’s no shortage of people out there carrying around negative perceptions of themselves that are wholly incorrect. The self is a construct and your brain will assemble it out of its experiences.
- Tao331 5y ago> there are self-interpretations that seem pretty self-destructive That's the counter argument to your previous assertion. A self-interpretation is wrong if it destroys the self. By destroying the interpreter (the self), the interpretation becomes an unfalsifiable claim.
- vintermann 5y agoThis is just nonsense. You're not wrong for being foolhardy, or for doing something I see as self-destructive. Presumably you have a reason that makes it worth it to you. Everyone is destructed in the end anyway.
- Tao331 5y ago> Everyone is destructed in the end anyway. Is this true? How do you know?
- pgcj_poster 5y agoBrains are networks. Our concept of a unified "self" is illusory and collapses when subjected to any serious philosophical scrutiny. If some people prefer to conceptualize themselves as multiple entities sharing a body, that's no less accurate than the useful fiction that, for instance, we remain the same person throughout our lives. I agree that most people who identify this way can't accurately be described as having a mental disorder -- because there's nothing wrong with it. It's true that you shouldn't revel in your mental dysfunction or let your identity distract you from your real problems. However, there's no reason why people can't have a plural identity and choose not do those thing. The kids are alright.
- moth-fuzz 5y agoThis article is chock full of cynicism with no actual factual reasoning. Deeply reactionary and without any actual point. A polemic, at best. Need I count the number of references to tumblr, tiktok, social media memes, dyed-hair left-leaning millennials with quirky personalities? All that self-victimization, which is all for the purpose of, let me guess, attention? You're the one writing articles on the internet, my man. The best evidence this article can come up with is equally polemic articles and a hand-picked troupe of social media teens. Selection bias at its finest. Is this as tiring for anyone else as it is for me? Note the top comments saying the same things about homosexuality and transgenderism, of course.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pksebben 5y agocame here to say it, but you said it better. If the first legitimate-sounding resource mentioned is cherry picked from the early oughts, you might be reading garbage.
- WaffleIronMaker 5y agoI'm surprised this is so highly voted, given the poorly grounded nature of the article.
- lsiq 5y agoFoucault implied the same. Or at least, suggested that as the scientific definitions are created so too does the phenomena emerge. Ian Hacking expanded upon this and named this concept, dynamic nominalism. That's why we had "madmen" in 19th century and that no longer exists, only to be subsumed by supposedly more specific new descriptions that psychologists have come up with. The idea of dynamic nominalism is not that such a label as "Multiple Personality" is contrived but that the described phenomena becomes real. The two simultaneously and unconsciously converge, in a sense, to exist. My own thought is that you can this expand concept for a lot of current & former social categories that are even broader - and not restricted to psychology, such as being a hippie. And also the social category that is currently in vogue.
- masterphilo 5y agoThis article is trying to make an excellent point (emphasized in the second half of the write-up), but the claim that "DID probably doesn't event exist" is untrue, and but I'm sure the author only meant as click-bait. DID does exist, the problem seems to be the willingness of many psychologists & medical professionals to broaden the definition to encompass much of the phenomena we see on Tik-Tok. Could it be that all young kids are extremely impressionable, and without a consistent culturally-enforced set of values (especially regarding identity), it's perfectly plausible for many of them identify (at the personality level) with a number of influencers that they follow on that platform? And how is that ultimately affecting their general mental health, even if they are not outwardly unhappy?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ThinkBeat 5y agoAs someone who has no idea what happens on TikTok, this article was confusing.
- Tao331 5y agoIt's r/tulpas without My Little Pony
- WheelsAtLarge 5y agoA woman I knew had one personality that would basically be a party girl with all it's connotations and then turn to being a highly religious god fearing woman, again, with all the connotations that go with it. She even had 2 different names. One for each personality. And she referred to the 2 personalities as if they were 2 distinct individuals. I happen to catch it by accident as she tried to keep the different personalities separate so she would try to keep the related social groups separate too. I think she was aware of the 2 and thought nothing of the transformations from one to the other which she made with out much fuss. My guess is that she had such an overwhelming need to be one, but she could not let go of it, that she created a second personality to satisfy her needs. It was very strange to deal with her in different settings. The personalities were different enough that I could tell who was who by looking at her. I've never met someone like that again. She was well aware of it so I don't think it was a mental condition that needed to be treated. I've often suspected that there must be a few people that have such a deep need to be someone else that they get lost in what ever second personality they create and lose touch with reality only to be brought back by their real life situation. It might not be multiple personality disorder but it has to be a flavor of it.
- manicdee 5y ago
- Majora320 5y agoI'm disappointed this culture war drivel got to the front page of HN. I have a close friend with DID caused by severe childhood trauma, who has contributed to the sorts of TikTok communities mentioned in the article. Those faking it for attention or clout exist, and invented victimhood is definitely a thing, especially among the sheltered upper middle class. But most of this is just byproduct of youth and inexperience with the world that people tend to grow out of. People like this watch teenagers still discovering themselves do or say some mildly stupid stuff and construe it as the collapse of society or something.
- 3243thwall 5y agoThis is a complicated topic that resurfaces from time to time in the psychiatric literature. These types of arguments tend to take the presentation of people meeting criteria for DID at face value, and then argue that it doesn't exist, which is sort of beside the point. No one (or few in the field) really believe that people meeting criteria for DID have independent identities in the sense of having different psychological entities in the same body, with different memory systems, personalities, and so forth. It's a strawman argument. Even DID researchers point this out, but it tends to get ignored by individuals writing pieces like this. The truth is, there are patients who present with symptoms of DID, as is the case with other dissociative and related disorders. They are almost certainly "fake" at some level, but the phenomenon of presenting with neurophysically implausible symptoms nonetheless exists, and has its own set of issues. It's sort of akin to psychopathy and lying: a psychopath might lie, but you don't say that predatory dishonesty isn't a problem because what they say isn't true. In the same way, someone presenting with dissociative symptoms is doing the thing they're doing, and it deserves some sort of distinct label. Contrary to what the poster has written, longitudinal and chart review studies do show that people with DID have sexual abuse histories at higher rates than other types of patients, like close to 80% of cases. And contrary to stereotype, the typical DID patient is rather shy and avoidant of attention. I guess it's odd to me in some ways because while it was important to try to determine whether or not people presenting with alternate identities really have "neurocognitively separate selves", finding that they don't doesn't mean you should write off the idea that there is something qualitatively different about the sets of problems involved when someone does do this sort of thing. You could relabel it , which might be fine, but this area is already full of controversy (should we open the can of worms of somatic symptom disorder, for example?).
- captainmuon 5y agoSo it is like that there is an ICD code for lycantropy - that doesn't mean the patients actually turn into werewolves, but that they delusionally believe they do.
- Foxmilk 5y agoI wonder how many of these people are just creating and interacting with tulpas without realizing it. For anyone who isn't familiar, there is a subculture online of people who create what subjectively seem to be autonomous personalities that frequently manifest I'm the form of hallucinations. Think fight club sort of. My ex tried it out. Called me one day at work, terrified because this dragon was following him around. He claimed to spend months trying to get rid of it, seems pretty shooken by the experience. But I was always skeptical. So nine months ago I decided to create one of my one, just to try it out, see what it felt like. And...now I've had a talking lion following me around for the past eight months. The best I can describe it is like some of the altered states of 'self' you might experience on LSD or ketamine. Thoughts seem to split off and go 'over there', and not be you. When I talk to my tulpa, it at least appears subjectively like a separate personality state. I can be incredibly depressed but he can be fine. Or he will be depressed and I can be fine. I'm not saying there are neural correlates like you would see in a 'real' personality. Maybe it is all roleplay. But it is roleplay that fools me as the roleplayer. For what it's worth, making a tulpa seems to have been really good for my mental health. I guess maybe you can see it as a form of self-regulation. I dunno, it didn't turn out at all what I expected. But it's hard not to think of him as a real person. I don't find myself being surprised by the actions of characters in my head, or laughing at imaginary friends. At this point, having out several hundreds hours into tulpaforcing, I can see and hear, and sometimes smell and touch him. I know I'm rambling, I guess I'm saying is that even though I am skeptical of DID, or at least the mainstream depictions of DID, after making a tulpa I am a lot less skeptical of the subjective experience of DID.
- rikroots 5y agoThank you for introducing me to the world of tulpas. As an adult, I've written a couple of novels. Reading a few of the reddit tulpa-related posts I got the feeling that some of the characters I generated had tulpa-like qualities - in particular the independence aspect: having a series of internal conversations with a key character who profoundly disagreed with the plot line I had developed for her was one of the weirder experiences I had while writing that book. (She did make some very good points and eventually got her way, mostly). I'm now wondering what sort of crossover there is between tulpas and childhood imaginary friends. I'm pretty certain that from my memories of my IF ('Mr Man'), he was an entirely separate entity from me, and a scary one at that - though only towards other people, never me. As much as he often offered me good advice at the time, I'm not sure I'd want to invite him back into my life today.
- 1MachineElf 5y agoAnother interesting theory that may be related is given in Julian Jaynes' The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind (1976).
- metamuas 5y agoConnecting a manshonyagger doesn't work out; see the death of Shardik. It would be horrible if 'connecting' someone lead to ananaphylactic shock.
- rurban 5y agoMy wife treats some of them, and they definitely do exist. The human brain is a fantasticly complex organ, and these personalities help the brain to overcome severe trauma. but it is extremely rare of course. now my wife read it and commented: no, this article is very well written and very true.
- rob_c 5y agoFrom what I've read (which makes me worse informed than ill-informed) most experts are still stating that most split-personality symptoms develop once the diagnosis is made and there is a chicken and egg concern that people aren't diagnosed without being made aware of it which may be hiding broader/other mental problems in the process. Out of curiosity does experience in treatment match these concerns?
- rurban 5y agoI've talked now to another colleague of her. they do share the scepticism that it belongs into the DSM5 at all. but they have a crazy case of a traumatized woman who has a cat as alter. miau. hard to detect any cheating, but they are trying
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MaxLeiter 5y agoI found the intro on multiple personality disorder and tiktok interesting, but the article is really about politics, which isn’t reflected in the title. I lost interest when he mentioned leftists
- tantalor 5y agoIt's mentioned in the subtitle: > TikTok culture can be incredibly toxic, but those on the left refuse to ever condemn it for fear of echoing conservatives
- meowface 5y agoFair reaction, but just as an FYI, Freddie deBoer is himself a prominent leftist blogger. So this is kind of an "intra-leftism" dispute. That arguably makes it a little less eye-rolling to read as one might find from a rightist critiquing the left, or vice versa.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThere's a lot of gatekeeping over what counts a "genuine left-ism" and deBoer is probably one the people most subject to it over the last decade. He is routinely eviscerated for his views on many other clearly left-ish blogs etc. and generally not treated respectfully in such venues. Don't even consider bringing up his name or any of his writing on, for example, Lawyers Gun Money, unless you do not mind being ridiculed too. So yeah, intra-leftism dispute is probably more applicable to deBoer than almost any other old-school-but-still-at-it blogged that I can think of.
- rob_c 5y agoTrying to replay a-politically (with the knowledge that nothing happens in a political vacuum in reality). It can be successfully argued that the political left have adopted the drama and status of victimhood in a way that hasn't been done before in mainstream politics and given the strong correlation between political affiliation and age I think it's a concerning edge to the topic of mental health, or perception there of. The right is also capitalising very late on this claiming that marxist censorship by private entities is akin to victimisation so the whole arena is now filled with it :( Not saying you're wrong for tuning out the article certainly is a little rambly.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoWhen it all goes political at the end, what exactly does the author think happened in colleges. He uses the word 'woke' as if a horrible plague struck. Maybe, I'm just sheltered, and civilization did collapse at some point in the last decade, so can someone point to a summary of what people in his bubble think happened? > The specific way that lefties will dismiss this problem will be to say, hey, who cares, it’s just adolescents on TikTok. They won’t affirmatively say that it’s good that thousands of teenagers claim to have spontaneously developed an extremely rare and very punishing mental illness, because that’s stupid, so they’ll say it just doesn’t matter, and really it’s weird that you’re paying attention to this. I’ve already established why I care - I believe that this behavior, and the broader suite of 21st century progressive attitudes towards mental health, are doing immense damage to vulnerable young people. But also we’ve seen this movie before. > People pretend that this never happened, now, but in the early and mid-2010s, the stock lefty response to woke insanity at college was not to say that the kids were right and their politics were good. That was a rarely-encountered defense. No, the sneering and haughty response to complaints about, say, incredibly broad trigger warning policies that would effectively give students the option to skip any material they wanted to was, “hey, it’s just college! They’re crazy kids, who cares? Why are you paying so much attention?” Of course, first it was just elite liberal arts colleges, tiny little places, who cares about what happens there. And then it was just college. And then it was just college and Tumblr, and then college and Tumblr and Twitter, and then it was media and the arts, and then all the think tanks and nonprofits, and when it had reached a certain saturation point the defense changed: now it was good. Just like that, overnight, the “it doesn’t matter if that’s happening” sneering defense switched to the “yes that’s happening and it’s good that is’s happening” sneering defense. From an argument of irrelevancy to an argument of affirmation in no time at all, and absolutely no acknowledgment that what they were dismissing as meaningless the day before they were now defending on the merits.
- rectang 5y agodeBoer is a partisan providing raw meat to a partisan audience. If you're on his side the style of showering contempt on your adversaries is thrilling, if you're on the other side it's grating. Such articles usually get flagged sooner or later.
- 5y ago
- DoreenMichele 5y agoThe HN title is a really terrible title. (It's a shortened version of a longer title that's not so click bait. ) This isn't really an attempt to assert that Multiple Personality Disorder doesn't exist. It's an attempt to say that there is unhealthy stuff happening in how youth interact via social media and most claiming to have this disorder on social media clearly do not.
- jzellis 5y agoNext you're going to tell me supersoldier serum and horny sentient planets aren't real either, you monster
- johnny22 5y agoI can't say I've heard of "horny sentient planets"
- sampo 5y agoI think it's a reference to the movie Guardians of the Galaxy 2.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThat or a very, very elliptical reading of "Solaris"
- Trasmatta 5y agoSee also: Internal Family Systems. It's a form of therapy that considers all of us has having many different discrete "parts". I recently started IFS therapy and have been having success with it. I'm not sure how literally I take the "parts" (I think they may be much less "solid" and more transient than IFS claims), but it seems to be a really interesting and helpful way to approach your own mind. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_Family_Systems_Model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_Family_Systems_Model
- ComradePhil 5y agoAre you working with an IFS therapist or are you using Pete Gerlach's online self-help course? Has anyone had success with Pete Gerlach's course?
- Trasmatta 5y agoI'm working with an IFS therapist. I haven't used that course. I am also reading Jay Earley's "Self-Therapy" book in conjunction, and that's been helpful.
- moth-fuzz 5y agoThe thing about DID and IFS is the underlying recognition that most people have parts, sometimes dissociated (as is the case with BPD, for example, and other dissociative disorders), and that this is part of normal human psychology. The crux of it is that this is simply one of the fundamental tools our brains has to use in response to trauma. The whole disorder part of dissociative identity disorder is when it becomes a problem that impedes healthy functioning. Just like we all have anxiety, it's there to protect us and warn us of potential dangers, but an anxiety disorder is when the anxiety is no longer helpful, damaging, even.
- sshine 5y agoI'll second this recommendation. I personally interpret the "parts" quite literally, but what's most interesting is: You can make most people say that "a part of them wants X, while another part of them wants Y" without having swollowed any metaphysics. It's like the ability to address the ambiguity of one's mind, without needing to admit that it is fundamentally fractured, is a language that many will eagerly adapt to. And yes, IFS also makes the claim that "multiple personality disorder" isn't. Here's a website that tries to explain what it's like to embrace the plurality of one's being: https://morethanone.info/ https://morethanone.info/
- causality0 5y agoI think quite a few identity-centered mental illnesses might actually be particular delusions, and in some cases we may be grouping people subject to one mental abnormality with others who are under the delusion they have that abnormality. That could explain why certain subsets of people exhibit symptoms which don't match the normal presentation. For example, and anecdotally based on my personal experience, people under the delusion of being transgender get grouped together with people who are actually transgender. The "real" transgender people behave about the same way before and after their transition. They carry themselves like their gender, they talk like it, they react like it, and the biggest change after transitioning is them getting happier. The ones I hypothesize are actually subject to a delusion of being transgender don't act like that. Their personality shifts radically after transitioning and they behave like an exaggerated caricature of their target gender and have a very difficult time navigating small group dynamics of their target gender. I've seen similar patterns with people whose presentation of disorders like DID and Tourette's Syndrome differ radically from the clinical symptoms but match the pop culture presentation.
- naravara 5y ago> The ones I hypothesize are actually subject to a delusion of being transgender don't act like that. Their personality shifts radically after transitioning and they behave like an exaggerated caricature of their target gender and have a very difficult time navigating small group dynamics of their target gender. If they’re on the autism spectrum, though, they’d have trouble navigating small group dynamics regardless so what you’re describing could just be a comorbidity.
- zozbot234 5y agoWhat parent describes seems more akin to gender-related disphoria. There's actually some very real controversy among trans activists as to whether disphoria should be viewed as a necessary condition for trans status, as currently asserted by most in the medical community.
- humbugtheman 5y agoThis is a vast oversimplification of the range of transgender experiences, and the connotation that people "fake" being trans is all too familiar, but misinformed.
- okareaman 5y agoThis guy is not a psychiatrist. He makes an obvious point that we have a tendency to defend what our opponents attack sometimes when we shouldn't. I get so tired of the Malcolm Gladwell substack articles that get posted frequently to HN and reach the front page for some damn reason.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 5y agoIt says I submitted this two hours ago but I summitted it 23 hours ago...
- solenoidalslide 5y agoIf you go to your profile page [0] it looks correct. I wonder if this is a way to hide submission information from the public/submitter, or some other kind of dark feature. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=paulpauper https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=paulpauper
- smegsicle 5y agoit's not a 'light feature' in that it's explicitly documented, but dang has mentioned that some stories 'deserve a second chance', so think of it as an automated form of how any aggregator often sees good links submitted multiple times before one catches on
- smegsicle 5y agohttps://hnrankings.info/31128272/ https://hnrankings.info/31128272/ the Operators deemed your story Fit for Reevaluation
- rectang 5y agoManual intervention by the mods would be strange for such a stridently partisan article, given this bit from the guidelines: > Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.
- smegsicle 5y agoit's getting a lot of discussion, so seems like it was a good call you feel like the article is unfairly biased towards one political party?
- 5y ago
- jollybean 5y agoHis bits about 'the left' are poorly articulated, and mostly of wrong. But he's correct to ruminate that we live in an age whereupon everything can be considered an issue of 'identity' to the extent that it's some kind of intrinsic, principal orientation of personae. Coupled with the fact that challenges to 'identity' can be considered 'hate crimes' (I'm not being hyperbole, this is the legal situation in many places) - and you have a problem. We used to have 'Hippies', 'Punks', 'Goths', and even 'national' and 'religious' identities - but most of those were forms of expression, perhaps 'important' but never really intrinsic. We've taken it to a new level entirely and it's a rapidly expanding social problem.
- bnralt 5y agoI think a lot of people mistakenly believe "multiple personality disorder" (DID) is real because there are people who believe they have it and act accordingly. There's a lot of evidence that cases for it are iatrogenic - that is to say, caused by the psychologist (and I suppose now, by social media). This lead to multiple lawsuits by patients who had spent years being convinced that they had DID and repressed memories (DID is usually linked to the also controversial idea of repressed memories by psychologists). See this New York Times article[1] from a few decades ago that talks about it more. You can Google "multiple personality disorder lawsuit" to see many more such cases. You see a lot of cases where bad psychology destroyed lives. And the history of DID has always been _very_ questionable. If DID was a naturally occurring disorder, and one that's particularly noticeable, it's striking that (as far as I can tell) no one saw cases of it until very recently. Two cases and their dramatizations - that of Chris Costener Sizemore ("Eve") and Shirley Ardell Mason ("Sybil") - in particular where responsible for cementing it in the public's imagination, and leading to an enormous uptick in the diagnosis. If you look into those cases, you see that it's highly likely that they were iatrogenic - the patients weren't showing signs of DID, but he attention seeking psychiatrists "discovered" alternate personalities during their sessions using questionable techniques like hypnosis, and then used this to get rich and famous. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/1997/11/06/us/memory-therapy-leads-to-a-lawsuit-and-big-settlement.html https://www.nytimes.com/1997/11/06/us/memory-therapy-leads-t...
- babyshake 5y agoI'd suggest people mostly believe in DID and often confuse it with schizophrenia because multiple personalities is an often used trope in fiction. The Marvel show Moon Knight being one current example that comes to mind.
- Barrin92 5y agoYet another entry in the emerging genre of making an entirely uncontroversial point (criticizing people for glorifying and faking mental illness for attention), followed by the second half which is the author complaining about how everyone silences him for saying brave truths. Much better than false victimhood due do fake mental illness to get clicks on tiktok is of course false victimhood due to fake controversial journalism on substack.
- naravara 5y ago> Yet another entry in the emerging genre of making an entirely uncontroversial point (criticizing people for glorifying and faking mental illness for attention), followed by the second half which is the author complaining about how everyone silences him for saying brave truths. To be fair, Freddie De Boer basically pioneered this genre outside right wing culture warriors. I suspect he knowingly does it because he’s aware it gets him more clicks and engagement than if he just produced his content straight. That culture war hook is catnip for “the algorithm.” It’s a shame because I do find him to be an incisive writer on the core points he’s trying to make, but the side dish of outrage bait he serves up with every entree gets tiresome fast.
- rossdavidh 5y agoI don't know if I totally agree but I definitely felt, somewhere around the halfway point, something along the lines of "whoa it felt like we were making some good points here but not it feels like we've gone into angry rant mode".
- jollybean 5y agoNo, the false victimhood and invented identities on TikTok are 100x bigger than the very random bored people on substack claiming victimhood. The former is an artifact of current pop culture, the later is irrelevant.
- User23 5y agoWhat exactly does it mean for a mental condition to be real or not real? It’s often easy enough to determine if a physical phenomenon is actually occurring or illusion, but for a mental one? And while it’s tempting to make analogies from physical phenomena to mental ones, it’s not even wrong.
- pnathan 5y agoI'm friends with someone who has clinical DID. It is, as near as I can tell, not induced by media, etc, but by extreme and profound trauma. > The people who have traditionally been treated for DID have suffered, greatly, and not in the cool arty time-to-dye-my-hair-again type of suffering common to social media performance, but actual, painful, pitiable suffering. Those patients who have been diagnosed in the past with the disorder, by doctors, and who have spent years and years dealing with the consequences, are often truly debilitated people, whether the disorder itself is real or not. They require intense therapy, are often medicated with powerful drugs, and are frequently subject to long-term hospitalization. They tend to live broken and pain-filled lives, like most people with serious mental illness. This is a relatively accurate description of their life. Clinical DID is not cute or something to parade in front of people you don't know. I have extraordinarily little interest in open DID fora like Reddit, because these fora don't adequately encompass my friends' reality.
- mav88 5y agoYeah it's horrible. I have had contact with half a dozen people with severe DID because of extreme trauma experienced before the age of four. DeBoer is a great writer and he's dead right about the effects of social media on all this but he is completely wrong about the literature. The so-called Greenbaum Speech, alternatively called "Hypnosis in MPD", is just one example of the consistent body of work out there showing that it is very real.
- ralusek 5y agoUnless you work in a field that exposes you to extremely rare psychological conditions, there is absolutely no way for any person to have had contact with a half a dozen people with severe DID. If you're talking about the new wave of people who are self diagnosing with nonsense, then sure, but that's not what we're talking about.
- mav88 5y agoRun along sonny. There are plenty of ways that someone can have contact with survivors of ritual abuse who also experience DID. In my case I just proved knowledgeable and willing to listen and they reached out to me. One was sexually assaulted by Roman Polanski when she was a child, two or three were beta sex kittens, one was a courier and at least one had an assassin as an alter. So yeah, fuck you.
- a_shovel 5y agoThat paragraph starting "People pretend that this never happened" is a jewel of dishonest writing. The author never specifies any particular piece of "woke insanity" that it applies to, so the author isn't responsible for anything any particular reader takes away from it. Furthermore, leftists can't refute it because it doesn't, technically, make any specific claims about any specific thing that happened in real life. It's just vibes, and you can't argue against vibes.
- reilly3000 5y agoThe phenomenon of mental illness & trauma-based clout is intriguing and I don’t really understand it. Certainly a conservative trope for the balance of my life has been one of victimhood, from the notion of a persecuted majority to the plight of small business ownership. If it’s a liberal trope to be victim of one’s genetic makeup and life experiences the logical conclusion is that one shouldn’t feel remorse for not meeting societal expectations. I resonate with that, but am also concerned that the victim’s mindset ends up being self-limiting. We really celebrate the stories of those who have overcome adversity, and oftentimes invest a lot of energy and resources into removing sources of adversity, clearing the way for others. If adversity engenders strength, why try to remove it? Alternatively if it simply expends strength and reduces human potential, why celebrate it? I have no opinion on the matter, but I’d love more information. I’d also love philosophical perspectives around these topics. Please share if you have them. On the point of TikTok self-diagnosis being popular, I’ve certainly observed that. However it’s not limited to one political group as the author suggests. The platform and its algorithm have been really affecting at exposing affine groups, without explicitly labeling them. For everyone who walks away with a dubious self-diagnoses, I believe there are ten who have found support, validation, and resources for their very real conditions. That doesn’t get media attention. It’s just like the fact that billions of dollars worth of person-to-person transactions happen through Craigslist every year, yet only the times where violence take place dominate it’s narrative. Teens behave in unpredictable ways and this is a novel time when the aggregate of their activities are on full view to the world. They will inevitably grow and evolve. I’m not going along with any doomsayers about what is happening with teens on TikTok; it’s all temporal and portends nothing in particular.
- drewcoo 5y ago> We really celebrate the stories of those who have overcome adversity Or maybe, like Mother Theresa, we value suffering. https://ivarfjeld.com/2013/03/04/mother-teresa-no-saint-but-adoring-suffering/ https://ivarfjeld.com/2013/03/04/mother-teresa-no-saint-but-...
- pessimizer 5y ago> The phenomenon of mental illness & trauma-based clout is intriguing and I don’t really understand it. The original sin is the convention that punishment for crimes shouldn't be determined by the type of crime and the guilt of the defendant. Instead, it's normal to start with that to get a guideline, then choose from within that guideline based decisively on the degree of empathy and pity that the judge and/or jury feel for the defendant. This is done by selling the defendant as disadvantaged. But selling the defendant as materially disadvantaged has a drawback: as the individuals who make up the court are drawn from extremely advantaged classes, and claims of material disadvantage make them feel bad about themselves. They generally need to hold the view that all material disadvantage can be overcome by will, having that will (to overcome material disadvantage) thereby becomes a moral standard, and lacking that will becomes a second justification for punishment. A dog can resist food when it is starving if you hit it enough, so punishment actually becomes therapeutic. With the rise of the concept of psychology and mass medicalization of normal human ranges of behavior, sentencing couldn't help but become a ritual where the defense tries to sell the defendant as mentally unhealthy and pitiable. In other words, someone physically incapable of generating the will that punishment should give them. Punishment in the justice system is ostensibly a process for deciding on the disposition of people who have committed acts considered wrong. If the anxiety, sadness, or mental instability etc. of the person committing these acts results in less punishment for being wrong, the obvious conclusion to be drawn is that mental illness and disadvantage makes you righter or more correct. Hypothetically, the person with the perfect combination of illness and disadvantage is never wrong. Which IMO is why we have an culture of opposing mobs being led by people with severe cluster B personality disorders, and people who admire those people also developing these disorders by imitation. It's why when you get called out for molesting tweens, you come out as gay, or why when the twitter mob comes for you for a racist joke you made, you release an essay about being molested as a child and describe the therapy you're about to go into. Everybody wants to be weak, because the weakest are the rightest. The problem is that these people aren't actually weak (because performance of weakness is part of social climbing), and the loudest are active crybullies. Actually weak people are still voiceless and ignored. The US is spending less on mental illness. The US has a weaker safety net.
- betwixthewires 5y agoGood luck making any headway trying to talk about things like this by using reason. These people and their enablers don't care about reason, they'll just accuse you of "denying their lived experience" or some other such meaningless string of words. Any attempt to actually help them, as opposed to nodding in firm agreement, is going to be met as if it is an act of aggression. They don't want help because they know they don't need help, not the kind they say they need anyway. They want affirmation. The best thing you can do is just live your life as if they don't matter, mock them whenever you feel like it, and let them destroy their lives, which they inevitably will. That may be cold, but you can take a horse to water...
- pessimizer 5y agoWhen you derive all of your self-worth from a disadvantaged identity, attacking that identity is akin to attempting murder. This is different from people with actual disadvantages who have spend enormous effort to hide and to hopefully overcome them, not to broadcast them. Broadcasting weakness is not something that animals do except to avoid imminent and overwhelming attack. My upset is when people who actually disadvantaged get caught up in this rhetoric and ideology. When the heat gets too hot for the fakers, they'll move on to the next thing, leaving the people with real problems behind.