4 ms·
> I think there's two extremes here. One is the issue covered well above. There is a great deal of junk science that gets published. It's more than that, I thi
by lelanthran 5y ago
> I think there's two extremes here. One is the issue covered well above. There is a great deal of junk science that gets published.
It's more than that, I think. Sibling-thread poster hit the nail on the head when he complained of politicised science.
The social sciences have this dominating and silencing effect on the rest of the sciences.
There's always been junk science, and when found out it gets discredited. This is still happening and is a good thing.
What's new is that any research that might produce results counter to the what the PC-mob deems acceptable is attacked. Whether or not there is consensus amongst researchers in that field is irrelevant when the mob calls for the firing of any researcher who doesn't toe the current political party-line.
Sure, we're not actually in the dark ages, but a trend of silencing voices in the name of purity of thought is particularly troubling, especially as the mob asking for this is unashamedly attempting to implement NewsSpeak[1].
[1] See the argument in yesterdays threads about what "man" and "woman" mean, and should dictionaries be changed, etc.
- pastage 5y agoNo this is not new. You have always have a direction set by political views, even if we have decided they are wrong they are still hard to kill like: smoking is good, white people are superior. There is still "science" being done to bolster those political views.
- lelanthran 5y ago>> What's new is that any research that might produce results counter to the what the PC-mob deems acceptable is attacked. > No this is not new. I don't recall a PC-mob being used to silence any and all non-supportive voices until quite recently. > You have always have a direction set by political views, even if we have decided they are wrong they are still hard to kill like: smoking is good, white people are superior. There is still "science" being done to bolster those political views. I don't see what that has to do with that I said - that a very vocal bunch of non-science people seem to have successfully lobbied into silencing specific topics.
- Kye 5y agoGood science defines its terms. Can you unroll "PC-mob" so we're all on the same page here? You don't sound like an asshole, so your meaning is probably not the usual "anything that leans a little left."
- sbilstein 5y agothe “PC mob” might be new but we’ve had mobs of every political, religious, and cultural motivation pressuring academia since it’s invention.
- pessimizer 5y agoThe real problem is that all of those mobs have to answer to the PC mob now. Or at least that's what I hear from people who think that censorship didn't exist until coincidentally around the time of Gamergate.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y ago> I don't recall a PC-mob being used to silence any and all non-supportive voices until quite recently. Are you genuinely serious or were you completely unaware of anti-communist government sanctioned blacklisting of academics suspected of being communist for political clout? Are you unaware of churches excommunicating Galileo for daring to scholarly research into the earth rotating around the sun? Are you unaware of our own Alan Turing, of the Turing award, literally castrated not for his research but because he was a known gay researcher? Are you unaware of why HBSUs exist(black scholars were segregated for being black, their research dismissed because of the race of the researcher)? Politics in academia isn’t new, like, at all.
- lelanthran 5y ago> Are you genuinely serious or were you completely unaware of anti-communist government sanctioned blacklisting of academics suspected of being communist for political clout? Are you unaware of churches excommunicating Galileo for daring to scholarly research into the earth rotating around the sun? Are you unaware of our own Alan Turing, of the Turing award, literally castrated not for his research but because he was a known gay researcher? Are you unaware of why HBSUs exist(black scholars were segregated for being black, their research dismissed because of the race of the researcher)? Every single one of those was NOT a mob. The people in authority, using their authority to push their PoV, is very different to people with no authority forming a mob and demanding that the current authority silence other people from speaking their minds is a very different thing. Whatever your view of the current authority is, it is infinitely better than mob-justice.
- pastage 5y agoGroup think exists in science too, I mean Newton calling Leibniz a copy cat was a set back and it's crazy that I still had to learn about the priority controversy almost 300 years later. We feed on unneccessary controversy.