4 ms·
> For passengers sure, they are slow. They could instead transport cargo. (1) applies triple for cargo, cargo which is fine with slow tends to be heavy. For re
by masklinn 5y ago
> For passengers sure, they are slow. They could instead transport cargo.
(1) applies triple for cargo, cargo which is fine with slow tends to be heavy. For reference, the Hindenburg had under 20 tonnes of useful lift, the ship itself weighted around 200 tonnes dry.
If you're happy with your cargo going under 200km/h, you're probably fine slapping it on a truck or five, or on a train with some point-to-point trucking.
It's hard to fathom how incapable airships are, they really aren't very good as you scale up, the use cases where they have any sort of superiority are extremely limited, leading to a very small market.
They're super ultra cool looking and everything, but their reality is absolutely dreary.
- bombcar 5y agoYeah, for cargo they're absolutely insane - maybe in some rare cases they could replace cargo/heavy lift helicopters - but otherwise they don't have much in the way of advantages.
- Pxtl 5y agoBasically the only scenario I've heard where they might be economical is the arctic, which is frequently impassible for everything but planes. There are few other places where roads or boats have effectiveness reduced to the point where an airship becomes an option.
- bombcar 5y agoThe “economical” would only come into play in potential perfect carbon tax environments from what I understand. Imagine a zeppelin configured like a sailing ship of the skies, designed to travel mainly under wind power and rarely fire its engines
- hutzlibu 5y agoAlso add lightweight solar panels to the hull (they exist as foil already) and you might have something economically in sunny areas.
- usrusr 5y agoThe closest thing to a viable use case for airship cargo is the one Cargolifter was aiming for, getting objects too big for roads to landlocked destinations. And the challenge that comes with that was illustrated quite well by Cargolifter: starting with a small craft and sizing up with experience is impossible because for loads fitting a road ground based transport will always win. (I'm sure that CL160 would have changed the economics of wind power forever, but they were too early for that use case to materialize)