5 ms·
The reality is that airships are kinda crap: 1. they get "free lift" but you need a lot of gas to lift a lot of mass, which quickly makes them extremely unwiel
by masklinn 5y ago
The reality is that airships are kinda crap:
1. they get "free lift" but you need a lot of gas to lift a lot of mass, which quickly makes them extremely unwieldy as it leads to gigantic cross sections (and sheer stuff to move, positioning a lift bag the size of a sports stadium is not exactly great, and requires humongous engines)
2. they're so damn slow
3. even ignoring the tendency to get on fire, hydrogen is a pain in the ass, it absolutely refuses staying put and embrittles structural metals leading to accelerated fatigue
- bombcar 5y agoYeah, they'd likely be best used as "cruise ships in the sky" where they can take advantage of large swaths of empty space (you could have ballrooms in a zeppelin pretty easily as they wouldn't weigh much) and the speed wouldn't be a huge issue. And you'd likely have to make them out of something other than metal, and it would vent hydrogen most of time.
- WalterBright 5y agoI'd love to take a low and slow tour.
- outworlder 5y agoFor passengers sure, they are slow. They could instead transport cargo. I think the biggest problem with them is mooring. It's a complex process, much more so than landing a plane, and requires lots of ground crew. It would have to be automated first.
- masklinn 5y ago> For passengers sure, they are slow. They could instead transport cargo. (1) applies triple for cargo, cargo which is fine with slow tends to be heavy. For reference, the Hindenburg had under 20 tonnes of useful lift, the ship itself weighted around 200 tonnes dry. If you're happy with your cargo going under 200km/h, you're probably fine slapping it on a truck or five, or on a train with some point-to-point trucking. It's hard to fathom how incapable airships are, they really aren't very good as you scale up, the use cases where they have any sort of superiority are extremely limited, leading to a very small market. They're super ultra cool looking and everything, but their reality is absolutely dreary.
- bombcar 5y agoYeah, for cargo they're absolutely insane - maybe in some rare cases they could replace cargo/heavy lift helicopters - but otherwise they don't have much in the way of advantages.
- Pxtl 5y agoBasically the only scenario I've heard where they might be economical is the arctic, which is frequently impassible for everything but planes. There are few other places where roads or boats have effectiveness reduced to the point where an airship becomes an option.
- bombcar 5y agoThe “economical” would only come into play in potential perfect carbon tax environments from what I understand. Imagine a zeppelin configured like a sailing ship of the skies, designed to travel mainly under wind power and rarely fire its engines
- hutzlibu 5y agoAlso add lightweight solar panels to the hull (they exist as foil already) and you might have something economically in sunny areas.
- usrusr 5y agoThe closest thing to a viable use case for airship cargo is the one Cargolifter was aiming for, getting objects too big for roads to landlocked destinations. And the challenge that comes with that was illustrated quite well by Cargolifter: starting with a small craft and sizing up with experience is impossible because for loads fitting a road ground based transport will always win. (I'm sure that CL160 would have changed the economics of wind power forever, but they were too early for that use case to materialize)
- jcrawfordor 5y agoFor large airships, unless stored indoors (which is of course hard because of the size of the structure required) they are essentially permanently in flight. The Goodyear blimps, for example, are followed as they travel by portable (truck-mounted) mooring towers but must have pilots on board 24/7 even when moored, because a modest wind can easily blow the mooring tower over if pilots don't maneuver the ship "on the ground." In high winds mooring is simply impossible and the airships must remain aloft. The logistics of this operation are very complex, and the airship must be able to swing 360 degrees while moored to allow for maneuvering, which requires a huge area. The result is that the Goodyear blimps rely on a pretty limited set of mostly small municipal airports that they have experience with. Closed air force bases are popular since they're most likely to have a far corner of the tarmac that the trucks can easily drive out to but that has no structures or other aircraft use that the airship would interfere with. The Goodyear website has a picture that gives you a good idea of what this looks like: https://www.goodyearblimp.com/behind-the-scenes/img/emeablimp.JPG https://www.goodyearblimp.com/behind-the-scenes/img/emeablim... Not pictured is the truck of helium cylinders that accompanies the blimp for top-ups, which are required as I understand it mostly due to leakage, as the pilots carefully avoid venting helium due to the high cost (it's an option for emergencies). Airships are huge and hard to manage.
- WalterBright 5y ago> even ignoring the tendency to get on fire We fly in aluminum balloons filled with jet fuel all the time. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vMZk-cHU6Zk&t=121s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vMZk-cHU6Zk&t=121s We figure out why they catch fire, and fix it. The Hindenburg disaster has straightforward engineering fixes.
- masklinn 5y ago> We fly in aluminum balloons filled with jet fuel all the time. Hydrogen ignites significantly more readily than jet fuel does, and protecting the gigantic volume of an airship's envelope (which is multiple times that of the payload) is a lot harder than protecting a plane's fuel tanks. Not to mention the airship still need fuel tanks to move around, it's not a captive balloon.
- WalterBright 5y agoTake a look again at the video I linked to and try and explain how jet fuel doesn't really catch fire and isn't much of a problem if it does. Preventing an onboard fire is probably the #1 concern of jet designers. Experience has gotten them pretty good at it. Damned good. Amazingly good. But never forget that jet fuel is not safe. It burns. It burns hot. It'll melt everything on an airplane it touches. It'll burn your wing off in seconds. The whole point of jet fuel is it stores a LOT of energy in a very small amount of weight.
- bombcar 5y agoAirlines have gotten amazing good at evacuations, such that I am surprised how well the general public is at them in emergencies. Look at pictures of any crash where everyone (or almost everyone) survived and the fire damage to the plane is frankly astonishing. Hydrogen zeppelins could be designed to nearly perfectly mitigate all fire risk; the real danger is weather related. (Ideas such as hydrogen can’t burn if oxygen isn’t present, fireproof bags, gondola suspended below so fire can’t reach it, emergency evacuation planning for when it does hit the ground, capability of venting, fire suppressions, etc).
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThey're also completely at the mercy of weather to a degree almost no other aircraft is.
- bombcar 5y agoHot air balloons say hi. ;)
- jeffreyrogers 5y agoIt embrittles steel, but not aluminum at the temperature/pressure it would be used at for this sort of application.