6 ms·
Google Play bans call-recording apps
- Abdelkader014 5y ago
- kevincox 5y agoCall recording apps have always barely worked, or worked on some phones. While the new policy is the nail in the coffin (for Play Store distribution) Android has always been incredibly hostile towards them. Of course most custom ROMs have a "record" button in the default dialer app. I used to run stock Android from Google but it has gotten clear that they don't want me to use my phone. I can't access the data of my apps and this pushed me to switch to LineageOS months ago. Now they take this away and my position is validated.
- sodality2 5y agoI've used this for over a year with no issues: https://f-droid.org/packages/com.github.axet.callrecorder/ https://f-droid.org/packages/com.github.axet.callrecorder/
- notRobot 5y agoMe too! I installed it through the Magisk module, and it works flawlessly.
- registeredcorn 5y agoHow difficult would you rank the experience of getting rid of stock Android for a non-programmer? I'm technically skilled enough to work in the industry, but hate reading and occasionally make stupid mistakes. Is it an involved many hours long process, or pretty straightforward? Any downsides? Problems sending sending/recieving calls or texts? I'd still need to maintain access to some apps, like Bitwarden and a few authenticators. I don't mind jumping through one or two hoops upfront, but if it's a constant problem it'd get old fast. I really want to be able to record calls if I feel the need to do so. This change is completely unacceptable to me. I've already moved away from Windows/OSX to Fedora for similar arbitrary, user-hostile actions. It sounds like its about time to do the same with my phone, regrettably. Technology has become a tedious thing. It's supposed to help the public in the ways that they want, not to be decided for them, where the only correct means is approved or denied by some faceless mush of "approvers". I feel a lot of the spirit of the early technologists has been lost with these authoritarian corporatists. It's incredibly frustrating to see such a good thing ground into the mud by these thugs in hoodies.
- hedora 5y agoIf you have a pixel, installing grapheneos isnt too bad. I did it via the cli because I'm a luddite, but the webpage based installer is apparently fine. (Assuming you can also figure out how to install chrome.)
- kevincox 5y agoIn general it isn't that hard LineageOS has fairly clear guides. The main hitch is Google's Safety Net. Some apps want to validate that you are using a "trustworthy" OS. Of course by "trustworthy" they mean "obeys Google, not the user" Depending on the phone you can spoof it but it is more complex and a cat-and-mouse game. Currently it is working for me even with Google Pay but it is surely only a matter of time until they require hardware attestation which will be basically impossible to fake. Of course while Google is the enabler here, the real problem is the apps. They shouldn't care what OS I used and shouldn't check. I just avoid the apps other than Google Pay which check (not that I've seen any yet other than an old bank).
- fsflover 5y agoAnother argument to escape Google and Apple and consider GNU/Linux phones (Librem 5 and Pinephone), where nobody will dictate what software you run.
- tapoxi 5y agoAndroid allows for alternative stores, like F-Droid. I would love to see those phones take off, but at the very least they'd need great Android runtime support.
- olyjohn 5y agoI'd love to, but I can't find an open source phone that does WiFi calling. And with no cell service at my house, it's a necessity. I can't find femtocells anymore, especially ones that work with my MVNO. I even bought a PinePhone, but it's just sitting in a drawer because I can't use anything but Android or iOS hardware.
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoWouldn't a femtocell for your "actual carrier" work with your MVNO? Like for me, I'm on Red Pocket Mobile using Verizon service. Would a Verizon femtocell block Red Pocket subscribers? Verizon signal boosters work fine with my phone. As far as I can tell, anywhere/anyhow a Verizon phone has service, my phone will have service too.
- olyjohn 5y agoHmm... I might have to look into this more. But back in the day when I had an AT&T femtocell, it was still tied into my account, and I had to 'allow' phones to connect to it. And it looks kinda like the T-mobile CellSpot also has to tie to your account so that you can set up e911 addresses. But it does say that anybody within range can jump on it, so MVNO might work on it. Maybe the way around this is a cheap pre-paid t-mo hotspot plan or something just to get it set up. Thanks for the suggestion. https://www.t-mobile.com/support/coverage/4g-lte-cellspot-setup-and-help#address https://www.t-mobile.com/support/coverage/4g-lte-cellspot-se...
- pestatije 5y agoAny suggestions for call-recording apps outside the Google Play garden?
- pontifier 5y agoI use a rooted phone and a call recorder in magisk. It's been the only way I've found to record reliably since the last recorder I used stopped working.
- skybrian 5y agoI haven't tried it, but it looks like Zoom will record calls on desktop for free, or do "cloud recording" if you pay.
- sodality2 5y agohttps://f-droid.org/packages/com.github.axet.callrecorder/ https://f-droid.org/packages/com.github.axet.callrecorder/
- klyrs 5y agoThe default phone app on LineageOS has a native call-record button.
- 1MachineElf 5y agoSorry average person, but only tech oligopolies may record your calls. /s
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hedora 5y agoI once had rocket mortgage lie to me and as a result screw up my credit rating. They said they do it to other people all the time because they don't adequately train their agents, but they weren't going to remove the error from my credit report, despite the fact that they're required to by law. I could have probably hired a lawyer, but the damages were reasonably well bounded. Anyway, they are incompetent crooks that record calls, then won't use the resulting proof they screwed up to correct mistakes, even when it would cost them nothing. I wish my phone autorecorded every call where the other side said it might be recording the call.
- ncann 5y agoUnder the guise of privacy, Android has been increasingly more and more user hostile with every new version. They removed access to external storage, only to relent to the backlash and have it back later under a special permission because, surprise, there are perfectly valid use cases for needing access to external storage like a file manager, or a backup manager. They removed access to clipboard for background process, despite the fact there are perfectly valid use cases for that like clipboard manager, or dictionary app. They kept restricting voice recording for years, and now pretty much just kill it. All of these should just have been locked behind permissions. Require adb access to grant the permission if you want, deny access to the App store if using the permission if you want, I don't care, as long as there is an option to do it for power user. I hate how my device keeps getting more and more closed like Apple. I hate having a powerful personal computing device being crippled by nonsensical software decisions from the big G overlord.
- car_analogy 5y ago> my device It's Google's device. You just pay for it.
- KSPAtlas 5y agoHave you flashed a ROM yet?
- kevinslashslash 5y ago> deny access to the App store if using the permission if you want, I don't care, as long as there is an option to do it for power user. That's what the article is about. It's a policy change.
- ncann 5y agoIn this particular case yes, but we're not always that lucky, and I'm not surprised if they will completely remove the API in the near future.
- KSPAtlas 5y ago
- zikohh 5y agoSo recently Truecaller added the ability to record calls on the device. Each time you call someone a little bubble appears asking if you want to record the call. I wonder if such a popular app will be taken down
- tintedfireglass 5y agoI hope that Spyware is removed once and for all
- pavel_lishin 5y agoWhy does the Phone app only allow recording in India?
- theduder99 5y agoI wonder if mobile carriers could offer recording as an additional service.
- hotpotamus 5y agoI remember back in the day, my mom had a little suction cup microphone thing for recording calls that stuck directly to the phone. I have to think the analog loophole would still work in this case.
- jcynix 5y agoExecutive summary: I simply will use a second smartphone to record things going on on my primary smartphone if needed (and legal, of course). So Google, what does this restriction deliver besides frustration? I moved from IOS to Android some years ago because of Apple's restrictive policies. And I enjoy apps like Termux which allow me to actually use a Smartphone as a computer, e.g. rsyncing ma data to and from a device, or using tools like ImageMagick or Exiftool. And one of my smartphones (a Xiaomi device, controlled by Netguard to limit data leakage ;-) even allows me to easily produce neat movies of things happening on the screen. And I dislike these arbitrary limiations of a Smartphones usability. I do understand and accept, actually like, that apps have to ask for various permissions. But I cannot understand why companies think people are too stupid to somehow circumvent suchbrestrictions? Same for apps which disallow screenshots. Ask me for permission, even every time a screenshot is requested, because I can use another device to get the screenshot anyway, like it or not Google.
- mrandish 5y ago> "Google has said in the past it would prefer if the accessibility APIs were only used by apps meant for people with disabilities" Google and Apple make all users of their phone platforms "disabled" thru draconian policy restrictions. Does that mean all users qualify because we've had our abilities limited?
- perryizgr8 5y agoEven headphone left/right balance setting is in the accessibility section. Does that mean I'm abusing the feature since I'm not hard of hearing or anything like that, just my left speaker is a bit quieter.
- dataangel 5y agoThis is such an idiotic decision, there are a million legitimate reasons to want to record your own calls that have nothing to do with disability. Is there working call recording functionality on iPhone? Tired of every fucking Android update just being worse.
- olyjohn 5y agoIt's just like on MacOS. Why do I need to give my apps "accessiblity" to be able to share my screen? That doesn't even make sense to a tech person, let alone the average person. I think the permissions are pointless anyways. Average person just clicks "allow" on everything without reading it anyways. And it just annoys the fuck out of me. App developers keep working around the limitations... Are these granular permissions really helping anybody? I thought all the apps in the stores were vetted and safe to use!
- kderbyma 5y agoSafe just means safe for apples wallet.