5 ms·
Congratulations on the launch! I wonder if this kind of business model, where it looks like there is basically "one really rich guy self-funding" for a couple o
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
Congratulations on the launch! I wonder if this kind of business model, where it looks like there is basically "one really rich guy self-funding" for a couple of years, is going to be more common.
That is, just looking at the site, my guess is that building everything from the ground up (core banking stack, acquiring the chartered bank, then all the APIs and tech on top of that) must have taken many years and many, many millions of dollars. And kudos, because the first thing that struck out at me is the documentation looks excellent. Overall, it looks like something where the the team had all the luxury to "do things right from the ground floor", instead of scrambling and making shortcuts before their runway ran out. I just think it would have been very hard to find a VC willing to be patient enough to wait that long with no revenue or customer feedback ("where's your MVP???")
- vasco 5y ago> must have taken many years and many, many millions of dollars I don't have any inside knowledge, and obviously you can burn many millions even with a small team but: "We started building Column in 2019 and launched in 2022." [0] "We’re only six engineers (seven if you count me…but I’m a weekend code pusher)" [1] [0] https://column.com/company/ https://column.com/company/ [1] https://column.com/blog/hiring-at-column/ https://column.com/blog/hiring-at-column/
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoYeah, agreed, it looks like they are very efficient. But I'm very familiar with the Bank as a Service space, and your data points very much prove my point: 1. The reason so many BaaS companies partner with existing banks is because the process of getting a bank charter is incredibly time consuming and expensive. There are tons of costs just in legal/compliance before you've even done anything. I'm not 100% clear if Column bought an existing chartered bank or got a new charter, but either route is millions right off the get go. 2. As you point out, they were at 3 years from founding to launch. That's an eternity in the VC-funded startup world. Most startups have an initial MVP in a ~6 month time frame.
- hef19898 5y ago>> Bank as a Service So, banking?
- avianlyric 5y agoNot quite. BaaS just provides the banking rails. The ability the send, receive and store money. But it’s up to their customers to build actual products on top of it. Such as bank accounts, loans etc. Otherwise all you really have is a REST API that happens to be able to move money. But good luck getting your average consumer to pay for that.
- hef19898 5y agoAnd who's owning the banking license in that case? Because to me that sounds a lot like, well, banking. And wasn't aware that the ability to move money from one account to another is actually a big issue. And if it's just the software banks use, well, they already use it, don't they?
- avianlyric 5y agoBanking licence is owned by the BaaS company, and they allow others to borrow it when using their platform. The companies building on top of a BaaS are not banks. They’re fintechs building products like privacy.com, or something else. Moving money between accounts at the same bank is obviously trivial. I’m talking about the ability to move money to other financial institutions via card payments, wire transfers or whatever.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThe diagram on Column's homepage (scroll down a bit to "our advantage") explains it quite well. There are a bunch of banking-as-a-service middleware providers like Galileo, Treasury Prime, Unit, Synapse etc. who provide nice, easy-to-use APIs for things like opening a bank account, sending an ACH, provisioning a debit card, etc. Doing these things "on your own" can be incredibly difficult, e.g. the NACHA rules around sending and receiving ACH files are incredibly complex. These companies do NOT own a bank charter. Instead, these companies partner with lots of different banks that DO have a bank charter and integrate with their "core banking" systems (core banking systems usually run on mainframes and are provided by companies like Fiserv). Then, fintechs like Chime you want to provide banking services to their clients can focus on the "user facing" part of the experience and less on the difficult, nitty-gritty parts of the banking stack. What Column has done is consolidate the roles of the middleware provided, core banking system and chartered bank into a single company so there are fewer middlemen to take a cut.
- abirch 5y agoI think many starts ups are "rich people" self funding (or are parental funded). For instance Microsoft and Bill Gate's and Paul Allen's helped them out a lot. Ditto with Mark Zuckerberg, Elon Musk's Tesla & Space X, Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway. You'll notice everyone aforementioned attended an Ivy League university.
- WJW 5y agoAt the very least Berkshire Hathaway is an odd example to be pointing out as a "self funded startup". Warren Buffett was an apprentice under Benjamin Graham for several years, operated several businesses beforehand to make his first millions and acquired the (heavily failing at the time) textile operations of Berkshire Hathaway around 1962, when Berkshire was already over a hundred years old.
- recuter 5y agoHe raised a couple million (inflation adjusted) from family and friends, starting with an old auntie. And taking over the textile operation of Berkshire Hathaway almost bankrupted him :) The Buffet we think of today really emerged with meeting Charlie Munger.
- _lqaf 5y ago> "rich people" self funding [...] Elon Musk Who took ~$5 billion and counting from the government...
- kurthr 5y agoIBM... Oracle... Palantir much more so, I mean Tesla figured out how to sell EV credits (that were intended for the Big 3), but SpaceX only recently got government funding after crushing all the competition by their bootstraps. It seems like Elon got his early money from parents and Paypal not the government. I do however notice a general trend of seeing Libertarians on the dole.
- mschuster91 5y ago
- Animats 5y agoacquiring the chartered bank They seem to have bought Northern California National Bank in Chico, CA.[1] The Column web site doesn't mention it, but they still have a physical branch in Chico. The FDIC gives their web site as "norcalbank.com", although it does show the name change to Column. Their site has no street address and "domain name only" TLS certificate from Amazon, so you don't really know for sure that column.com is connected to a real bank. The terms[2] are very unfavorable to the customer, especially for a business which claims to be a real bank. "THE MAXIMUM AGGREGATE LIABILITY OF BANK AND ITS AFFILIATES, AND ITS AND THEIR LICENSORS AND SERVICE PROVIDERS, FOR ALL DAMAGES, LOSSES, AND CAUSES OF ACTION, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE) OR OTHERWISE, WILL BE TEN U.S. DOLLARS ($10.00)." There's an arbitration clause, and they demand to use JAMS, which is not as well thought of as the American Arbitration Association. "To reduce the time and expense of the arbitration, the arbitrator will not provide a statement of reasons for his or her award unless requested to do so by all Parties." This is about the level of legitimacy one sees with the typical crypto operation. If you lose money through an error at their end, they don't have much of an incentive to fix the problem. [1] https://banks.data.fdic.gov/bankfind-suite/bankfind/details/58224 https://banks.data.fdic.gov/bankfind-suite/bankfind/details/... [2] https://column.com/api-terms-of-service https://column.com/api-terms-of-service
- patentatt 5y agoBanking is highly regulated at both the state and federal levels, it astounds me that they're able to have such a blatantly consumer hostile clause in their terms. Either this is plainly unenforceable (which happens and companies do all the time), or it is illegal and will get them a fat fine (seems unlikely though), or we live in a dystopian-Randian hellscape (most likely).
- MaxMoney 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sentientslug 5y ago