3 ms·
> rigorous one-year study in which people followed a low-calorie diet between the hours of 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. or consumed the same number of calories anytime dur
by loeg 5y ago
> rigorous one-year study in which people followed a low-calorie diet between the hours of 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. or consumed the same number of calories anytime during the day has failed to find an effect.
Duh? The reasonable mechanism of action for IF is that it's a tool to consume less calories.
If the study's IF group is eating the same number of calories as the control group as part of the study design, this is the expected result.
> “These results indicate that caloric intake restriction explained most of the beneficial effects seen with the time-restricted eating regimen,” Dr. Weiss and his colleagues concluded.
Yeah! That is the whole point.
> when subjected to a properly designed and conducted study — scientific investigation — [IF] is not any more helpful than simply reducing daily calorie intake for weight loss and health factors.
Yeah! People struggle to "simply reduce daily caloric intake," though.
- nabla9 5y ago> Duh? The reasonable mechanism of action for IF is that it's a tool to consume less calories. That's not the only reasonable mechanism. Even with the same calorie intake, there are other suggested mechanisms. For example altering glucose metabolism, shift from lipid synthesis to the using of of fat and other effects related to breaking body weight homeostasis.
- rubyskills 5y agoAlso there are some theories that spiking mTor less frequently is better. Some interesting research being doing on sirtuins and their role in repair of systems as well, especially in a fasted state.
- simiones 5y agoWhile I always suspected this result to be true, there are many extraordinary claims about the importance of fasting with scientistic explanations (I've seen claims that it works because of different insulin levels, ketosis, blood sugar effects etc.). So, this study at least puts some of these ideas to rest (if it can be replicated of course, which is not necessarily a given in nutrition "science").
- treyfitty 5y agoThis study was merely a step in validating and adding credibility to "yeah, calories in-calories out is still the most important factor in determining weight and other health markers." The complexity of the human body shouldn't be turn into something trivial, as your comment suggests. There's a lot of people that studied/studies how the complex web of neurons impact health and well-being, and they added value to the literature. Let's not trivialize the exploration and appreciation into how complex the human body is.
- zackees 5y ago