7 ms·
Bill Ackman loses $400M dumps entire Netflix stake after just 3 months
- nodemaker 5y agoMoral of the story is that even billionaries have paper hands!
- anothernewdude 5y agoI don't think they see a possible recovery for Netflix here.
- francisofascii 5y agoIt is that? Or maybe they discovered whatever model they had setup for Netflix was flawed, and they just decided to dump it and move on.
- formerkrogemp 5y agoMost valuations these days are predicated upon market sentiment, low interest rates, rapid growth, and forecasts into future cash flow growth. Should any of these crash into reality, the proverbial faeces hit the fan, and the valuations disappears like the smoke and mirrors they are. Nothing grows 20% YoY forever. It's all unicorn farts and VC pixie dust powering these high flying valuations.
- francisofascii 5y agoSure, many companies have this problem. But does Netflix? They have been making a profit for quite some time. They PE ratio is 20, which is not high compared to other companies. Do they need to grow to be profitable? If they can cut costs a bit and stabilize subscription levels, they should be fine. What am I missing?
- formerkrogemp 5y agoThe growth is baked into the valuation. I don't disagree with your ideas, but so much is built on perception. Share prices fall. Capital becomes more expensive. Options aren't worth as much. Employee morale drops. Profit isn't the only or main measure of success these days, which is unfortunate. As a long term shareholder, I'd be somewhat concerned about their ability to compete and deliver, but I'd be fine with their current profit levels. Not at current valuations however.
- Melting_Harps 5y ago> Moral of the story is that even billionaries have paper hands! To be perfectly fair, this level of volatility is not even seen in BTC anymore, wow! You have to go to the super leveraged exit scam alts to see a 62% drop. For all this talk about stability being critical to the health of the established markets, this really is egg on the face when a FAANG has taken such losses on a service which they have this much market-share on in comparison to the rest of the Industry. Netflix's share price peaked in November 2021 and is about 62% lower year-to-date.
- thoughtstheseus 5y agoFalse. Many not scammy businesses decline 62% in YTD figures. The decline potential is obvious… Netflix has enormous operating leverage, which Bill mentions in his official note. Operating leverage magnifies the impact of marginal subscribers.
- bavell 5y agoLol how many $100B+ market cap businesses decline 60%+ in 6 months? Parent's point is that this is unheard of for an established player and makes stability of FAANG look really bad.
- thoughtstheseus 5y agoNot many because they have not been around very long. I’d guess few of them would be old enough to drink alcohol in the US. It wasn’t until ~2000 companies started to cross the $100 billion market cap threshold.
- bavell 5y agoSure, but don't get hung up on the $100B number. The overall point being made is that FAANG is seen as a rock of stability compared to crypto and yet has experienced massive price change over a relatively short amount of time. The point of mentioning the market cap is that you'd expect volatility to be very low. Just shows you that the stability is not quite as stable as previously assumed.
- moralestapia 5y agoYup, its clear that NFLX is on a rough patch but I'm sure they'll recover. This feels like a rookie mistake.
- ncmncm 5y agoSeems like he can afford it. Won't miss any meals, anyway.
- thoughtstheseus 5y agoIt’s not his money.
- theknocker 5y ago
- jqpabc123 5y agoIf you make big bets you have to be willing to accept big loses.
- twomoonsbysurf 5y ago
- kumarvvr 5y agoThe netflix story is beginning to turn, and not just because of Elon or password sharing crackdowns. Anyone can see that the other players have caught up, and their brand does not seem to have that pull anymore, especially when paired against the likes of Disney, Marvel, DC, HBO, etc. Their content has a lot more competition, and the pandemic has altered the dynamics of streaming. I guess most households have at least a couple of streaming subscriptions if not more, and dropping off NF is easier, especially against rising prices and restrictions on sharing. Now, they have to fight head on with the big studios who have a whole ecosystem with them. I frankly wonder why anyone would invest in NF at this juncture. I would expect subscriber growth to taper off, and their pricing flexibility is limited due to competition. Also, price sensitivity for streaming seems to be particularly high, perhaps amplified by social media. Atleast with the cable TV, you get hundreds of channels. Now, the fatigue of selecting content is very real. Also, the algorithms are crap on NF.
- tinus_hn 5y agoIs it really surprising that a service that gained tons of subscribers due to lockdowns loses a lot of them again once the lockdowns end?
- Mindwipe 5y agoThey didn't even really lose them, Netflix gained subscribers if you exclude Russia.
- gdulli 5y agoNot accounting for Russia they'd still have been 2 million subscribers short of the forecast of 2.5 million subscribers. And they're forecasting a loss of 2 million more in Q2, which makes the loss of 200k in Q1 look small.
- mattbrewsbytes 5y agoNetflix's core competency was the best distribution (DVD by mail then streaming) and not the best content. Their competitors can beat them on content because that's their competency, distribution is commoditized at this point. This is an example where they were ahead of the industry with distribution and now that their competitors have invested in infrastructure/distribution, supply chain (movie/show production takes time), marketing, and have competing products the competition is fierce when your price is the highest. Now replace Netflix with Tesla and this could be the same case in the automobile market in a 3-5 year span. Market leader because they lead the industry in one element but once that tech (batteries/EV/charging network) is commoditized, the market leader could suffer.
- pizzaknife 5y agofor the record, i absolutely loath needing 3+ subscriptions to streaming content providers AND a delivery bill (internets) just to enjoy what comes out to 5 or 6 "shows/movies" a month. No, I do not have a reasonable solution, just griping
- mark_l_watson 5y agoI hear you. We have 5 streaming services, and my wife enjoys them all. I have experimented with just buying movies on Google Play and Amazon Prime, and a few series on Apple TV. If it was just me in our household, I would go this route. I have recently retired and I expected to spend more time watching streaming content but the opposite has happened. I find reading, walking, or sitting outside feels like a better use of my time. EDIT: if people pay for Amazon Prime for the shipping, then just using Prime content augmented with buying content otherwise unavailable seems like a good plan.
- moistly 5y agoMaybe rotate through the services on a quarterly schedule? Cut your costs to a fifth of what they are now?
- mark_l_watson 5y agoI have mentioned that possibility to my wife. I am well off financially, but I am frugal. I love my local library.
- formerkrogemp 5y agoAre SaaS and internet subscription companies in general in a bubble due to low interest rates?
- McLaren_Ferrari 5y agoEverything is in a bubble due to low interest rates. Doesn't matter how big or powerful a company is, it's simply no match for the US Government as far as investment risk is concerned.
- formerkrogemp 5y agoHere's the real money question. What happens to all of our startups when the bubble compresses?
- specialist 5y agoFWIW, Noob me assumed Netflix's streaming biz had plateaued once they entered the video games biz. How'd that biz strategy meeting go? You're getting crowded out of the market for your core biz. So you decide to enter a more crowded, more competitive market, for which you have no history or culture. Grow or die, right? Too bad there's not an option for "That was a fun ride. Thanks everyone. We're switching from being a growth stock to paying dividends."
- eigenvalue 5y agoI have found the vast majority of Netflix's original content from the last couple years to be pretty much uniformly awful. I really don't know why I have stayed a subscriber given that I almost never watch it and already have Amazon Prime Video "for free" and also YouTube Premium (which btw is a much, much better value proposition in my book than Netflix at this point). I think it's mostly inertia and the fact that it's not that much money. I suspect many others are in the same boat, and the company is really playing with fire by messing around with big % price increases and password sharing crackdowns. When inertia is your friend, you shouldn't do anything to rock the boat!
- AdrianB1 5y agoIn what way is the content awful? I had a subscription 4-5 years ago that I cancelled due to very bad client support, but the content was quite decent. All I hear from people that still have Netflix is that the content is bad, when I ask in what way most people tell it turned very political/PC. One of the most viral pictures in my area a few weeks ago was photoshopped movie poster "A Netflix original" with "Zelens'kjy" as movie name and a black guy with a M16 as the main character. Is this a thing?
- anony999 5y ago>> One of the most viral pictures in my area a few weeks ago was photoshopped movie poster "A Netflix original" with "Zelens'kjy" as movie name and a black guy with a M16 as the main character. I would not be surprised to see a netflix remake of the original movie just like that. Perhaps the main character would also have a more "diverse" sexual orientation. It's really that all the movies I've watched recently on netflix play the same note. They seem to produce movies just to tick some boxes.
- lp0_on_fire 5y agoI do believe that their original catalog has gotten very political and PC over the years but my largest complaint is that most of their originals now (with a few exceptions) are very formulaic and just not not written well. They're falling into that same trap milking of certain shows to their illogical conclusion while cancelling others for seemingly no reason beyond it wasn't an _instant_ hit. With people having been stuck indoors for the past two years it's unsurprising that formulaic, poorly-written, message-driven content isn't keeping them in front of their screens.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- michelb 5y agoWhy would he take this loss? Why not wait it out and sell when it gets a bit higher again?