5 ms·
What I don't get is why enabling 3rd party extensions is somehow more dangerous on arm macs than on x86 macs...
by nottorp 5y ago
What I don't get is why enabling 3rd party extensions is somehow more dangerous on arm macs than on x86 macs...
- mrkwse 5y agoIt's a strange shift and one I've fallen into the trap of. Discord requires kernel extensions for screen sharing and requires the reduced security toggle as a result. I've gladly used screen sharing in the past with presumably the same mechanisms, and not thought twice about it. Yet for some reason I'm hesitant to reduce the security of my main personal machine, even if that 'reduction' results in a consistent level of security with my old 2015 x64 MacBook. The reality is that I probably need to go and determine if there are a greater volume of more prevalent kernel level exploits to figure out what the factor of risk really is - it may be that these features are exploited more regularly and to greater effect than they were in 2015.
- saagarjha 5y ago> Discord requires kernel extensions for screen sharing and requires the reduced security toggle as a result. Are you sure? There are several userspace APIs to do this so a kext would be very concerning and, quite frankly, inappropriate for this usecase.
- Y-bar 5y agoIt's an Electron limitation (because of course it is): > [...] does not work on macOS for audio capture due to a fundamental limitation whereby apps that want to access the system's audio require a signed kernel extension. Chromium, and by extension Electron, does not provide this. https://www.electronjs.org/docs/latest/api/desktop-capturer#caveats https://www.electronjs.org/docs/latest/api/desktop-capturer#...
- moron4hire 5y agoHow does Chrome on its own do it?
- d3nj4l 5y agoDiscord only requires this for sharing audio along with screen sharing - I've shared my screen with the Discord app several times before without audio and I've never installed the kext. And, at any rate, the kext they want you to install is the same one Rogue Amoeba uses for their well known and widely used app, Audio Hijack. Discord licenses it from them; they mention it in the dialogue that prompts you to install it.
- nottorp 5y agoThis is another topic: "why you should learn to do a native app" :)
- nottorp 5y ago> it may be that these features are exploited more regularly and to greater effect than they were in 2015. It's not like you allow any kernel extension to run, do you? You still have to approve each of them manually. Atm I have two usb-serial adapters with different chipsets hanging off the x86 mac mini plus an Arduino that comes with its own usb serial. Is that possible on arm macs?
- GeekyBear 5y agoARM Macs have a new security feature we haven't seen previously. They are built to resist attackers who have physical access to the hardware. https://twitter.com/XenoKovah/status/1425800637166596101 https://twitter.com/XenoKovah/status/1425800637166596101
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- legalcorrection 5y agoThis tweet has made the rounds, but it’s wrong in its claims about Secure Boot. Your claim that protection against physical presence is novel to ARM Apple devices is also mistaken. See my comments in a previous thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30738720 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30738720 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30738679 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30738679 Extracting the relevant bits and cleaning them up: Macs/iOS devices and PCs—through the Secure Enclave and TPM/Secure Boot/Bitlocker, respectively—offer really good protection against physical access attacks. They verify the integrity of boot components and are only able to decrypt the system volume if they detect an untampered boot chain. Further, they can lock down direct memory access to protect powered-on systems from bypasses to user authentication. This is why nowadays, if a thief steals your laptop and you had the hard drive encryption with hardware security features on (on Windows, if you set up with a Microsoft Account, this is enabled without any further action by the user), you can feel fairly secure that even a technically savvy thief cannot access your data. And: This tweet is wrong when it claims that Secure Boot does not protect against physical presence attacks. This misunderstands the point of Secure Boot. Secure Boot can indeed be disabled, but that will change the TPM PCR values, so assuming a standard BitLocker configuration, the TPM will fail to unlock the BitLocker key. So if you try to disable Secure Boot on such a machine, you will be unable to boot or otherwise access that volume (even with another machine) unless you have the BitLocker recovery key.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- GeekyBear 5y ago
- gumby 5y agoI don't think that's the reason. It's simply that with an essentially clean room platform, Apple has the opportunity to harden the security. While with the existing Intel platform, people are used to doing certain things that Apple didn't want to break. Apple still sells models with Intel CPUs. People who buy them presumably don't want their existing workflow to break, and are willing to buy an old generation of CPU to get that.