5 ms·
If electricity is cheaper to generate when the sun is shining, the retail price of electricity should reflect that. In fact, the retail price should fluctuate m
by WalterBright 5y ago
If electricity is cheaper to generate when the sun is shining, the retail price of electricity should reflect that. In fact, the retail price should fluctuate minute by minute, so that demand can be shaped to match supply.
Trying to match variable supply to a fixed retail electric rate is certain to cause energy gluts and shortages.
For example, I'd be happy to charge my electric car during price minima, heat the electric water heater to the max when power is cheap, and run the A/C to the cold end of comfort when electrons are plentiful.
- elcomet 5y agoThis makes prices unpredictable, and I think it's a bad thing. You cannot plan when you can charge your car. Why not have just two prices which are predictable (one day and one night for example) ?
- WalterBright 5y agoThe price of pump gas changes every day. Is that a bad thing? I'm old enough to remember when pump gas was regulated. Two things happened - gluts and shortages, at the same time! This all ended abruptly when Reagan signed his first Executive Order to repeal all that nonsense.
- elcomet 5y agoEvery day, not every minute. And the office does not change while you are buying it.
- robbiep 5y agoThe wholesale price does fluctuate minute by minute. The grid and the average consumer/retail user is not yet sophisticated to take advantage of what you propose. We know this because until recently, this ‘ideal situation’ that you propose was available by a company called Griddy, that went balls up when their consumers got absolutely slammed during the Texas snowstorms, and the idea of having the wholesale price if you’re a retail consumer became a very very silly idea
- WalterBright 5y agoOh, I know about the Texas example. It wasn't the concept that was bad, it was the implementation. The implementation needs to be coupled with meters where you can set a max price you'll accept. Any system where you sign a contract that says you'll pay any price to turn on a lamp is idiotic, and so are the people who sign such contracts. (The wholesale prices fluctuation does little to affect demand, because the demand is on the retail price, which is fixed.)
- midasuni 5y agoWhen it’s dark people turn on the lights. When it’s cold they turn on the heating. Those are the drivers of demand. Industrial demand (aluminium smelters etc) are more price sensitive, but they tend to be billed by the minute anyway. some “residential” people will be happy to turn off their Bitcoin or weed growing equipment when the price rises but that shouldnt be residential. The wealthy will have their own storage systems to smooth out the bumps and thus spend less than those who are poorer. You may like that idea, but for most people this would be devestating and less to more deaths.
- WalterBright 5y agoEvery house has many energy-hungry devices that can time shift their use. 1. electric car battery recharging 2. hot water heater - heat it to the max of the range when electricity is cheap 3. A/C - cool it to the coldest end of the range when electricity is cheap and so on. 1,2,3 are just the start of what can be done, cheaply, to shape demand to the price. > devestating People adjust their use of gasoline based on the constantly shifting prices. This is how demand is shaped to match supply.
- mschuster91 5y ago> People adjust their use of gasoline based on the constantly shifting prices. This is how demand is shaped to match supply. Yeah, but unlike electricity gas can be stored efficiently and long term - your typical 5-series BMW has ~60l of tank volume, a Ford F150 has ~90-100l, not to mention jerry cans. That means when gas is expensive, a consumer usually can choose to simply fill up the tank at another date.
- tomp 5y ago> If electricity is cheaper to generate when the sun is shining, the retail price of electricity should reflect that. This would be amazing. It would quickly turn the population off further investment in solar and other unreliable, unpredictable sources of energy and prove that nuclear is the only viable green power.
- pydry 5y agoExcept in the UK where it's called octopus and electric car drivers love it.
- WalterBright 5y agoWe pay variable prices for gasoline every day, mainly due to unpredictable supply. Society hasn't collapsed.
- DocTomoe 5y agoAnd we would happily change to another system if it provided long-term price stability.
- WalterBright 5y agoYou'd be happy, but that happiness would fade after not too long. It was tried in the US in the 1970s, and produced long gas lines, shortages, and gluts. It's what always happens when the government engages in price fixing and supply fixing.
- DocTomoe 5y agoYou mean like OPEC? Also, I did not even mention price or supply fixing: prices can be stable for reasons outside governmental and/or monopolistic-evildoer's direct control.
- WalterBright 5y agoI meant Nixon's price and allocation controls he imposed on gas. The proof that the lines were not OPEC's doing is the moment Reagan repealed those controls, the gas lines disappeared and never came back. And I mean the moment. Gas lines one day, gone the next.
- wcoenen 5y agoThese are called "time of use tariffs". Here in Belgium this type of tariff is marketed under the name "dynamic tariff". (It's only offered by the biggest player Engie, but other companies are working on it.) The price varies hourly, but it is determined by the day-ahead electricity market so the price schedule for the day is known the evening before.
- WalterBright 5y agoIt's a good approximation. But renewable power generation is affected by the weather, and the weather is not predictable. The price should change minute by minute. Of course, this implies people having internet-connected hot water heaters, car chargers, etc., which are hardly expensive.
- Symbiote 5y agoThe weather across all of Europe (which is relevant for the pricing) is reasonably predictable.
- WalterBright 5y agoCan it predict a day in advance every time the sun goes behind a cloud?
- Symbiote 5y agoI didn't think of that (not much solar power in Denmark...) but my feeling is that it isn't really relevant on the scale of a country -- clouds move across many PV sites, covering one panel as they uncover the adjacent one. The graphs at the start of this paper show fluctuations on 9 PV power plans in a 50km square, 49 plants in a 250km square, and 225 plants in a 500km square. https://solargis2-web-assets.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/public/publication/2014/7e83f59297/Suri-et-al-SASEC2014-Cloud-cover-impact-on-PV-power-production-in-South-Africa.pdf https://solargis2-web-assets.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/publ...
- Symbiote 5y agoHere's the price for my residential electricity in Denmark for the next 24 hours: https://i.imgur.com/EER7bMP.png https://i.imgur.com/EER7bMP.png The light part of the graph is transport costs and taxes. I think the price moves within a range -- I'm protected from enormous spikes, but I also won't see the price go negative. This is a standard tariff, there are other options for people owning electric cars. There's also an app to show this information, and (I assume) a way to tell the car to charge at the cheapest time in next few hours.
- WalterBright 5y agoIt's a good start, but still an approximation. I bet it makes a significant difference, and that difference will increase over time as people adapt to it, and buy electrical appliances that automatically adapt to it.
- thow-58d4e8b 5y agoThat's close to the way things work in Europe Pricing for the next day is decided on the spot market, around 2-3 PM. All large consumers and producers place bids on one-hour slots until the market clears. Prices do not fluctuate minute-to-minute, but hour-to-hour. Consumers might opt in to electricity resellers selling spot prices, or get a fixed but usually higher guaranteed price per kWh. All that changes for the end consumer is that your electricity meter readings will be forwarded to a different company
- DocTomoe 5y agoAs an European with a fixed-Euros-per-kWh-contract (with two prices, one for daytime, one for nighttime, the latter being a bit cheaper), I'm curious - which countries allow you to get a contract in which your electricity costs get updated daily?
- juki 5y agoNord Pool covers a large part of Europe: https://www.nordpoolgroup.com/en/maps/#/nordic https://www.nordpoolgroup.com/en/maps/#/nordic Your actual contract would be with some local electric company that uses Nord Pool (or some other provider).
- DocTomoe 5y agoApparently, Nord Pool just is an electricity exchange market - I was aware those existed. I was more asking for a local electric company which changes prices daily (and allows me to know that before so I can adapt). At least in Germany, I am not aware of anyone offering that kind of contract, and I would love to see how that is implemented elsewhere.
- juki 5y agoAt least in Finland pretty much every electric company offers "pörssisähkö" contracts using either hourly or daily prices. Afaik they all provide an app to see the prices, or you can get them directly from Nord Pool. Since German prices are on that map, I assume there are at least some companies doing that in Germany too.
- usrn 5y agoI don't want to live in a place that does that, my power consumption over the course of the day is pretty consistent. We already do that for industrial power consumers how are most capable of changing the time they put load on the grid.
- WalterBright 5y ago> I don't want to live in a place that does that Would you prefer rolling blackouts like California has? Would you prefer paying much higher electricity rates for all those peaker plants and grid storage batteries?
- usrn 5y agoI'd prefer the cheap LNG and nuclear power where I live now. Power cost fluctuating over the course of the day would mean cutting back on critical stuff since I already optimize my power consumption pretty well. Maybe I could cut power to my refrigerator/freezer at night but I prefer having it cold on the small chance that there is a blackout the next day.
- WalterBright 5y agoIt'd mean you could take advantage of cheaper rates to spend overall less money. Fluctuating rates means you'll spend overall less money.
- yazaddaruvala 5y agoThis would definitely work, but would require a big infra adjustment. I don’t know but I wonder if (and it seems likely that) the time arbitrage of electrons is better/simpler (and cheaper?) solved by batteries now or in a few years time.
- WalterBright 5y agoWhat batteries ain't is cheap. Grid scale batteries so you can have a fixed price 24/7 will more than double your electricity bills. If they can be built at all, with their massive need for rare metals.
- yazaddaruvala 5y agoSorry, I don't mean at home batteries. I mean gird scale batteries at production sites to smooth fluctuations in supply, and virtual producers like Tesla in Texas that store power when its cheap and sell when it's expensive to smooth out fluctuations in demand.
- WalterBright 5y agoI specifically talked about grid scale batteries.
- aitchnyu 5y agoAre there any residential water heaters or ACs with "storage" that works till 4 pm and releases at 10pm?
- WalterBright 5y agoI have a conventional water heater, and when a tree falls on the power lines I discovered that the water will remain hot enough for a shower for 3 days. I don't see any problem with heating the water to the max during the day, and you'll be able to enjoy the hot water at night. With your existing heater.
- dpierce9 5y agoRenewables do make electricity cheaper. Here is a highly simplified version of how rates are set: Fixed price = (unit cost + a profit margin) * number of units The fixed price is set for a period of time based on historical and forecasted costs. Which costs are allowed and the profit margin for regulated utilities serving fixed price load is determined by the public service commissions. When their costs go down the regulators will say you can’t charge as much during the next period. Utilities are a natural monopoly and their prices are controlled.
- WalterBright 5y agoThat formula denies how markets work, and gets us high priced electricity and rolling blackouts. Like it or not, supply of electricity with renewables is highly variable. Fixed price electric rates are simply incompatible with that. P.S. Back in the 70's when the DOE allocated gas and set prices, it was simply unable to react to varying gas supplies and demand. The result was gas lines for years until Reagan repealed all that nonsense.
- dpierce9 5y agoThis is in fact how regulated utilities work for fixed rate customers (simplified). The utility charges a customer a rate of x for some period. If the cost during that period is below x the utility may have to lower the price in the next period. If the cost is greater than x they may be able to raise the price in the next period. The exact mechanism for cost-recovery is state-specific and subject to a lot of considerations [0]. Utilities act as wholesale price buffers for retail customers (not commercial users) but the costs are eventually paid. None of this denies how economics works or that solar and wind are variable. [0] https://emp.lbl.gov/sites/all/files/lbnl-1005742_1.pdf https://emp.lbl.gov/sites/all/files/lbnl-1005742_1.pdf
- WalterBright 5y agoIt denies economics because it does not shape demand during the day due to price signalling.