4 ms·
Dell's Proprietary DDR5 Module Locks Out User Upgrades
- rektide 5y agopersonally this feelsike a tipping point to me, in a good way. more and more and more systems have soldered down ram, because it's way way way smaller footprint. there's some chance dell has some gross nasty vulgar drm in this solution. but probably not. it's probably reverse engineerable with not much effort. and it's a tiny little modular dual channel ram solution. this is desperately needed. it's absurd such a stupid obvious helpful minor shoft hadnt happened. there's literally nothing new here, it's just a form factor shift. this is obvious beyond belif. but it's been easier to solder down ram & thats what this cheapskate industry has gone. good for dell for doing what is obvious & in reach. hopefully this starts the trend, hopefully this spreads.
- viraptor 5y agoYeah, the article mentions "if they open it", but really the question is "if they patent it". If others can implement the same and the design works - this seems like a great move. Of course if they're trying to just make licensing money that way, I hope the whole idea crashes and someone reimplements it in an accessible way...
- Stevvo 5y agoI don't like it, but if the alternative way of meeting the laptop's design requirements is soldering the RAM then I'll take it.
- DangitBobby 5y ago> At first glance, it sounds like a better implementation than soldered memory. However, CAMM would effectively blockade users from memory upgrades unless they purchase directly from Dell. So... At first glance it sounds better than not being able to upgrade at all, but if you really think about it, you have to purchase upgrades from Dell.
- KennyBlanken 5y ago> Dell will equip the Precision 7670 with a beautiful 16-inch display That sound you hear is the sound of a freelance tech writer sucking Dell's dick. They haven't even announced a release date and this guy is writing like he's personally seen the screen.
- kimixa 5y agoOne of the advantages of soldering RAM is better signal integrity - shorter paths and easier routing, plus connectors tend to be awful for high frequency stuff. So I fear this isn't a "Better soldered RAM", as it may lack it's advantages.
- nix23 5y ago>One of the advantages of soldering RAM is better signal integrity Can you proof that?
- bogantech 5y agoEvery connector has some amount of resistance (higher than a soldered joint) for example
- kimixa 5y agoAn example of DIMM vs non-DIMM (soldered) ddr signal integrity analysis is in here: https://www.signalintegrityjournal.com/articles/1731-signal-integrity-characterization-of-via-stubs-on-high-speed-ddr4-channels https://www.signalintegrityjournal.com/articles/1731-signal-... And the connectors aren't just increased resistance, but cause reflections of the wave. And surely the routing issues are self-evident? No constraints of pushing all the signals through a specific pinout edge connector. All that is (one of) the reason all gddr is soldered, and apple's M1 gets a super wide memory bus at low power by being even closer on-package.