4 ms·
I always permit early exercise, which is specially good at the earliest stages when the common options are worth little, even less than a cent pre funding That
by gumby 5y ago
I always permit early exercise, which is specially good at the earliest stages when the common options are worth little, even less than a cent pre funding
That is, you can exercise your options whenever you want, even your first day at your job. What happens is the company can buy them back when you leave, but that ability goes away by the same amount as the regular vesting schedule. So if you leave the company after two years the company buys back half your stock, but there’s no tax impact (and by then you’re in the LTCG regime). Big win, easy to do, so why doesn’t everybody do this?
- rstephenson2 5y agoIs there some nuance as to how this is set up? The company buying back the stock when you leave seems particularly interesting: if the valuation has changed in between when you start and when you leave, the company either buys the stock back at the new, higher price (in which case you make some cash on unvested stock) or the company buys it back at the original price, and from a tax perspective you are selling it to them priced under fair market value and the company owes taxes on that I think? Is there something I’m missing?
- Swizec 5y agoI've been part of such an approach in the past. The way it worked there (and I imagine would everywhere) is that you exercise your full options, thus turning them into RSUs. You then give the company options on your RSUs at current valuation and the percentage of your RSUs that are covered by the options reduces on the vesting schedule.
- gumby 5y agoNothing so complicated. Not turning them into RSUs, simply exercising the options to buy ordinary common stock with the company's right to repurchase expiring every month (or whatever the option vesting schedule would be). Repurchase is at the purchase price paid by the employee so nobody owes any taxes. The point is that whenever you leave you have the same number of shares either way, but this way you pay for them at par (and with 83(b) owe no tax until you sell) and get the LTCG clock started right away. If you pay when you leave you have to pay tax on the delta This is much friendlier to the the employee, at least when the purchase price is quite low. And why wouldn't I want that for my team? I've done this with half a dozen companies at least; I don't know why everyone doesn't. The change to the option plan is quite standard and the law firms all know it.
- beagle3 5y agoThere is nuance, though - adversarial shareholders can bring a company down. It happens often enough with bona fide investors; but when you have a disgruntled employee (or one who quits to go work for a direct competitor), who has the same information rights as any other shareholder, but basically no skin in the game (if they exercise one share), things can get really nasty. There are many reasonable ways to deal with it, including “right of first refusal”, some kind of custodian/escrow, FMV+x% forced sale that can be called by the company, allowing only substantial sale to 3rd party (or an employee with 2000 shares could sell one share each to 2000 different people, and all of a sudden you get regulated as a public company) etc. I am all in favor of sharing ownership with those who shared the risk and the burden, but the governing laws weren’t written weren’t written for this, so it needs to be taken account in the specific agreements.
- gumby 5y agoThis is one of the most minor concern I can imagine for a startup. >I am all in favor of sharing ownership with those who shared the risk and the burden, but the governing laws weren’t written weren’t written for this, so it needs to be taken account in the specific agreements. These issues almost never happen and the process for giving employees equity interest is well developed. The standard SPAs always have ROFO clauses and such. There's no need to innovate -- any Vally law firm's standard docs have everything needed. In the US shareholders of private companies have pretty limited inspection rights: basically public filings and board minutes etc (usually the latter say things like "the CEO presented the last quarter's performance and a discussion ensued"). Preferred investors negotiate more detailed inspection rights. In 30+ years of running startups in the Bay Area I have never seen any of the things you describe happen (not just my own companies -- never seen them happen). OTOH, at the second company sold (first one I founded) the front desk receptionist made enough to pay off her mortgage and fully fund her retirement. That's the way things should work. Spend your energy on the upside.
- beagle3 5y agoIt was not in the US - it was in a country where shareholders in private companies actually have rights - and I was contracting for a company where this was actually used for good: founders tried to screw early employees (already vested and exercised) out of some rights through a restructuring (that was essential for business reasons) - and the employees managed to level the playing field using such an approach. It was good for everyone. But it could also have been used by a single vengeful employee to effectively stop or delay that restructuring, which would have been bad for everyone. All I said was that there was nuance. A good lawyer in the relevant jurisdiction would know what it is.
- berberous 5y agoThis is almost always a repurchase at original cost (not fair market value). The company does not owe taxes on that.
- gumby 5y agoRepurchase at the original purchase price. No taxes apply to either party.
- HWR_14 5y agoWhy bother with options at all at that point? Why not just go directly to RSUs?
- gumby 5y agoRSUs are pretty awful since you don't have access to the 83(b) exemption and tax is paid at ordinary income rate rather than long term cap gains rate, so RSUs can't offer the same opportunity to build long term wealth. RSUs seem to make sense to public companies which don't meaningfully have access to all the kinds of compensation available to private companies. IANAL but RSUs seem like a ripoff for a private company to use them even if the common price is high compared to a standard ISO SOP.
- eftychis 5y agoRSUs are terrible for a private company that aspires to go public, because the moment they trigger -- usually IPO + enough volume traded -- the company owes half of them in taxes (regular income taxes). This places a considerable pressure on the stock and causes a crash on the price usually -- as everyone from peon to executive have to sell half of their multi-year "vestments." So instead of the company raising slowly money via the market and the employees getting a good check when they decide to slowly sell, Uncle Sam gets some taxes up front... (And usually due to the likely crash, less than they would.)
- yibg 5y agoTaxes. If you give RSUs, the value of them might get really high in later years, along with the tax burden. And because the RSUs are liquid you can’t sell them to cover tax.
- gen220 5y ago> why doesn’t everybody do this? Just a guess, the directors of the company might prefer, from a fiduciary point of view, to invest the cash in capex or sales, rather than re-acquiring options for the option pool. Although, if you're acquiring at cost of exercise, the stock is probably more valuable than the cash you're paying for it. I could argue it either way, curious how you've valued the opportunity cost? If your company doesn't have a significant sales+marketing department that can always seem to justify soaking up excess capital in exchange for marginal growth, your technique seems like a no-brainer! Smart idea.