9 ms·
The grid operator cited is the California Independent System Operator. How much of CA's electricity consumption is fed by that operator? In the article they m
by kelnos 5y ago
The grid operator cited is the California Independent System Operator. How much of CA's electricity consumption is fed by that operator?
In the article they mention 23GW from wind and solar. A quick search says in 2018 CA's electrical generation capacity was 80GW (which I assume has only gone up). So this 97% is a bit misleading, no? It doesn't represent 97% of total CA electricity usage... it's less than 30%?
- kmonsen 5y agoThat's assuming everything else is 0.
- danans 5y ago> How much of CA's electricity consumption is fed by that operator? 80% of California and part of Nevada also. Don't confuse the grid operator with the utility. Those are separate entities. The ISO is the market maker for electricity - ultimately responsible for keeping supply and demand on the grid in balance. They contract with numerous entities to achieve that. The utility is responsible for some combination of generation, transmission, distribution, and billing, depending on where you are located. There are many other players in the markets, including spinning reserves, independent generators, demand aggregators, community-choice-aggregators, and some that play multiple roles.
- selectodude 5y agoCAISO doesn't cover the city of Los Angeles, but that's about it.
- jjtheblunt 5y ago> but that's about it isn't that the major consumer?
- selectodude 5y agoCovers the Bay Area and the entirety of Southern California except for the city limits of Los Angeles. So all but about 4 million people.
- joebob42 5y agoMy interpretation is that this was a low demand moment where that 27gw was more or less equal to the demand (e.g. a demand trough not a renewable output spike).
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoSo the title should be - CA generated 97% of electricity from renewable energy for a brief moment on April 3?
- CrimsonCape 5y agoNo, because joebob's interpretation is wrong.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoHow so?
- simpsond 5y agoYes, the article says that in the first paragraph. Also, solar generation is highest during march/April. Cooler temps and good angles. Demand is lower too, as temps are good for people.
- KarlKemp 5y agoNo. The whole day was the „brief moment“.
- tppiotrowski 5y agoFrom the article: > Rooftop solar advocacy group Save California Solar said although this milestone should be celebrated, California’s renewable energy progress is better measured by conditions on a hot August summer day than a cool April spring day. Renewable peaks typically occur in the spring, due to mild temperatures and the sun angle allowing for an extended window of strong solar production.
- jweir 5y agoCapacity is the ability to produce energy and with renewables that number is very different than with fossil fuels or nukes. Renewables never reach capacity, well your solar might for a peak moment, but then it will drop as the sun drops. For example - you have a 200 MW wind farm, you might only be able to produce 10MW at that moment. The capacity is 200MW, the generation is 10. Also the 3rd was a Sunday in spring - no office workers, less demand, not a heating or cooling day in a lot of California, ie a lower energy day than say a week day in summer where the temp is 105 in the Central Valley.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoApril 3rd was a sunday, and probably a very sunny one, with temperatures in ranges where a lot of people don't really need AC nor electrical heating. What do you do when it's not sunny, very cold/hot, no wind, and businesses and factories are open? Somehow we talk a lot about solar, and not enough about nuclear.
- gameswithgo 5y ago
- labster 5y agoWe talk about nuclear more than we talk about solar on HN. Probably because it’s controversial we get more atomic writes, while solar is presumed to exist.
- cinntaile 5y agoIt's the title of the article after all. We could talk about Intel as well, but it's not relevant.
- strainer 5y agoYou need forms of storage for that. The conundrum can be turned on its head - "What do you do when you have nuclear and the businesses and factories are closed ?" You either simply waste nuclear capacity that you've paid and waited years for to be built - or you need forms of storage to make use of it. Both Nuclear and Renewables really want storage, they will compete for it. If you can only make use of 60% of a nuclear plants capacity, you're price per unit is 100/60 more than the 'base-load' ideal that it was sold for. And another thing future nuclear plants will have to run alongside - is more and more renewable supply since renewables are cheaper and faster to build. We will have a situation where almost all demand is met by renewable supply eventually, and before that situation the demand left nuclear will decrease from 70,60,50,40,30...% - that's even without storage. How many decades do you expect it will take before those plants built with contracts to run for half a century or more, become pointlessly uneconomic ?
- ajsnigrutin 5y ago
- IvyMike 5y ago"The CAISO is one of the largest ISOs in the world, delivering 300 million megawatt-hours of electricity each year and managing about 80% of California's electric flow." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Independent_System_Operator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Independent_System_... Right now, 3PM in California, the CAISO demand shows around 21GW of demand. http://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/index.html http://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/index.html Note that CAISO's peak, ever, was 50GW. (PDF) http://www.caiso.com/Documents/CaliforniaISOPeakLoadHistory.pdf http://www.caiso.com/Documents/CaliforniaISOPeakLoadHistory.... The "installed capacity" of 80GW I believe is the number if you add the theoretical max of all hydro, solar, wind, gas peaker plants, etc. But each source will never simultaneously be at max, so we never get close to this 80GW number. https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/california-electricity-data/2020-total-system-electric-generation/2018#:~:text=California%20has%20approximately%2080%2C000%20MW,and%206%2C000%20MW%20from%20wind https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/califo....
- vmception 5y ago> “If California is to have any hope of getting to 100% renewable energy on an August day in the future ... it will take 100 GW more energy produced by solar. Halting the progress of rooftop solar makes that goal impossible" I'm also confused by the scales here. How are they praising the use of 15,000 MW (15GW) and 8,000 MW (8 GW) in one sentence, in an article about 97% of California's energy being used, and saying they need 100 GW in the next sentence and being sad they can't put it on rooftops. In an article showing a photo of a solar cell field in a vast, desolate, arid region of central valley.
- Retric 5y agoIn California August requires a lot more electricity due to AC than April. Seasonal demand differences can be huge, and why a lot of maintenance for nuclear reactors etc take place in the spring and fall.
- vmception 5y agoI'm catching on. Is there not enough space in central valley for this? is there too much loss transporting that electricity to population centers?
- Retric 5y agoIn theory moving electricity 1,000 miles can have minimal transmission losses. Unfortunately California’s grid lacks the infrastructure to support significant long distance transmission.
- incomethax 5y agoSort-of. Transmission for HTHV lines (745kV single circuit cost $2.5-4M/mile with ~1% line loss; 345kV single circuit will cost ~$1.5-2M/mile with 5% line loss). For 1MW solar capacity you typically need about 4 acres. 100GW of solar would require 400k acres of land - and come at a cost of about $3 billion for the panels, not to mention the price of land or entitlements. Add in cost of substations and transmission you’re realistically looking at a $10+ Billion project. Which while doable would not profitability compete with other grid solutions. If panels drop by another 30% and power densities improve the grid will naturally tend towards that direction.
- mschaef 5y ago> A quick search says in 2018 CA's electrical generation capacity was 80GW (which I assume has only gone up). So this 97% is a bit misleading, no? It doesn't represent 97% of total CA electricity usage... it's less than 30%? Their full installed generation capacity is 80GW, but there's huge variability in actual load. As I write this, current load is around 21GW, on a range of between 18.7GW and 27GW over the day. It gets into the 40's in the summer. https://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/default.aspx https://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/default.aspx There's a significant need for reserve capacity to deal with this load variability, as well as plant failures, etc.
- Mvandenbergh 5y agoThat is all the capacity added together before de-rating. Capacity is de-rated based on how likely it is to produce during a system load peak. So a nuclear plant might be counted as 75% of nameplate to account for outage risk. Renewables are de-rated a lot and by how much changes over time as they make up a larger share of the connected capacity. California de-rates solar by less than, say, the UK since Cali has a lot of air conditioning load which is coincident with insolation whereas summer days are the low-load periods in the UK. The capacity before de-rating > capacity after de-rating > highest anticipated load > actual load on a normal day.