4 ms·
> None of their claims have materially panned out. Well, I can send arbitrarily large amounts of money across the planet, to any country with internet access,
by sneak 5y ago
> None of their claims have materially panned out.
Well, I can send arbitrarily large amounts of money across the planet, to any country with internet access, for tiny sums, safely, irreversibly, to anyone.
Many people have sent many millions to Ukraine, for example. Transnational, permissionless internet money is quite handy.
That wasn't possible before, and that's pretty useful, so I think the basic claim (that cryptocurrency is useful) is holding up fine.
- logifail 5y agoIn one corner we have types who want to send > arbitrarily large amounts of money and in the other corner we have the types who know about and enforce AML and KYC legislation. How is this possibly going to end well for the first group?
- sneak 5y agoIt turns out there are actually things that lawmakers don't really have the power to effectively ban, drugs and prostitution and gambling and cash transactions principally among them. A lot of people don't seem to integrate this fact. The practical power of a lawmaking body is not unlimited. There are certain things they simply cannot stop, no matter how many laws are passed. It won't "end" for either group, really. The latter will pass some laws, and the former will mostly ignore them, same as happened with hookers and blow. The people who inhabit both groups (the subset of lawmakers that like being able to pay for their hookers and blow with unreported bitcoin) will laugh at the absurdity of the whole thing.
- Jach 5y ago"The laws of mathematics are very commendable, but the only law that applies in Australia is the law of Australia." --Malcolm Turnbull, Australia Prime Minister (2015-2018) There are some people who see attitudes like that in the government and think how can [things backed by math] survive a coordinated government onslaught that'll happen any year now? And then those that just look at such statements as the unlettered nonsense they are. Bitcoin lets you "be your own bank", independent of any KYC laws that may or may not apply to other banks in your jurisdiction.
- TomSwirly 5y agoAnd if no one else accepts my bank? If selling things to US citizens for cryptocurrency is criminal, and enforced?
- Jach 5y agoThey're not obligated to, just as I'm not obligated to accept a check from your bank and can demand cash or some other form of payment. Your question is like asking what if no one wants to talk to me with PGP or some other secure message protocol. What if selling things to US citizens via any means is criminal, and enforced?
- BoxOfRain 5y agoI definitely think a huge part of the business of government generally is enforcing society's suspension of disbelief, it's a lot cheaper to merely convince everyone that you're all-powerful and resistance is futile than to actually become all-powerful.
- TomSwirly 5y agoYou're saying that the use case for cryptocurrencies is crime, which I agree with, and the world's police won't touch you because they can't, which I think is ridiculous. If the EU and the US alone said, "In a month, we'll consider every crypto transaction to be criminal in nature, and we're going to enforce it," the market would collapse as everyone stampeded for the door at the same time.
- sneak 5y ago> If the EU and the US alone said, "In a month, we'll consider every crypto transaction to be criminal in nature, and we're going to enforce it," the market would collapse as everyone stampeded for the door at the same time. True. And yet, cryptocurrencies would still remain useful! A market collapse is not the same as it not having utility. Bitcoin was useful even when it was only pennies, and it will remain so. This thread is about whether or not cryptocurrencies are useful. They are. Could governments crash their markets? Yes. Could they stop people from using them? No.
- logifail 5y ago>> If the EU and the US alone said, "In a month, we'll consider every crypto transaction to be criminal in nature, and we're going to enforce it," the market would collapse > True. And yet, cryptocurrencies would still remain useful! A market collapse is not the same as it not having utility. (Genuine) Q: How many market participants are interested in "the utility" vs the (potential for) "getting rich"?
- falcolas 5y agoTheres one big weakness in the use of cryptocurrencies: swapping back and forth with the local fiat currency at scale. All a government has to do is shut those commercial ventures down, and the value of the $coin will disappear for those residents. Plus, unlike drugs and prostitution, the ledger is public and permanent… simplifying enforcement against the remaining fringes dramatically.
- sneak 5y ago> All a government has to do is shut those commercial ventures down, and the value of the $coin will disappear for those residents. So long as any of those residents can travel to another place where they can exchange it for hard money, that's not true. Countries do not exist in isolation.
- falcolas 5y agoCarrying large quantities of cash across a border is usually investigated by the border guards. If you don't declare it, you're breaking the law. This is compounded by how some countries are big enough that traveling across a border is a fairly significant undertaking (Brazil, for example). Not something most folks can or will do on a whim. Plus, you'd have to transfer a fairly significant amount of money to be worth it, making it more likely you'd run afoul of the border patrol.
- sneak 5y agoIt doesn't matter. As long as some members of society are willing to cross the border with cash, the availability of liquidity will be preserved (albeit with a slightly higher cost). "Most folks" won't need to deal with it any more than most folks know how to drive a semi full of groceries.
- rglullis 5y agoIf they shut down, they will just push even more of their economy to the black markets. Also, anonymity is not yet something that people care enough. But it already exists - monero, zcash, or the Aztec Network on top of Ethereum. I can bet that any serious attempt from the government at chasing regular people based on their Blockchain activity would lead to a lot to adopt the "truly private" networks.
- theamk 5y agoThis would be one way to do this, yes, and I think it would be overall good for society if there was a clear association of cryptocurrencies and crime. There would still be shady cryptocurrency things (just like we still have illegal drugs and gambling and prostitution), but at least we won't have smart people proudly announcing that they made new crypto system (just like we don't have people proudly announcing they made a new kind of illegal drug today). Because for each person who genuinely believes into monetary anarchy and/or does not trust the government, there are lots more (thousands? tens of thousands?) people who read about it in New York Times and want to earn their money. It is the second group which is fueling the first, and so getting rid of it will make crypto harmless again.
- kllrnohj 5y agoExcept Bitcoin transactions (or any other blockchain transaction) is forever public and forever traceable. It's the complete opposite of a cash transaction. Once your wallet is in some way connected to you, all your transactions since the beginning of time are now known. This is a wet dream for government enforcement.
- bena 5y agoFor those who may be unfamiliar with the acronyms. AML is Anti Money Laundering KYC is Know Your Customer
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Many people have sent many millions to Ukraine, for example Far more has been sent over traditional rails [1]. Once you consider state aid, e.g. the billions the Congress has authorized, crypto's contribution is irrelevant. Given Ukraine had to convert 80% of its crypto into hard currency before it could use it, crypto was also the most expensive donation vector. If we consider crypto’s likely role in softening Russian sanctions (also almost negligible, but we’re comparing two small things), the net contribution could be a wash. [1] https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory/crypto-aid-ukraine-innovation-sideshow-83687130 https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory/crypto-aid-ukraine...
- notch656a 5y ago>Far more has been sent over traditional rails [1]. Once you consider state aid, e.g. the billions the Congress has authorized, crypto's contribution is irrelevant. When you put it that way, your or my life is just a point of irrelevance in the sea of humanity. While that has a ring of truth to it, it's an odd way to dismiss each piece from making its contribution. A house is built of many bricks.
- dogman144 5y agoThe amount doesn't matter as much as the latency and resources* used to send it. *not going to address the green energy mining debate here but yes I know it is a thing. Given funds sent by congress that went through how many approval gates, delays, and intermediaries, vs. millions sent almost over night to the UKR address... What are the pros/cons of the the two approaches? - billions were sent via congress, and the last time this occurred at a similar scale and sense of urgency was covid relief. The [0] fraud [1] involved [2] and what scale was somewhat substantial and is now a focused DoJ investigation. Scale of $2bil seizures, for instance. Sending direct to a crypto address also has issues and fraud certainly exists, but wouldn't say irrelevant in the alternative controls it offers. $100 mil almost overnight with no strings attached vs. billions from Congress that has strings and will take some time presumably. - Zelensky has consistently been upfront about the need is both resources, and speed of receiving resources [3]. What's more in line with that need - overnight donations, or Congressional authorizations that eventually lead into donations. - Conversion: per Zelensky, biggest need is armaments, and he's been able to buy armaments directly in crypto, so that neutralizes your last criticism a bit, or at least more accurately fills out the picture [4] Do you have any information the aid issued by Congress - has it actually reached UKR, how much of it, strings attached, etc? [0] https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-announces-nationwide-coordinated-law-enforcement-action-combat-health-care https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-announces-... [1] https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/12/politics/secret-service-covid-funds/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/12/politics/secret-service-covid... [2] https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/04/course-relief-money-will-be-ill-spent/610126/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/04/course-rel... [3] https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2022/04/zelensky-kyiv-russia-war-ukrainian-survival-interview/629570/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2022/04/ze... [4] https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2022/04/zelensky-kyiv-russia-war-ukrainian-survival-interview/629570/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2022/04/ze...
- Traster 5y agoOkay, provide some evidence for that claim. Because again, that's the claim of "Well crypto is doing amazing things" but it needs actual evidence. I know it theoretically could happen if you ignore all the glaring problems in practice. But does it actually happen? What has cyrpto provided that you can't provide via Paypal or bank transfer? Hell - here's a paypal address for a bunch of guys who want to buy Ukraine a fighter jet - info@buymeafighterjet.com . Here's the donation page for the Kyiv school of economics https://kse.ua/support/donation https://kse.ua/support/donation - you may notice a small bit of text right above the crypto addresses for you donation - that small bit of text is a form for card transactions, 8 different ways of doing a bank transfer and a paypal address. So what has Cryptocurrency acheived here? You donate crypto to these charities, and then what happens? They convert it back into fiat currency to actually spend it. You've literally just added more steps to something that was already solved.
- lui8906 5y ago> Okay, provide some evidence for that claim. Because again, that's the claim of "Well crypto is doing amazing things" but it needs actual evidence. I know it theoretically could happen if you ignore all the glaring problems in practice. But does it actually happen? Which part of the claim are you refuting here? It is a fact that one can send very large sums of value between two addresses for a trivial transaction fee. This value can be swapped across other tokens with low slippage in the millions (denominated in USD). > What has cyrpto provided that you can't provide via Paypal or bank transfer? Hell - here's a paypal address for a bunch of guys who want to buy Ukraine a fighter jet - info@buymeafighterjet.com . Here's the donation page for the Kyiv school of economics https://kse.ua/support/donation https://kse.ua/support/donation - you may notice a small bit of text right above the crypto addresses for you donation - that small bit of text is a form for card transactions, 8 different ways of doing a bank transfer and a paypal address. I spoke with someone yesterday who lives in Nigeria, they were moving to Rwanda and needed to pay a deposit in advance. They were unable to pay via MoneyGram, Western Union etc. - one provider offered to handle the payment and requested many documents for a few days and in the end rejected the transfer. This person then had to send money to a friend who lived in the US who then forwarded it to Rwanda. This experience made the person feel isolated and outside of the system. This is an anecdote however my guess is if you think PayPal is "good enough" you don't live in a country that is marginalized by the status quo payment system. > So what has Cryptocurrency acheived here? You donate crypto to these charities, and then what happens? They convert it back into fiat currency to actually spend it. You've literally just added more steps to something that was already solved. So that's your take, global finance is a solved problem? No todos? No improvements needed we can pack it up? This is a stunning poverty of imagination in my estimation and a denial of the very real struggle many people face day to day in transacting.
- HWR_14 5y ago> Many people have sent many millions to Ukraine, As I understand it, somewhere around 20MM was sent to Ukraine via crypto. The National bank of Japan sent 100MM the first day with lower transaction costs (fees, electricity, complexity). And the Ukrainians still have to convert the crypto to money to use it. Meanwhile, everyone could just send money to Ukraine via the standard banking system if they wanted to.