4 ms·
The main reason to make a building airtight is for energy efficiency. But it's pointless to go to such lengths for airtightness if you have massive thermal bri
by londons_explore 5y ago
The main reason to make a building airtight is for energy efficiency.
But it's pointless to go to such lengths for airtightness if you have massive thermal bridges in the walls and roof in so many places.
If you want to be really efficient, the insulation should be constant thickness with no nails or screws poking into it, and certainly no bits of wood across it. Since the insulation has no mechanical strength, that really means you're building two houses - an inner house and an outer house, both of which need to stand up without the help of the other.
- rapjr9 5y agoBuilding a house within a house would also add a lot of soundproofing. I wonder if anyone has studied whether people like or dislike not being able to hear what is going on outside the house. Seems like there would be some safety issues, like you can't hear someone outside calling for help and can't hear how intense a storm is or if a car/truck drives up, but on the good side you also can't hear the neighbors lawn mower and wood chipper. Some people may like feeling connected audibly to the outside world and feel more isolated if they can't hear nature while others may like that it makes the outside world go away. It may not be possible to hear wind chimes. An emergency siren may be difficult to hear, though emergency sirens are not used much any more in the USA, except near nuclear power plants and such. Maybe that needs to change with climate change. In fact, changing climate may need to be part of the calculation on how houses are built (not just increased wind resistance but also estimates of how warm/cold the area will be year round in the future.) It would be great if houses could be 3D printed so people are not limited by increased costs due to homebuilders not upgrading their skills. House design may need to change radically on the East Coast (Nor'easters's) and in Tornado Alley and on the South coast (hurricanes).
- frosted-flakes 5y agoI disagree. Airtightness is far more important than insulation. Insulation is worthless if air currents can simply carry the heat and bypass the insulation. And unless you're building an ICF house, some minor thermal bridging is unavoidable. But it does not matter because you can just insulate more somewhere else to make up for it. Exterior foamboard insulation around the entirety of the house is already quite common and cost-effective.
- mikeyouse 5y agoThis is exactly right - there are calculators that assess the heat/cooling load of your home (https://www.borstengineeringconstruction.com/Heat_Loss_Analysis_Calculator.html https://www.borstengineeringconstruction.com/Heat_Loss_Analy... for a basic one) and with sensible insulation + leaky buildings that were common in the past, the heat loss to air infiltration can approach the total load you'd otherwise need. Using that calc - with typical R-Values for an old building of 1,000sq ft + ACH50 of 10 (converted to 0.5 for this since ACH50 values are at pressure) with a 0º outdoor temp and a 70º inside temp, the heating load would be 50k BTU. Doubling the insulation on the walls, doubling the R-Value of the windows, and doubling the roof insulation has the same impact as bringing the leakiness to an ACH50 of 3. One of those can be done with a few tubes of caulk, a few rolls of weather stripping, and some cans of spray foam. The other involves removing siding/drywall/roof material. Everyone in building science will tell you that the "best dollars" on saving heating/cooling costs are spent in making your home tighter.