3 ms·
So the total projected end to end cost is up to $105b from $100b 2 years ago. Isn't that just accounting for inflation? The LA times really has an axe to grind
by asdff 5y ago
So the total projected end to end cost is up to $105b from $100b 2 years ago. Isn't that just accounting for inflation? The LA times really has an axe to grind whenever they write about the bullet train.
- MichaelBurge 5y agoIn 2018, the entirety of all corporate income taxes collected was $200b, and the entire Medicaid program was $389b[1]. " In 2021, the solar industry generated more than $33 billion of private investment in the American economy": So the entire solar industry is 1/3 of this single rail line. You can't just casually call it "inflation" when you're spending significant percentages of the annual budget on a single train line and somehow it's still not enough. 1/6 of the entire solar industry is not "inflation". Amtrak requested $4 billion in COVID relief from the government to maintain its national rail network, and $1.5 billion to "expand rail service"[2]. That entire amount you just called "inflation" for a single rail line, and they're running 26 lines all over the country. Also: Even if the construction costs somehow end up comparable, Amtrak's entire annual revenue is $2.3 billion. How long's it going to take to pay back $105 billion with this single rail line, if the entire Amtrak network would take 50 years to pay this one line back ignoring all operating costs? [1] https://www.cbo.gov/publication/55342 https://www.cbo.gov/publication/55342 [2] http://media.amtrak.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Amtrak-General-Legislative-Annual-Report-FY2022-Grant-Request-1.pdf http://media.amtrak.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Amtrak-Ge...
- Fatnino 5y agoHave you ever traveled long distance on amtrak? Their website claims there are trains between the stations you want but then a few clicks later tells you they are canceled for the day you chose to travel. Doesn't matter what day, it's canceled that day, sorry. For example, try to get from the bay area to Chicago. Prices claim to start around 500 bucks for a non bed ticket for the 2.5 day trip. But it's actually not possible to get an itinerary that doesn't include traveling on a weekend.
- Gibbon1 5y agoThe LA times only reports the high cost estimate for California's high speed rail because for whatever reason the LA Times has a hate boner for the project. If you go by them the costs keep massively going up while nothing has been done so far. One can also read progress reports from the rail authority and look at satellite pictures. Which will both show that estimated cost is increasing 'a bit' and steady progress being made in the central valley. https://www.buildhsr.com/ https://www.buildhsr.com/ Quote: The current cost estimate to deliver the 500-mile system linking San Francisco to Los Angeles/Anaheim via the Central Valley ranges from $69.01 to $99.9 billion. From here https://hsr.ca.gov/about/capital-costs-funding/ https://hsr.ca.gov/about/capital-costs-funding/ You can compare that to the BART Silicon Valley Extension Phase II. Budget for that is 6.9 billion for a six mile extension. Which the press is studiously ignoring.