3 ms·
Immigration laws aren't very good in almost all countries. Governments do want to plan better and have good-sense policies that let in people who can integrate
by telchior 4y ago
Immigration laws aren't very good in almost all countries. Governments do want to plan better and have good-sense policies that let in people who can integrate and contribute. But they are held back by a basic human instinct: xenophobia. The average person is OK with seeing one stranger in town, but start feeling creeped out when they see handfuls, and get downright paranoid when exposed to large numbers of foreigners. Inevitably, this instinct becomes a tool for a subset of politicians, who then play power games with immigration policies.
I'm not sure exactly why, but there are also some systemic habits that make immigration much worse than it should be. For example, it's nearly universal that countries will put tight global restrictions in place because they want to reduce immigrants from a single place. E.g. looking at Central / South America right now, a lot are tightening up policies against all nationalities because they don't want immigrants from Venezuela. This is really baked in -- look at how intense the outcry was when the Trump administration put restrictions on specific, named countries at the beginning of the pandemic. That's generally just not done.
So in short, you may be correct that there's a theoretical human right, but the world just isn't going to realign in that direction anytime soon. In the same way that it's sort of a human right to have pleasant, non-hostile interactions with other people, but that would also be impossible to effect; there are simply too many assholes in the mix.
One thing I've often pondered is that there should be some sort of non-governmental group that you can join or qualify for, which evaluates and vouches for its members and guarantees their good conduct in any country they visit. Basically, the same thing a passport does. But it's a pipe dream in a world where almost everything is based on accidents of geography.
As a side note, there is a new sort of route to immigrating for people in your situation, these days: instead of going to another country first, instead work remotely, build up cash, and use that to immigrate. (Because, as others have pointed out, money is one pathway to immigration.)
- __d 4y agoYour "average person" doesn't reflect my view of an average person's feelings. Even leaving alone the assumption that it's possible to distinguish a foreigner by appearance, a feeling of being "creeped out" by seeing handfuls of them seems very extreme. Perhaps it's a matter of experience? For instance, I've lived in Sydney, New York, and Berlin, and in each case, during my daily commute there are hundreds, perhaps thousands, of people of different ethnic appearances, but it's far from creepy, let alone paranoia-inducing.
- telchior 4y agoI thought of adding the caveat that the "creeped out" feeling doesn't really apply in major cities but I'm making an effort to be less long-winded. Anyway, that's what I'd say in response. In a big city, nobody blinks if they, say, see a group of Sikhs wander by with turbans and beards. But in the small/mid-sized town I grew up in there will be a lot of whispered comments and an undercurrent of fear. For other groups the fear might be replaced with other reactions (disgust, discomfort, anger, or even just a mildly hostile bemusement). Those towns far outnumber the big, metropolitan cities. And the normalization of otherness doesn't even apply to all major cities. For instance I've seen serious, in-your-face racism in Tokyo, which is one of the largest in the world. I've seen it in Manila, which is considered one of the friendliest cities (depends on your skin color!). And I've seen it in tier 2 cities in Austria (which I'd assume is pretty similar to Germany), too. Berlin isn't a very good example.