3 ms·
pretty sure that's because log is not well defined over the complex numbers, it's just defined over branch cuts. similar to how sqrt(x^2) != (sqrt((x)^2)
by lupire 5y ago
pretty sure that's because log is not well defined over the complex numbers, it's just defined over branch cuts.
similar to how
sqrt(x^2) != (sqrt((x)^2)
when x is Real but not Positive Real, because sqrt is not well defined over the full Reals.
It's not a flaw of notation, it's a flaw in the attempted math.
- gjvnq 5y agoHow about we just accept that the square root is a relation inatead of a function?
- d_tr 5y agoI am not sure what you mean by "relation" and what the benefit would be. There is a definition for "relation" in mathematics. A function is a type of relation and a relation is a set. But you probably have something else in mind.
- ducttapecrown 5y agoMultivalued functions are types of relations. Relations are more general than multivalued functions because relations don't have to be defined on the entire domain.
- kergonath 5y agoWhat’s wrong with the square root, apart from the fact that it’s not defined over all of R? It’s a fairly well behaved function overall.
- moonchild 5y agoI think you mean sqrt(x^2) != (sqrt(x))^2