3 ms·
> If you want to say the science is still unsettled, sure. I agree studies give conflicting results and there is isn’t a clear winner here. I agree more studi
by Retric 5y ago
> If you want to say the science is still unsettled, sure.
I agree studies give conflicting results and there is isn’t a clear winner here.
I agree more studies are perfectly reasonable.
However, the default when faced with conflicting information isn’t to put forth effort into changing behavior. That requires justification, which isn’t available.
Consider if millions where micro-dosing Tylenol to avoid dementia and the results where inconclusive, what messaging would you provide? (Stop your wasting money), (do it it’s probably worth it), (might help, might not, we don’t know do what you want). The temptation is to say ‘do it’, the costs are low and the benefits could be significant. However, when there are known useful things people could be doing it’s probably best to stick with the third option.
PS: Ok you could jump on the latest study and constantly flip flop on recommendations, but that just confuses people and erodes trust in the process.
- squeaky-clean 5y agoLook man, my comment was saying you can't just cherrypick a single sentence out of context from a long study (especially when the context of that section contradicts your own point). If you want to argue about sodium intake there's other comments in here for that. The statement you picked made it out that there is no correlation between sodium intake and heart rate. The study you took that statement from was making the point that we can't draw such conclusions either way. I didn't say anything about whether or not people should flip flop recommendations. But don't irresponsibly cite studies. It defeats your entire argument when you do so.
- Retric 5y ago> The statement you picked made it out that there is no correlation between sodium intake and heart rate. “was independently associated with increased heart rate in healthy individuals and individuals with hypertension.” Cherry picking would have been linking to the study that suggested lower salt intake was unhealthy directly. Instead I linked to the meta study to give better context.