3 ms·
Braves business is built on Google Chromes source code... Google has 500+ staff working on that codebase. When they finally annoy Google and they decide to r
by londons_explore 5y ago
Braves business is built on Google Chromes source code...
Google has 500+ staff working on that codebase. When they finally annoy Google and they decide to rewrite the license for future versions, will Brave be able to keep up?
- classified 5y agoYep, biting the hand that feeds will only work for so long.
- tomrod 5y agoAye, the DOJ won't look favorably on anti-competitive practices.
- inglor 5y agoGoogle has open sourced only as much as they had too for using Webkit's GPL codebase and have been notorious in close-sourcing bits when they are able (like the DevTools WebAssembly debugging tools and a ton of other stuff). So the fact Chromium is (mostly) open source (Chrome is most certainly not) is certainly not charity or the goodness of their hearts. It is the work of idealistic individuals like Lars Knoll who gave us this among other things like Qt. This is also true for a lot of other Google projects like Android.
- londons_explore 5y agoHaving spent a lot of time working on the codebase... Far more is opensource than Google needed to make open, and the development model is far more open than androids. In the chromium codebase, there are even some modules where the key technical decision-makers aren't Google employees.
- magicalist 5y ago> Google has open sourced only as much as they had too for using Webkit's GPL codebase This isn't remotely true. Most of Chromium code is BSD-3-Clause. > have been notorious in close-sourcing bits when they are able (like the DevTools WebAssembly debugging tools I'm not a fan of that either, but to be fair it's a Chrome extension[1], not part of Chrome. > and a ton of other stuff). Like what? The trend has generally been the other way. Flash was removed, PDFium was released. Video codecs? But they've always been that way. [1] https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/cc%20%20-devtools-support-dwa/pdcpmagijalfljmkmjngeonclgbbannb https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/cc%20%20-devtools-...
- inglor 5y ago> This isn't remotely true. Most of Chromium code is BSD-3-Clause. Yes, because when Apple forked KHTML they made the _least amount_ possible open source and when they faced public pressure and were criticised (note unlike Google - Apple doesn't really have a big business incentive to keep their browser open source anyway) they open sourced the parts that are/were outside WebCore and JavaScriptCore as BSD. Hardly benevolence. > I'm not a fan of that either, but to be fair it's a Chrome extension[1], not part of Chrome. That's true - it's also true for other parts of the codebase. I see your point about video codecs, drm and a bunch of other stuff and Google _does_ benefit from the fact companies like Igalia filled with ex-Googlers can contribute significantly to Chromium. I think it's important to make a distinction here between the engineers "with boots on the ground" - many of them care deeply about the internet and chromium being open and about working on an open source project and the people higher up making the more strategic decisions. It's also worth mentioning Chromiums is very much a "closed club" with a different (harder) contribution model, builds and meta-builds that work well only if you work for a large-co (otherwise it's built on your machine and takes hours) and it's very unreachable if you're not "in the know" compared to other projects. I don't think that part is malevolence though I just think making an open source project more open is hard.
- freedomben 5y agoPeople won't want to hear your comment (myself included) but it's a fair and important point. I've been on the other side so it does resonate with me. I worked for Red Hat at the time when CentOS changed their model and it was amazing how many people were like f*k Red Hat and their greedy money grab[1], I'm switching to <replacement>. Without realizing that the distros that do very little except rebuild Red Hat are only possible because Red Hat makes it possible. They could absolutely kill the clone if they wanted to[2]. To be clear I have nothing against the clones (in fact I use them), I mainly get bothered by people thinking a quality linux distro happens by accident. [1]: It was a little more complicated than just "money grab": https://freedomben.medium.com/centos-is-not-dead-please-stop-saying-it-is-at-least-until-you-read-this-4b26b5c44877?sk=e500c2f16403d634ff8a4ea17d705252 https://freedomben.medium.com/centos-is-not-dead-please-stop... [2]: Pre-empting the inevitable "but the GPL", Red Hat goes above and beyond the requirements of the GPL and could make it way harder to build. Also a huge important chunk of the distro is BSD/MIT/Apache/etc. Without that the GPL'ed only stuff would never be a feasible distro anyway
- passivate 5y agoThe open-source (also high-profile) nature of the project probably helps Google themselves keep their own team in check with outside accountability.