3 ms·
I'm confused by this comment: Although Stallman argues otherwise, the nature of the GPL is really incompatible with how business is done in the real world.
by throwaway2037 5y ago
I'm confused by this comment:
Although Stallman argues otherwise, the nature of the GPL is really incompatible with how business is done in the real world.
Red Hat deals heavily in GPL'd code that it writes and maintains. It is a major contributor to many, many GPL'd open source projects. Even where it cannot get patches accepted upstream, they maintain many year, massive patch sets to satisfy needs of corporate clients. How do you explain their success? The same is true, to a lesser extent, for SuSE, which has a major economic footprint in corporate Germany (and Austria and Switzerland).
And how about The Qt Company or MySQL / MariaDB?
- JohnHaugeland 5y ago> How do you explain their success? Red Hat is a rare outlier. The vast majority of business related software is not GPL, and cannot be.
- lostcolony 5y agoCertainly consumer oriented stuff. The thing notable about every company I've seen relying on GPL code is that what they sell are services/support. People pay Red Hat to be able to email someone when they have a problem. That's it. That's the business mode. Same with MariaDB (MySQL is a little unique in that it was purchased by Oracle, and I can't speak to Qt having no familiarity with it). That works for B2B positioning, since the cost of support staff scales well when each new customer is worth thousands of dollars in revenue...and doesn't work well for B2C where the cost of support staff won't scale well when each new customer is worth a few bucks.
- chrisfinazzo 5y agoThe distinction I would make is between companies who are in the business of developing software and people who use software to help them do a thing. Red Hat, Qt, and the rest give the core stuff they build away but make people pay for more complicated services and support. For them, that's reasonable and it works. Now, if you're Goldman Sachs and somebody gets a hold of the code that runs your trading platform (which surely includes some open-source components) and tries to use it as the basis of their work at another company, that's a problem. They're not in the business of selling software and paid people to develop something that supports the parts of the business that people can actually see. Allowing anyone to use that code simply based on policy gets problematic real fast.[1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergey_Aleynikov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergey_Aleynikov Just because some parts are open shouldn't mean everything must be and you can use it without repercussions. IANAL, but this is the basic reason why copyright exists, to make sure people can get paid for their work.
- Macha 5y agoSure, but I don't see the problem. These companies can't use GPL code if they don't want to share those. If the reason they don't want to share is because they feel it would get in their way of making money, they can find someone to take some of that money in exchange for producing code that they can use that does the same as the GPL library. For single copyright owner software, this might be the same code from the same owner, just under a commercial license. For free software you might have to implement your own clone. That's the prospective user and the software author being unable to agree on a price (the author wanting the release of the derivative source code), not any fatal flaw with free software.
- simiones 5y agoThe point is: can the ideal of the GPL actually work in the software development world? The answer seems to be "no". You can't build a software development company around a GPL code base. You can build a support services company around that (like RedHat or MySQL did), but that's it. You can build a service company that uses software internally, like Google and Facebook and AWS etc. But the idea that you can build and sell a piece of GPL software is a fantasy of Stallman's and no more than that. Free software has even helped encourage the software-as-a-service world, where no one owns even a copy of a propietary piece of software...
- chrisfinazzo 5y agoYou are technically correct, the best kind of correct.
- Macha 5y agoShould they then abandon that ideal and ensure there is no software that provides those benefits? In a world without copyleft, I don't think many of the ecosystems we have today would exist. The alternatives are that this software doesn't exist (because there's no economic incentive to build a business to sell it), or it's permissively licensed and some random other builds a business off it and with the extra resources outcompetes the original. I'd take a world with some free software over none, and I don't see any way to loosen the restrictions to make it more easily broadly commercially viable without causing its own extinction.
- orangepurple 5y ago> How do you explain their success? Release the source code in the most user-hostile, obfuscated, undocumented format possible while technically in legal compliance!
- glowingly 5y agoI remember a time when the then-independent CentOS was afraid to even reference Red Hat by name, instead referring to a large North American Enterprise Linux vendor. A bit too "he-who-shall-not-be-named" for me.
- okprod 5y agoI believe Red Hat gets most of its revenue from subscriptions and maintenance/support. They don't really have an incentive to try and protect software they've developed; instead, they benefit the more of the software they maintain is deployed.