3 ms·
Unlike in Russia, there is no singular "media" in the west. There are "western medias", plural, and you have the luxury of choosing your bias. There are plent
by cmrdporcupine 5y ago
Unlike in Russia, there is no singular "media" in the west.
There are "western medias", plural, and you have the luxury of choosing your bias.
There are plenty of idiots in the west who will sell you re-furbished Russian propaganda, if that's what you want.
(Is CNN stupid? Yes, it is, it's the same crap hysterical entertainment-news it has always been, mostly laughable to non-Americans and Americans alike. But there's plenty to choose from if you don't like that)
- zteppenwolf 5y ago
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoThere is no "general western media" in this era, because coverage is no longer centralized. There are dominant ideologies, which the "western media" reflects because the population has that bias already. You can stare at CNN or MSNBC and see a bias, of course. They largely repeat Pentagon or White House talking points. But that is no longer where people get the bulk of their information. Spend 20 minutes clicking the "wrong" links on YouTube and you'll get an entirely different bias. It should be obvious from the last two election cycles that people don't get their "news" from cable news anymore. They're deep in the bowels of social media and whoever manipulates that best. For better or for worse. Sorry, it's you who comes across as ignorant. And elitist and smarmy. Talking about "the west" as if there's one block, when what we actually have is a highly divided society... Except there's one thing that's actually uniting us right now and that's almost universal disgust at Russian actions in Ukraine EDIT: To add: is there a society-wide bias highlighting the ineptness and weakness of the Russian military? Probably inaccurately? Yes, quite likely, and it's probably dominant across the whole west. But why? Is it because propaganda? No, it's because we hope and wish this to be the case. I'm perfectly willing to admit that Russia is probably stronger and will "win" but goddamn it if I don't want to boost the narrative otherwise because I want them to lose so bad it hurts.
- zteppenwolf 5y agoYou can't justify the lack of commitment to truth with "its the bias of the population". First of all: its not. Its the bias of the media itself; however, the population often manifests much richer judgement than simply reducing this complicated struggle to "good vs evil". And even if it was: the media should impartially cover events. It should not manipulate numbers in favor of cherry picked narratives. edit replying your edit: But then; again, we should not create media based in wishful thinking. Instead, media should be based in facts. It disappoints me very much that so many people just accepts this blatant propaganda and sell these as if they are true.
- lm28469 5y agoGood luck impartially covering world events, the mere action of choosing to talk about an event is already biased. There are more "events" in a day than you could cover in a year worth of journalism
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoI'm sorry about it's almost become a joke, anybody who uses this phrase: "The Media". It used to be my fellow travelers on the radical left. Now it's nutcases on the far right. It betrays a simplistic propagandistic desire to create a singular "enemy" narrative to which one is righteously opposed, without having to get deep into the weeds to pick things apart. It's pathetic and elitist "analysis". There is no singular "media". There is no singular narrative. People pick the poison that fits their ideological biases. In general the ideological biases they have are the ones that fill their stomachs and keep a roof over their head. But be my guest, rant all you want about the western or "mainstream media". It won't help you convince anybody.
- lm28469 5y ago> provides basically different versions of the same content. Well yeah, they provide opinions about facts. They all select subjects from a given pool of "content" (ie. world/local events) and spin it their way. It's not like some greater entity force them to talk about a restricted set of "content"
- simion314 5y ago>Do you understand that what you are saying makes no sense? The general western media follows a coordinate coverage and provides basically different versions of the same content. This is your authoritarian thinking, at least in Europe there are political parties that are kissing Putin's ass hard and deep, so there are groups that have media control that you can chose to follow. But even those can't pretend that the reality before their eyes is fake and instead try different tactics, The Russian trol army is as pathetic as their real army, those destroyed tanks are real so you need some other bullshit excuse then west propaganda, I seen more competent trolls blaming NATO, Putin should ask you for a refund, then give you his favorite tea, really low quality trolling.
- simonh 5y agoIn the west we have access to all the media, from pretty much everybody. I don't follow it much these days, but for example Al Jazeera was a useful source during the Gulf War. You can still get RT if you want to, and their reporting is actually covered in western media too. Back when I was a student in the 80s you used to be able to get the English Language edition of Pravda at a local news agents.