5 ms·
Russia isn't exactly winning here, and russia has totally destroyed most of its soft power and degraded the impression of having a scary military in the process
by bawolff 5y ago
Russia isn't exactly winning here, and russia has totally destroyed most of its soft power and degraded the impression of having a scary military in the process.
Like if you approach from a purely machevelian perspective:
* Nato's major enemy no longer has as many friends as it used to
* NATO now can witness russia's capabilities
*NATO members are now reminded why NATO is useful. Countries who previously didn't want in, suddenly do.
I don't know what NATO did/didn't do, but the outcome so far seems like the ideal one NATO would want geopolitically, so it doesn't seem like they are inept to me.
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>degraded the impression of having a scary military They're still waving the 'we have nukes' card, so states are still scared though.
- zaarn 5y agoYou can't use that card for everything. There are well established geopolitical red lines in the sand where the nukes would be launched, have been for a long while, even during the cold war. Some poking and prodding is generally accepted, and while it will lead to escalations, it'll not lead to war. Only differing leverages politically. If on the other hand, you start waving your red nuke card for every issue you want your opinion to be accepted, then it becomes worthless. Just like in the boy who cried wolf. Where is the line in the sand for the baltic and scandinavian states wanting to join NATO? "If you join NATO, we nuke you" "If you stop trading with us, we nuke you" "If you don't stop trading with the US, we nuke you" "If you don't join the Russian Empire, we nuke you" Sure, russia can bring all those, but I doubt anything but the first one is even considerable for a state. And even then the more you wave the card the more attractive the first option of joining NATO becomes, because once you're in, Russia can't nuke you.
- ElectricalUnion 5y ago> "If you join NATO, we nuke you" I don't think this is specifically true, but being in conflict does prevents you from joining NATO.
- zaarn 5y agoNo it doesn't. You merely have to show that you're willing to resolve conflicts peacefully first. Generally so far this has meant "don't be in any conflict", but nothing stops participants from agreeing that, for example, Finland is always willing to resolve things peacefully. And after all, the threat is "if you join NATO", which means while joining NATO they aren't in a conflict, only once they joined.
- medo-bear 5y ago> degraded the impression of having a scary military in the process you dont think what happened to mariupol is scary? also i dont think that this war shows how weak russian army is (this was known before the war), but i think it shows how good ukranians can fight. personally i don't think american troops would fare much better in ukraine on the other hand what this war might show to europeans is that blindly following america comes at a pretty high cost
- krzyk 5y agoThis war shows that we can't make trade wit Russia as it is unable to exist peacefully with other countries. Complete isolation (preferable demilitarization but that is not possible until they have nukes) and just wait until it falls down again.
- HKH2 5y ago> it is unable to exist peacefully with other countries. Have you heard of the US? It is that country that keeps starting fights to maintain the petrodollar so they can print money out of thin air. They have shown that you can commit numerous crimes and still be seen as the good guys. They can even do colonization in the 21st century without anyone blinking an eyelid. Russia certainly needs to work on their PR.
- trasz 5y agoThe fact that we can’t fight one offender doesn’t mean we shouldn’t fight any of them.