2 ms·
Should we [really] embrace a cashless society? [Book: 'The Pay Off']
- mdp2021 5y ago> Digital payments leave myriad traces – traces that accumulate into vast stores of information about us. Depending on how you pay, this record may be more or less extensive and may be visible to a few or several organisations. It may comprise information that shows who you are, where you were, how much you spent, what you bought and from whom. Your smartphone might reveal just as much information, if not more, but it’s still possible to leave your device at home, or even go without one. The equivalent choice won’t be available if cash goes. // Abandoning the freedoms of cash may not be of any great concern if you’re as pure as the driven snow and not too worried about being tracked and ad-targeted, but are you ready to settle for a world in which every transaction is recorded and, by definition, controllable? Think about that the next time you choose how to pay, because each time you go cashless, your decision is helping to shape our collective future. There may come a time when we all, to paraphrase Lord Byron, have cause to lament: “Alas! how deeply public is all payment!” The original was "Alas! how deeply painful is all payment!", and a possibly preferable version would be "Alas! how deeply painful would payment become!" The authors, Natasha de Terán and Gottfried Leibbrandt, introduce in that brief their book The Pay Off - How Changing the Way We Pay Changes Everything > Leibbrandt and De Teran shine a light on the hidden workings of the humble payment - and reveal both how our payment habits are determined by history as well as where we go from here. From national customs to warring nation states, geopolitics will shape the future of payments every bit as much as technology
- WaxedChewbacca 5y ago
- raxxorraxor 5y agoCashless is not really an option in my country. For social security the state has the right to look into your complete transaction history. If someone would become unemployed and someone gave him 20$ to buy something, the state would again withdraw 20$ from the help the recipient receives. While it is the task of the state to minimize tax burden of unemployed people, it isn't difficult to imagine that this is a bit detached from reality. Sure, there is exploitation of social security, but this kind of financial surveillance of people needing help isn't conductive to a solution. So in emergencies cash is more or less required to keep people afloat. If we hadn't scrapped banking secrecy in the last decade or two, going cashless would be more viable. But to be honest, having some cash in hand still feels a lot better. Also while I support social security, there is an effect that non-wage labor cost make buying work quite expensive. So a craftsman has difficulties to pay another. He would have to work countless hours to be able to finance the work of another for a single hour. The reality is that a lot is solved with undeclared work. There is of course abuse as well, but I would say that it has become mandatory to finance a lot of services people need. Otherwise many people would not be able to pay for it. From my experience it is the urban population with lacking life experience that just sees the convenience of being cashless and doesn't even think about issues like this. Sure, if the greatest challenge is waiting in the supermarket line, cashless does seem to offer a lot.