3 ms·
A "smart contract" is merely a program. Manipulating a program or abusing it for your personal gains at the expense of others is often illegal. If you're not i
by jeroenhd 5y ago
A "smart contract" is merely a program. Manipulating a program or abusing it for your personal gains at the expense of others is often illegal.
If you're not into the cryptocurrency mess, this reads like regular old hacking. "If code is law and your code allows me to execute arbitrary SQL queries, then this SQL injection is perfectly legal" doesn't hold up in court. The FBI will not let you go because technically you only asked the remote server to execute your request.
It does invalidate the "code is law" concept, but in the real world, code isn't law.
- logifail 5y ago> Manipulating a program or abusing it for your personal gains at the expense of others is often illegal "Manipulating" doesn't seem like the right word here. This is more like a billionaire buying up a popular social media platform and then once he owns the majority of it, deciding how it should operate.
- cma 5y agoIt would be buyung up majoruty, then voting to transfer all assets to self. In non-crypto world there are minority shareholder protections that cover even someone with a 1% stake against the other at 99%.
- _aavaa_ 5y agoThis feels more like embezzlement
- bilbo0s 5y agoNot even embezzlement. Everyone put skin in the game only on the condition that the stipulations laid out in the contracts were followed. One of the stipulations was that people with more money get the most say on what to do with all the money. This was an explicit stipulation, and I can't for the life of me understand why anyone would agree to put in their resources in under such conditions, but they did. Looking at the Terms and Conditions as well as the contract, this goes under "A fool and her money". There was no embezzlement at all, this contract literally said people with more money can potentially vote to take all the money. Which is madness, but people agreed to it.
- lokar 5y agoWith a written contract actions allowed in the contract can still be considered as fraud. Making the contract a program does not change that.
- vkou 5y agoNo, this is more like someone buying up 51% of the voting shares of a public company, and then using his voting power to transfer all of the company's assets into a shell corporation that he controls, screwing the minority shareholders. Which is illegal, and will get you sued if you try it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kybernetikos 5y agoIsn't that because management of a company are required to act in the interests of all share holders? It seems like this kind of structure needs similar safeguards but I doubt that it actually does in any relevant jurisdictions at the moment.
- oneoff786 5y agoYeah but this case doesn’t involve any malicious code vulnerabilities. Code is not law, but this “attack” isn’t abusing the code so much as the basic premise of what the code is designed to do. This is the intended agreement
- teawrecks 5y ago> Manipulating a program or abusing it for your personal gains at the expense of others is often illegal. Here's the challenge, though: it is impossible to definitively say whether the functionality of a program is intended behavior or not. For a classical server that gets "hacked", the code is running on a server that someone owns and access to that server is defined by the owner. Similarly, the maintainer of the code decides whether the behavior of the code was intentional or not. On a blockchain, there is no single server, the code is being executed on many machines. And you can't trust any individual, the author of the contract got their chance to clearly describe the intention of the code when they wrote it. There is literally no way to determine whether the contract was used as intended, or exploited. You can't go ask the author because they can just lie. The code is all you have. But that doesn't mean "code is law". Consensus is law. The blockchain can be forked, the transaction reversed, and the contract amended. > in the real world, code isn't law. That hardly matters here.
- NovemberWhiskey 5y ago>Consensus is law No; the law is the law. What exactly do you intend the content of the statement 'consensus is law' to be? The world 'law' has a meaning, and it's distinct from the meaning of 'consensus'. The whole idea that you'll replace the existing legal structures with some consensus of transaction miners is some apocalyptic nerdvana with no basis in the real world.