3 ms·
It's fun to pause and reflect how much of engineering is like this. I mentor a high-school team that built a high-arc ball shooter this year. They committed to
by shadowgovt 5y ago
It's fun to pause and reflect how much of engineering is like this.
I mentor a high-school team that built a high-arc ball shooter this year. They committed to driving the function from distance to flywheel velocity using a theoretical approach: they pulled in all the Newtonian mathematics for shot angle, arc path, and the ratio of linear to angular velocity the flywheel would impart the ball leaving the chute. Put it all in one equation. I recommended it'd be simpler to do some practice shots at different distances and build a look-up table from distance to flywheel velocity (with linear interpolation for distances between the measured ones).
To their credit, their approach worked great at all but long ranges; my guess is their angle was slightly off, or they didn't account for air resistance or how back-spin on the ball might torque the path in flight. But the teams that nailed the challenge this year all did the dumb thing (took several shots at several distances and built a black-box lookup table).
And that's just for Newtonian physics over small distances and speeds with relatively mundane objects.
Theoretical modeling is vital to engineering... It's the thing that lets us extrapolate and scale. It gives us any hope at guessing at what a new design will do without having to commit the resources to just building it and seeing if it explodes. But a lot of practical engineering is coming up with clever ways to build large things out of small things that are actually, not theoretically, stress-tested.
- cs702 5y ago> coming up with clever ways to build large things out of small things that are actually, not theoretically, stress-tested. This reads like a definition of engineering.
- mech422 5y agoThat sounds like a fun project! :-) If you're doing it again next year, maybe you could do some measured shots with lookup table and compare to the existing system? Might help find the error ?