2 ms·
> Agreed, but this is such a low bar that even iOS meets it. Apple has never attempted to restrict users' ability to compile and run source code. In fact, for a
by sneak 5y ago
> Agreed, but this is such a low bar that even iOS meets it. Apple has never attempted to restrict users' ability to compile and run source code. In fact, for almost a decade now the automatic signing in Xcode will sign and provision your compiled code, even if you didn't have a verified and paid-up developer account.
The first two sentences are false.
Apple only lets iOS run signed apps. Self-built apps must be signed, and online signatures are provided from Apple. They can stop at any time. These apps will also not stay running 24/7, forcing you into Apple services if you want basic functions like messaging notifications.
You need to identify yourself to Apple (even without a paid developer account) to get an Apple ID to be able to request signatures to run those compiled programs.
Just because they hand out free temporary keys does not mean you aren't inside a jail.
- kmeisthax 5y agoIf it was actually illegal to sell computers that refused to allow self-compiled code, like the RMS comment proposes, what I stated in my original comment would be Apple's legal defense. Said hypothetical law would just mandate that Apple continue handing out provisioning profiles for self-compiled code. It would not mandate that Apple not have a code signing or provisioning regime at all; you would need a different law to do that.
- ece 5y agoIf this self provisioning profile can't use all APIs on the native OS and doesn't allow alternate OSes, it still allows plenty of room for Apple to keep doing anti-competitive, user-lockin, censorship and anti-consumer things. Apple has deleted dev accounts for pointing out pitfalls in App Store moderation, and removed an app to let you check if an iPhone was jailbroken. iMessage and iOS are equally capable of locking in users, one with network effects, and the other with the only apps that work with other Apple products. Unlocked bootloaders would allow more fair consumer choice.