4 ms·
> “A sarcophagus containing a human body is not an archaeological object. These are human remains, and while examining the sarcophagus and analysing the body an
by lostlogin 5y ago
> “A sarcophagus containing a human body is not an archaeological object. These are human remains, and while examining the sarcophagus and analysing the body and other objects inside, we must do so with respect.”
Not something I expected to read. A new attitude?
- sandworm101 5y agoWhen it is under a european cathedral it is a tomb to be respected. When it is under a african pyramid it is an archaeological site to be dug up and collected. That is not a new attitude, rather a very old one.
- apexalpha 5y agoThere's also a 3500 year difference between the two. I'm sure people living in 5022 wouldn't care much for graves from our time.
- sandworm101 5y agoAfrican. Not egyptian. And even in egypt they were being built until roughly 2000 years ago, not 3500. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nubian_pyramids https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nubian_pyramids
- apexalpha 5y agoI never said Egyptian... Also the article you linked says between 4500 and 2000 years ago. So the '3500 years' was a pretty decent guess if you ask me.
- qiskit 5y agoDepends on whether the people living in 5022 have ties/connection to us or not. "Clash over telescope at sacred Hawaiian site" "It is the burial grounds of some of our most sacred and revered ancestors" https://www.cbsnews.com/news/clash-over-telescope-at-sacred-hawaiian-site/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/clash-over-telescope-at-sacred-... Strange how hawaiians care about these ancient burial grounds and we don't? Perhaps because the US has no connection to these ancestors while the hawaiians do?
- Mikeb85 5y agoThese bodies are from ~600 years ago. Versus pyramids that are 3500-5000 years old.
- 1MachineElf 5y ago>When it is under a european cathedral it is a tomb to be respected. *was, *was >When it is under a african pyramid it is an archaeological site to be dug up and collected. *was, *was >That is not a new attitude, rather a very old one. They are explicitly saying it now because that attitude has been changing.
- travisathougies 5y agoWell, as this is under an actively used Catholic cathedral, and Catholics typically like to do our services on top of our saints, I imagine the clergy and the diocese has something to say as to how the bodies are treated.
- jimmyswimmy 5y agoInterestingly, always: a Catholic church contains an altar, the literal definition of which requires that it either contain or support the relics of saints. In other words, there are either bones in the altar or something which touched the body of a saint. Neat how the tradition had continued for so long. I wonder about how they manage to reliably source the material as well as to ensure its provenance. Supply chain is an issue everywhere!
- netsharc 5y agoThe Catholic Church is still making saints nowadays, e.g. the second to latest ex-pope (the one who didn't retire to a sanctuary to be taken care of by a cadre of single women): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_John_Paul_II#Canonisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_John_Paul_II#Canonisation
- travisathougies 5y agoYes, indeed, there's always some portion of a saint (or something having touched a saint) in the altar, stemming from the early days of the Roman church when, during Roman persecutions, the church would hold Mass/Divine Liturgy over the bodies of martyrs in the catacombs. However, most churches don't have full bodies anymore, for obvious reasons. However, when the altar is stripped (for example on Good Friday). If you were invited into the sanctuary... you would be able to see a stone, on which there is inscribed several crosses. Under each cross is a relic, set into the stone. The priest consecrates bread / wine over the stone. In terms of provenance... you can't sell a relic, but most monasteries, shrines, the Vatican, or other places that have burial records, will provide relics upon request, if available. Orders keep careful details of their martyrs and saints. So for example, a Dominican parish will often ask a Dominican priory with burials of a Dominican saint for a relic. We have indeed even entered the modern age where some monasteries / priories / convents even let priests request relics online!