6 ms·
This is only measuring mental speed, not: - Common sense - Life experience - Intelligence - Ability to listen to others - Curiosity - Empathy
by belter 5y ago
This is only measuring mental speed, not:
- Common sense
- Life experience
- Intelligence
- Ability to listen to others
- Curiosity
- Empathy
- donthellbanme 5y agoAnd the most important asset; money.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoAnd many of those degrade with age too, IQ peaks in your 20's, and I question life experience formed in the cold war, back when homosexuality was a crime and racism was common sence, houses were 2x annual income and top tax bracket was 70% If we have minimum age for participating in politics, there should be a maximum age. Set it at like 70% of life expectancy. Alternatovely, remove minimum age - I would rather have a 16 year old in parliament than a 90 year old, maybe some problems with schools will actually get addressed.
- belter 5y ago> And many of those degrade with age too, IQ peaks in your 20's Maybe true, not sure, but outcomes surely do not correlate with age. "Scientists can publish their best work at any age" https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2016.20926 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2016.20926
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoI think thats the wrong measurement - in politics a crisis happens, and you must respond withing a set amount of time. So if older people take longer to come up with sensible solution, it could be too late
- bregma 5y agoIn politics it's almost always the old people who have to come up with a sensible solution to the rash and impetuous decisions made by their younger colleagues in a time of crisis.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoWhat is the basis for this assertion? I believe the opposite is true - older politicians overhwlmingly cause a mess because they are stuck in their old ways Kennedy was 46 years old during Cuban missile crisis, he has shown restraint when many generals, significanlty older than him, advocated use of force and likely would cause a global nuclear war. Today young people overwhelmingly show the will to deal with climate change, and older generation overwhelmingly wants to continue to ignore it.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoIQ doesn't peak at any age, since its defined so that you can't really compare between people (or if you believe in such things “races“) with different (average) ages. I'm not sure why such a measurement would become the standard one for intelligence as it seems a bit useless by design.
- bbarn 5y ago> and I question life experience formed in the cold war, It's not like russia is a nuclear armed threat actively leading a war that everyone is afraid to intervene in right now... The rest of your comment here is just nonsensical name calling and assuming anyone older is automatically homophobic and racist. This kind of childish behaviour is why there are minimum ages for offices.
- ben_w 5y agoI don’t read it as “calling and assuming anyone older is automatically homophobic and racist”, merely saying those things were considered “common sense” during the Cold War. I don’t actually know the extent to which each of those things were or weren’t considered common sense in any given year in any given location, so it may be correct or false or even every combination of both, but in any case it is a very different claim.
- leaflets2 5y agoYes, @bbarn I also don't think GGP meant any of those things (Did you wake up on the wrong side today :-))
- wing-_-nuts 5y agoThe dude has a point, if offices have an age minimum, I'd argue they should have a maximum as well. IMHO nobody over the age of 70 should be in high ranking public office. Heck the average age in the senate is 63. Is there any wonder that our government is out of touch?
- tgv 5y ago> maybe some problems with schools will actually get addressed You're basically saying you mostly care about problems you have experienced, while complaining that other generations don't understand you (without any basis, I might add). That's pretty self-centered.
- engineeringwoke 5y agoUhhh the generation that we call the Baby Boomers have been in control of their respective societies for over forty years. You can see the age (and the apathy, of course) in all of them. The worst (and oldest, of course) are Japan and Italy, but it's a bad problem everywhere. I would support a maximum voting age, give the reins over to the next generation and let it go already.
- tgv 5y agoThe amount of nonsense is staggering > the generation that we call the Baby Boomers have been in control of their respective societies for over forty years So they grabbed control when they were in their 20s and didn't let go? That's a bit unlikely, isn't it? And most of the people in that generation had no power whatsoever. > You can see the age If you define a group by its age, of course you bloody can see the age. Do you add sentences in the hope that a random true one strengthens other ramblings? > and the apathy Strange. In the last years, apathy under adolescents and young adults seems to be getting out of control. Or are you calling them boomers too?
- engineeringwoke 5y agoLol why would I attempt a "conversation" with someone like this
- ben_w 5y agoIsn’t the point of democracy to align governments with the things people care about? To rely on self-centred voting averaging out over the whole population?
- leaflets2 5y ago> If we have minimum age for participating in politics, there should be a maximum age Or a test: do you know where Canada is located? The largest country (area wise) on each continent? Can multiply two double digit numbers? And some other basic things -- one would need to pass such a test to get to vote. Would reduce the likelihood that the voters change their country to a dictatorship
- jmull 5y ago> If we have minimum age for participating in politics, there should be a maximum age. Set it at like 70% of life expectancy. As if the people who actually vote are going to disenfranchise themselves. Also, your 0.7 of life expectancy is about 55-57 in the US and UK. Is that really where you think people are probably incapable of making decisions for themselves? Seems silly.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"Is that really where you think people are probably incapable of making decisions for themselves?" You don't hold public office to make decisions for yourself, you are making decisions for everyone else. Well we can argue where exactly the boundary lies, but why do you think most scams and fraudulent schemes target older peopl? They are also considered vulnerable cusotmers by UK competitions and market authority.
- jmull 5y ago> why do you think most scams and fraudulent schemes target older peopl? (1) just following the retirement money (2) student loans… crypto… mlm… home loans… plenty of scams target people at other stages in their lives. (I won’t even mention religions.)
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago> student loans… I am talking about criminal fraud, the kind that send you to jail. Either you are being disengineous and are equating crime with questionable investment strategies. Or you believe that the US government is complicit in defrauding an entire generation? I mean the latter could be a good argument for cancelling student debt.
- lordgrenville 5y agoI love quoting Hayek's suggestion that the franchise be restricted to people between ages 45-60, because young people don't have enough life experience to decide, and old people don't have a stake in the future!
- postalrat 5y ago> IQ peaks in your 20's Does that tell us more about intelligence or the testing?
- ihateolives 5y agoI'm usually not the one to think that older generation is a backwards bunch through and through but in case of many world leaders and decision makers I'll make an exception. > Common sense We're having a frigging climate crisis and still not acting on it. So - nope. > Life experience From different era where world was a bit different, slower paced and pretty much black and white with two genders, fossil fuels and without those pesky women, gays and other minorities raising their voices. > Ability to listen to others This would presuppose empathy. > Curiosity As on having open mind to new ways of doing things? Nope. > Empathy Straight out nope again. Much, if not most of world's problems are exactly because of the lack of empathy for our fellow man and disregard for the future i.e. their own children. Nope, empathy is nowhere to be seen. Geriatrics in power seem to make very slow and very wrong choices.
- inglor_cz 5y ago"without those pesky women, gays and other minorities raising their voices." Consult the calendar. When Joe Biden was young, the Sixties were in full swing and the voices you mention were already pretty loud. They didn't have overwhelming results yet, but the path towards them was already being very visibly trod. What you describe was an even earlier world - and we do not have that many centenarians in positions of power. Queen Elizabeth is pretty much the only important head of state to be still surviving from that period.
- Ensorceled 5y ago> Queen Elizabeth is pretty much the only important head of state to be still surviving from that period. Even then, the Quiet Generation built things; roads, schools, libraries, arenas and institutions that are being destroyed by under-funding and neglect.
- oneoff786 5y agoJoe biden was pro segregation back in the day
- fipar 5y agoYour first paragraph targets world leaders but then your comments seem a bit ageist to me when IMHO they apply to most people regardless of age: > We're having a frigging > climate crisis and still > not acting on it. So -nope. Last time I was at a tech conference (fortunately years ago) the bulk of the audience and speakers were people in their 30s or younger and a lot of them had traveled long distances to get there. A few were frequent conference speakers traveling several times per year, all in very climate-unfriendly airplanes. I see a lot of people under 30 who get expensive ICE cars as they progress in their careers, not to mention that if they have a good career in terms of revenue they’re most likely involved in something that negatively affects climate. I could go on. > From different era where > world was a bit different, slower paced and pretty much black and white with two genders, fossil fuels and without those pesky women, gays and other minorities raising their voices. Civil rights are surely not an invention of the current young generation. I’d argue that if we have a more vocal civil rights/social justice movement now it is thanks to all the people who are now over 70 or even dead and who were fighting that fight in more conservative times. This is also not something that’s uniformly distributed in the world or even in “civilized” places (sadly, I’d add), as I keep stumbling upon very young (decades younger than me) bigots far more frequently than I’d like (ok, to be honest, I’d like that frequency to be 0). > This would presuppose empathy. If all the young people you interact with are emphatic you’ve no idea how lucky you are. Suffice to say that school continues to be hell to a lot of weird kids right this very moment, that ain’t a problem that went away. That’s because most people are bigoted regardless of their age. If anything, I’ve seen a-holes become a bit less of that as they grow older. > Geriatrics in power seem to make very slow and very wrong choices I’ll take the role of unsolicited editor to your comment and suggest that you just say “People in power seem to make very slow and very wrong choices”, that would make it accurate.
- goodpoint 5y agoIs that sarcasm? "Ability to listen to others" and especially "Empathy" are the very opposite attributes of people "running all major world powers right now"
- ben_w 5y agoWhile it certainly feels like that when you’re in a particular politician’s out-group, I think they literally could not even get to play on the national political stage without being really good at those behaviours. Even the worst politicians, those that I personally hate with vitriol, those whom I doubt even have a rich inner mental world, absolutely do demonstrate listening to the person in front of them. It may not be real empathy, just affectation, but the effect of the affect is the same on the support base they need in order to get elected, or in some cases even chosen as a candidate.
- belter 5y agoIt's not sarcasm, because my comment was not if the persons politically in charge of the major world powers, have those traits in the correct measure. I was pointing to the fact the paper is not measuring those traits, and they are certainly more important than mental speed. And even that, the paper says until 60 only decreases as older persons take more time to more carefully consider their decisions. OP seemed to be worried that as they are older, the paper would imply their mental ability was somewhat diminished or less capable, and I pointed to other traits very important, the paper does not analyze.
- samus 5y agoThey absolutely need those abilities. How else to judge who is safe to ally with, and for how long, and when your underlings start to rebel against you? Insult them however you want, but don't underestimate them. Or the powers behind their thrones!
- goodpoint 5y agoWhat you described has little to do with empathy.