4 ms·
Hmm. I think the main reason Trek could be set on an Earth is the exact reason it shouldn’t be: at it’s best, it is an allegory for our world, with just enough
by ben_w 5y ago
Hmm.
I think the main reason Trek could be set on an Earth is the exact reason it shouldn’t be: at it’s best, it is an allegory for our world, with just enough latex to pretend that the Klingons aren’t the Russians (Rura Penthe being Siberia, Praxis being Chernobyl); that the Romulans aren’t the Chinese; that the Cardassians aren’t the Old World imperial powers retreating from their colonies, and so on.
Put it back on Earth, and it will all be too on-the-nose.
That said, I do share Stross’ annoyance with the use of tech as a magic wand, though in my case my problem is with the inconsistency. For example, in Voyager in particular, in the pilot episode they say the ship has a maximum cruising speed of warp 9.975, not only do they never ever go that fast in the show, if you look up how fast that’s supposed to be, it would get them home in 7 years without any shortcuts or shenanigans, not the 70 years they say at the end of the episode.
Plus, they have time travel and stasis and Voyager could therefore get home in zero subjective time.
And every episode involving time travel in all seasons of all series, they always use the same mechanism for going backwards and forwards in time, sometimes even using the difficulties of this as a challenge to be overcome in the plot even though the show has had the go-fast-around-a-star method on record since TOS.
- traverseda 5y agoWho are the Ferengi?
- morelisp 5y agoRather than the "obvious" answer from unfortunate casting decisions, by the middle of the series they're firmly 20th century Americans.
- coding123 5y agoCorporate greed
- morelisp 5y agoThey're certainly capitalists, but despite lots of references to stock markets, the Nagus's holdings, etc., we don't see them forming, discussing, or dealing with a lot of corporations. Quark and his more distant relatives are firmly petit bourgeoisie, Brunt is middle management at something like a brown-collar job, etc. The fascism of Cardassia and cooperative structure of the Federation both ring more corporate than the Ferengi, most of the time.
- jeramey 5y agoAmericans. The primary social measuring stick used is acquisition of wealth, and they have no real social safety nets to speak of. They have an overriding belief that free markets will ultimately solve any real problems peacefully. Grift is sometimes (ok often) admired and winked at, though generally officially denounced. There are substantial oppressive problems with regards to females fully participating equally in society, and they’re slow to change but there are occasional signs of progress and leaders bucking those trends. Sounds a lot like my American culture to me!
- ben_w 5y agoI would say specifically late 1800s to early 1900s American, when unions were busted with guns and women had zero political power. I can’t remember Brent Spiner’s original lines in the episode the Ferengi were introduced, but I think it was something along the lines of “all the bad bits of the old west and none of the good bits”.
- Stevvo 5y ago“Ferengi are us. That’s the gag, the Ferengis are humans. They’re more human than the humans on Star Trek because they’re so screwed up and they’re so dysfunctional. They’re regular people.” - Steven Behr
- iso1210 5y agoAmerican capitalists, specifically Yankee Traders. Data literally says so in TNG.
- dumpsterlid 5y agoI definitely don't object to the "Star Trek is inconsistent with the rules it sets out for its universe argument" but also... it is a massive series so after a certain point I don't care. You don't watch Star Trek for that.
- Stevvo 5y agoI guess you have not seen season 2 of Picard; they just used the go-fast-around-a-star method from TOS again. Why this method is not usually used makes up a part of the plot.
- ben_w 5y agoWhile I have indeed not seen season 2, that they used it was clear from the very trailer that told me I didn’t want to watch it. Good to know they give a reason why it’s hardly ever used.
- matt-attack 5y agoNot sure it was used in TOS. It was however used in Star Trek IV.
- ben_w 5y agoAt least twice in TOS, the first accidental, the second deliberate (and the latter episode doubled as a failed pilot for a spin off): https://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/treknology/timetravel-tos.htm https://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/treknology/timetravel-tos...
- b3morales 5y agoExactly, allegory: TNG and DS9 in particular have episodes about some pretty hot-button topics. Political terrorism; assisted suicide; gender identity and relations; religious rights; capital punishment, and the justice system in general; mental health; environmentalism... The veneer of the transporter and the rubber foreheads provide just enough distance for these things to be portray-able without everyone having an immediate hot take reaction and turning their brains off. They wouldn't work if they were put in an Earthbound setting: they'd be too real, too inflammatory. I agree that the technobabble can be annoying, and there's certainly fluff in there. But Roddenberry wanted to tell stories about us as we are, and as we could be, just as much as Stross: he just approached it from a different angle.
- jl6 5y agoYou can still derive some fun from the nonsense and self-contradictions by trying to work out reasons for it. For example, maybe warp 9.975 can only be sustained for a limited time or distance. There’s a whole usenettish genre of Trek apologetics dedicated to this kind of thing.