2 ms·
Good response. But incorrect, I think. While it is true that "the human story" does endure (c.f. Shakespeare, Beowulf, 1001 nights et al.), there is nearly alw
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Good response.
But incorrect, I think. While it is true that "the human story" does endure (c.f. Shakespeare, Beowulf, 1001 nights et al.), there is nearly always a context that affects how the characters behave. Even though both the best and the worst of human behavior may never change, the range of possible actions, and their side-effects and implications, change accordingly to the technological context.
Consider a world where technology allows you travel around the planet in minutes. How does this affect the relationship between place and human activity? When you can have lunch in Paris even in you work in Tokyo, what does that mean? How does it affect the notion of communities, and in turn, child-rearing? [0]
Yes, even with that far-fetched scenario, humans will still be humans. There will be jealousy, love, murder, greed, tenderness etc. etc. But that still leaves plenty of scope for people's actions and choices to differ dramatically, even if they are driven by the same old emotions and allegiances. That's what make sci-fi interesting: what would you do if <X> was possible? what would you do if <Y> was now impossible?
Stross' objections to ST are really along the lines that these questions are meaningless in the sense that the characters' actions are essentially identical to what they would be in a time with totally different technology. Nothing about the sci-fi setting has any real impact on what choices they make. I might not agree with this entirely (transporter beams do open up some possibilities that would otherwise be unavailable), but I think Stross has a point that there's really no sense to sci-fi if it's literally just a retelling of an existing story with the tech doing the tech-tech tech thing.
[0] the Terra Ignota series by Ada Palmer
- dumpsterlid 5y ago"Stross' objections to ST are really along the lines that these questions are meaningless in the sense that the characters' actions are essentially identical to what they would be in a time with totally different technology." They aren't though? Like what about Data?? There is a fundamental issue with the logic here that Stross is equating not explaining future tech in a believable, consistent way with characters not being meaningfully changed by the technology. Fantasy could not exist as a genre if one equalled the other.
- ozim 5y agoStross just dug hard into elitism bullshit. Much better Sci-Fi writers were writing basic fundamental social science fiction where sci-fi setting was just a stage.