3 ms·
how did that pushback look like? to old? failed technology? i saw a lot of excitement around VRML at the university in the late 90s. the problem was that aver
by em-bee 5y ago
how did that pushback look like? to old? failed technology?
i saw a lot of excitement around VRML at the university in the late 90s.
the problem was that average computers just didn't have the capacity for 3d rendering back then. at the university we had high end SGI workstations, and of course these were used for impressive demonstrations of what VRML could do. but i guess because noone outside had computers capable enough it didn't catch on.
the current generation is not aware of what we did back then and may not realize that lack of performance was the primary problem we were facing.
- mathgladiator 5y agoThere's a bunch I can't really say, but I think a bunch of forms from bad incentives which don't align to any long term goals. My opinion is that the key idea of the metaverse definitely requires a standard like HTML which people can just hack on with text files. X3D is the closest in my opinion of achieving that, and I argued we should make X3D a first class citizen to overcome performance challenges of the browser/device. Even today, pick whatever web framework, and it just boils down to HTML. There really should be a common 3D substrate that is that easy.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoGamers often bought 3D cards for PCs by the late nineties.
- KerrAvon 5y agoLet’s stipulate for the purpose of this discussion that VRML is satisfactory, though IIRC it isn’t for various reasons. The real problem in the 90’s and today is that we haven’t figured out user interface hardware that people can/want to actually use for extended periods of time. Even today, literally every player in this space thinks it’s going to be a head mounted display/goggles/glasses. Until someone produces 3D/holo displays that don’t require gadgets affixed to your head and body in one way or another, I think AR/VR is going to be a failure for general consumer use no matter how slick the underlying rendering technology. Edited to add: something like Tilt5 where it’s very inexpensive and you aren’t expected to wear the device forever might be an exception.
- em-bee 5y agoi agree that VR is still far away from taking off. i expect the solution is going to be something like CAVE, which we already had working in the 90s. by today it is feasible to have a 4-sided projector mounted in a room so that you can project a 3d environment to multiple walls and give you the feeling of being inside. 3D glasses like those used in movies today are light enough to help with the 3D effects too. but VRML wasn't just for VR. we are playing 3D games without VR for quite some time now, and there is no reason we couldn't use VRML or X3D today to create interesting experiences. in the end it comes down to how easy it is to create and distribute the content. what we need is another drive into browser support where we can embed a 3D object easily, and then maybe it will catch on.