4 ms·
Monkeys can sense their own heartbeats
- kazinator 5y agoWhich monkeys? If they are ones that can already pass the mirror test, this doesn't seem like anything astonishing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_test
- curl-up 5y agoI've always wondered, but could never find good sources on this: couldn't MSR results simply be produced by mirror neurons firing? I.e., touching a marked part of the body does not mean "Animal in the mirror is me", it can simply mean "Marked part of that animal is 'itching' me"? Similarly to how amputees can "scratch their itch" in an amputated limb by observing another person scratching themselves. Are there MSR tests that used windows to other animals/puppets with marked spots instead of mirrors as a control?
- kazinator 5y agoMost of the criticisms of the technique revolve around false negatives, but you bring up an interesting point. Still, "marked part of the animal is itching me" shows that the animal can identify a marked body part in the image (e.g. forehead) and indicate the corresponding part on it own body. The "self" concept has to be involved there to some degree even if not to the point of "the animal I see is actually me".
- curl-up 5y agoMirror neurons seem to be the primary mechanism of learning from other members of the group. So in a sense, every species able to learn from others (by replicating the behaviour) would automatically also be able to identify the "self"? This seems like a too broad "definition", but maybe it actually isn't at all (i.e., maybe learning by replicating is actually a "stronger" condition than knowing about self). When I mentioned the "itch", it was mainly about the reflex a lot of animals have, not a "conscious identification". Think about reflexively licking your lips when you see someone else get sauce/cream/beer-foam on their lips, or even the reflex of getting aroused when observing others being aroused?
- practice9 5y agoI wonder if they tested other animals like dogs or cats
- temptemptemp111 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 11235813213455 5y agoIsn't it the case for all humans? as I'm writing this, I can just sense each of my heart beats vibrations, I don't even need to put my finger on my throat
- ben_w 5y agoI can even see it, close to the knobbly bit of my tibia on my ankle, when I sit in the right posture.
- OJFord 5y agoThe article isn't saying 'wow, monkeys can do this amazing thing we cannot', it's saying 'wow, monkeys have the awareness of their heart beat, something that's integral to them, too'. It's hard to phrase because obviously the claim isn't they understand what it is etc.
- permalac 5y agoI hope so, otherwise I will need to see a doctor
- asveikau 5y agoI think some times I feel it more than others. Certainly if it's beating fast I notice much more than resting. I think at rest I tend to notice it indirectly, particularly how it makes my body move or noticing it alongside a deep breath.
- vasco 5y agoA good heuristic for life: Whenever you think you can do something or feel something more or better than average, assume you don't. If for some reason verifying it would actually impact your life, try to find definite proof for it, but otherwise this type of thinking is generally detrimental as you end up with snowflake syndrome and will ignore meaningful statistics or advice as "not applicable to you" when in all likelihood you're just like everyone else.
- asveikau 5y ago
- seanwilson 5y agoMust be fun coming up with ways to test ideas like this: > We first got our monkeys to sit in chairs in front of a computer screen and hooked them up to electrocardiograms to monitor their heartbeats. Then we played videos of either a yellow or green cloud bouncing up and down accompanied by beeping sounds. Sometimes we would sync the bouncing and beeping to match the monkey’s heartbeat, and at other times they were out of sync. > We then used eye trackers to measure how long the monkeys looked at the images. If the monkeys had a sense of their own heartbeats, they would find the in-sync bouncing less interesting and novel than the out-of-sync bouncing and so would spend more time looking at the out-of-sync image. I wonder if you could get them to tap along or similar to a sensor that was beeping to their heart beat where you made the beep quieter and quieter until eventually silent.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jjtheblunt 5y agoso can we primates, no?