4 ms·
i think its time we admitted that nobody wants a facebook clone. it doesn't matter how distributed it is, how open it is, how shiny it is, or anything else. n
by notatoad 15y ago
i think its time we admitted that nobody wants a facebook clone. it doesn't matter how distributed it is, how open it is, how shiny it is, or anything else. nobody is going to replace facebook with a product that is essentially facebook. if google can't do it, a couple kids aren't going to do it either.
the next social networking phenomenon will be something new, not a new implementation of something old, and it's time to stop trying to re-invent old things.
- wmf 15y agoLooking at the screenshots I'd say Diaspora is now a Google+ clone.
- glassx 15y agoNot really. Diaspora already had most of its design in place, including the drag-and-drop 'Circles' feature (called Aspects in Diaspora), before Google+ was even announced.
- libraryatnight 15y agoYes, exactly. Many Diaspora users were posting about Google+ ripping them off.
- michaelchisari 15y agoWhich is pretty ridiculous, since Appleseed had circles since 2007, and I know Diaspora was aware of Appleseed before they released any code. Also, I spoke with someone from Google about Appleseed's circles two months before Diaspora even released any code. Not that I'm claiming that Google+ stole Appleseed's idea for circles, since they put out a presentation in June 2010 talking about social segmentation from a theoretical perspective, and even if they did, it wouldn't raise much ire, since I stole the idea from Livejournal's friends list, which it had since, what, 2000? There was a lot of precedence for groupings of social relationships, and honestly, I was shocked at the hubris of the Diaspora* team to claim that Google had pilfered them for inspiration.
- notatoad 15y agoand g+ is a facebook clone. by the transitive property...
- guelo 15y agoA lot of people hate Facebook and would love to leave. The problem is that the network effect is very strong.