7 ms·
Birds Aren’t Real took on the conspiracy theorists
- ibz 5y agoConspiracy theorists aren't real. My theory is that they are a fabrication meant to make us disprove anything that goes against the mainstream narrative. In reality, the truth is always somewhere in the middle.
- christophilus 5y agoConspiracy theorists are created by the deep state in order to make the rest of us feel secure in our smugness.
- fumar 5y agoWhat is the mainstream narrative?
- ycombinete 5y agoEducate yourself please, sheeple
- noworriesnate 5y agoDo you have a source on that? Sources are important[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [1] https://googlethatforyou.com/?q=are%20sources%20important https://googlethatforyou.com/?q=are%20sources%20important [2] https://poop.is/elementaryly-rapid https://poop.is/elementaryly-rapid [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/NCIS_(TV_series) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/NCIS_(TV_series) [4] https://poop.is/raggedly-anguished https://poop.is/raggedly-anguished [5] https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/research_and_citation/mla_style/mla_formatting_and_style_guide/mla_general_format.html https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/research_and_citation/mla_style/m...
- atoav 5y agoAlways the one on the other political side.
- JasonFruit 5y agoWhat is the other side? I only see the War Party.
- atoav 5y agoThe other side is the one that does not support one of the established parties.
- krapp 5y agoAnything the deepfake CIA holograms on mainstream media tell you.
- criddell 5y agoBirds are real.
- kingcharles 5y agoHey, everyone! This guy thinks bird are real! LOL
- micromacrofoot 5y agodo your own research
- revolvingocelot 5y ago>In reality, the truth is always somewhere in the middle I've always held that lizard people control some of the government, and that the moon landing was fake but obviously shot on location.
- irrational 5y agoHmm, birds are fake, birds are dinosaurs, dinosaurs look like lizards, therefore lizard people are fake.
- sn41 5y agoDinosaurs never died. They just became the world government. (/s)
- peteradio 5y agoToo big to fail
- b112 5y agoBy Gregory Peck's left ear, please stop!
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoThey just turned into pigeons, really.
- akomtu 5y agoYour theory doesn't explain how some birds became alligators.
- krapp 5y ago>and that the moon landing was fake but obviously shot on location. Stanley Kubrick is nothing if not a true auteur. Also probably eats mice whole.
- redisman 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oneoff786 5y ago> In reality, the truth is always somewhere in the middle This is a dumb take in the context of outlandish conspiracy theories.
- irrational 5y agoThey are clearly joking. They start off with conspiracy theorists not being real.
- oneoff786 5y agoI don’t think they’re joking. I would be curious to hear from them. A lot of conspiracy theorists think they’re in the middle. They identify some crazies in their group but still hang out with them and use their presence to justify their own, still extreme, opinions as the moderate view.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI don't think they were joking either — is incongruous with their first statement. Calling it a "dumb take" however is more likely to invite fighting rather than discussion. Is there any historical evidence that the conspiracy theorists were ever half-right (or right at all)? To be sure, there have been conspiracies in the past but our inability to keep a secret seems to have always trumped attempts to conceal (but IANAH, I am not a historian).
- oneoff786 5y agoIt’s a well established source of bias, especially in media. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_balance https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_balance You should not assume views have merit by default.
- irrational 5y agoWait, do we mean different things by conspiracy theorists not being real? Because, otherwise, I can’t see how you can think this is not a joke. I think they mean there literally are no people alive/real that hold conspiracy theory views. Clearly there are real people who espouse conspiracy theories, therefore OP must be joking.
- drewcoo 5y agoThere is no middle. Only outsides. Like a klein bottle but also not.
- bee_rider 5y agoJokes aside, I'd be 0% surprised if there were some famous conspiracy theorists who were on various intelligence agencies payrolls to draw attention and make the idea of a conspiracy look silly.
- h2odragon 5y agoThere's also some "voluntary cover" involved; people who know things are eager to tell what they know as well as avoid the consequences. So they're likely to add a dose of crazy too, to disassociate what might be recognizably their experiences into something they can deny at need. Few people tell their stories with full fidelity anyway, we gloss over our mistakes and make everything better and less banal by instinct.
- ratsmack 5y ago>Conspiracy theorists aren't real. There are some real nut cases out there, like the whole "Q" thing. But I think that the true believers and the most fervently vocal ones are a fairly small minority and the rest look at it the same way as Santa and the Easter bunny.
- JKCalhoun 5y ago> the rest look at it the same way as Santa and the Easter bunny. Ha ha, as an atheist, I chuckled at where you stopped. After unraveling the Santa Conspiracy as a child I began to question all of our other "cultural lore". Like the Easter Bunny.
- brnaftr361 5y agoIf you tear off enough of the sheeting everything is a form of myth. Order and authority, the language and how we justify it all.
- MauranKilom 5y agohttps://xkcd.com/690/ https://xkcd.com/690/
- throttledagain2 5y ago
- ngcc_hk 5y agoFake news worked. That is Hans dynasty and one of the scholar insisted on the old idea that emperor has to give up his seat to the whatsoever good guy, like the legendary 3 kings pre-history. One did handover to the scholar proposing this. No bloodshed. I think it is the most peaceful handover of sovereign of million people in the ancient history. Just keep on talking and one day people may find sone bird are just drone. And all are. And hacker news are just fake news about real news. It is human after all.
- boredumb 5y agoIt's all fun and games until the NSA actually creates bird drones for spying on citizens for the sake of national security and any one who identifies them are labeled insane and have their rights stripped and shipped to a oil refinery in north dakota.
- fullshark 5y agoOr the NSA commits illegal massive surveillance at a global scale, and an NSA analyst reveals it then gets asylum in Russia and US citizens shrug and move on forgetting it ever happened.
- riku_iki 5y ago> NSA commits illegal massive surveillance at a global scale has illegality been proven? From what I could find they performed surveillance under FISA warrants. There are obviously greater conspiracy theories, but are they supported by evidence?
- drdeca 5y agoAiui, A number of their actions were later ruled unconstitutional (with no punishment)?
- riku_iki 5y agoMaybe you have a chance to provide any specific reference to see if it is related to Snowden disclosure?
- smegger001 5y agoa court that literally rubber stamped everything brought to it without even looking at it yeah...
- riku_iki 5y agoIt doesn't mean it is illegal.
- omosubi 5y agoI miss the left that took Chomsky's "manufacturing consent" seriously
- _ofdw 5y ago[flagged]
- naoqj 5y ago"Everybody who voted for a candidate who I don't like is a sociopath" is not a good recipe for nuance.
- _ofdw 5y ago>"Everybody who voted for a candidate who I don't like is a sociopath" That's neither an accurate nor a very charitable interpretation of what I wrote, but I suppose I expect no less from HN. "Right wing sociopaths exist" != "All republican voters are sociopaths"
- dundarious 5y agoI think people who self-identify as lefties still do, but they’ve had almost no political influence since LBJ left office, so since before its publication (I know that seems like a contradiction in order of events, but I just mean the constituents of the same political tendency over time). What is termed “the left” in popular news media definitely does not, but that has been the case practically since it’s publication. Since the Clinton turn at least.
- wyldfire 5y ago> This is the fourth interview McIndoe has given as himself, not his conspiracist character. The fact that he occasionally does sincere interviews and then goes on to (back in character) deny that the interview took place seems a little unhealthy. I know it's all a big joke but it just feels like real people could fall into this satire conspiracy theory when he attacks the credibility of legitimate journalists.
- low_tech_love 5y agoI think it’s part of the joke (and by consequence of real life conspiracy theories) that you will never know for sure what is the true. Good, lasting CTs are by definition impossible to disprove completely. It is up to you to decide what is real without anyone telling you. It is a good exercise.
- fullshark 5y agoMore likely he likes attention and lifts the veil if the profiler has enough juice (Guardian-yes, your podcast-no).
- choko 5y agoThe flat earthers did it first and did it better. The fact that most people think that the flat earthers are mostly serious makes it a more clever satire. I'm sure many people are ready to point out that there are actually people that believe the satire, but that's true of most satire.
- lalaland1125 5y agoThere are very serious flat earthers out there. Generally the religious ones. The people quoting Bible verses to "prove" a flat earth are generally unironic
- choko 5y agoSee my first comment. There are always people that will take a joke seriously. That doesn't make it any less a joke. The fact that YOU can't distinguish it as a joke merely lends credit to my point.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- efrafa 5y agoReminds me my fav band https://youtu.be/6hGcUUM2DkQ https://youtu.be/6hGcUUM2DkQ
- Epiphany21 5y agoThe whole "birds are fake" thing is a long running and largely apolitical joke that predates 2017 by at least a decade. That's where this Peter guy got the idea from in the first place. The Guardian is complete trash. They will write anything and pass it off as factual to get clicks. It's nakedly propagandistic in its attempt to tie every unpopular idea back into one public personality (Trump) and push petty tribalism that way. There is no large group of Trump supporters/voters who believe birds are battery powered. Not everyone you politically disagree with is a moron who lacks agency.
- j4yav 5y agoQanon is a better example of lots of people believing some really outlandish stuff and aligning it closely with politics. Flat earth is also interesting because it tends to be correlated with strongly religious.
- Epiphany21 5y agoI've yet to see any kind of productive or useful discourse come out of mainstream media in regards to the Q nonsense. That kind of stuff can't gain traction under a system that prides itself on truth and transparency. Same goes for the COVID-19 related tensions that culminated in pitiful US vaccination rates and people eating animal-grade deworming paste. The underlying problems are not really so partisan in nature. >Flat earth is also interesting because it tends to be correlated with strongly religious. I think it would be more interesting to see how many of them haven't been on a plane and how long ago they last read non-fiction literature.
- djanogo 5y agoIt's amazing how these trash authors keep doing this, find individual who talks about conspiracy or believes in weird stuff and tie him to Trump or Rush or voted certain side, it helps keep their readers in their bubble.
- NoboruWataya 5y agoI'm fairly sure this is also just the latest in a series of articles the Guardian have run about "movements" that are really just trending subreddits. I might be misremembering that but they definitely had one about r/antiwork, which in fairness was also covered by other media and had a lot more potential to turn into an actual movement than this. I think the new strategy is just to write about any and every internet phenomenon as if it is the harbinger of a revolution. 1% of the time (Qanon, GME) you'll get it right and look like incredibly prescient. The other articles will be forgotten.
- sircastor 5y agoI used to think conspiracy theorists were just nuts until the Snowden NSA leaks. I still think most conspiracies are total bunk (obviously), but I admit finding out the kind (and scope) of surveillance that the NSA was engaged in had made me a little more willing to believe some things.
- cpfohl 5y agoConspiracies and conspiracy theories are different. People actually conspire to do all sorts of things, all over the world. Conspiracy theories are different, though because they start with a “what if” and move to belief instead of starting from evidence and moving to belief. At least, this is the way I define the terms.
- craig1f 5y agoI think you have the right definition here. People aren't rational. They are rationalizers. Rational thinking is when you use facts and draw a conclusion. Rationalizing is when you have a conclusion, and you work backwards to justify it with rational-sounding arguments. Conspiracy theories start with some ridiculous conclusion, and work backwards to make it sound intelligent. It's not intelligent, but it SOUNDS intelligent.
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y ago> People aren't rational. They are rationalizers In college we had to read Freud's Civilization and its Discontents for a literature class. The only thing I remember about that entire book was him saying that no matter what, if people wanted to do something, they would find a way to rationalize it to themselves to avoid cognitive dissonance. That one concept has been illustrated over and over in the 30 years since!
- alexdowad 5y agoI think two important points which distinguish many implausible conspiracy theories from real conspiracies are 1) disregard for what humans are actually capable of doing and 2) not having any reasonable motive to attribute to the purported conspirators. Any theory which alleges that some group of people secretly controls the world falls under #1. Trying to keep just 50 or 100 people organized and getting them to all do what you want is incredibly hard, let alone the entire world. An example of #2: Here in Zambia, when the government started offering free COVID-19 vaccines, various conspiracy theories spread on social media: some said that anyone who accepted the vaccine would turn into a chimpanzee, others said that their bodies would become magnetic and attract iron objects, while others said that vaccinated persons would become sterile and be unable to produce children. I don't think any advocate of these theories ever explained why the government would want to turn their citizens into chimpanzees, though.
- js2 5y ago> “Yeah, they’re role-playing together. They’re role-playing the collective understanding of the conspiracy theory.” This is how the flat-Earthers started, isn't it? But every parody eventually runs into Poe's law. I love sarcasm. My daughter loves it too. We sometimes engage in conversation where we're both clearly being sarcastic, but we get increasingly dead pan about it till neither of us is quite sure if the other is still being sarcastic. She termed this a "sarcasm trap" a few years ago. We find it fun to see how far we can take it. Birds Aren't Real seems way too on the nose for anyone to mistake it as serious, but there are some truly naive/gullible people in the world.
- b3morales 5y agoMost definitely. Feels like an old comment of mine is relevant here again https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27731523 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27731523 Foucault's Pendulum is a (fiction) book about some "Birds Aren't Real"-type protagonists who cross paths with people who went down the rabbit hole. They try to play their own game while staying separate from it. It does not end well.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dharmab 5y agoA friend of mine works with a person who seems to honestly believe Birds Aren't Real (at least in part). I made a joke about this when we were fighting bird monsters in a video game and he groaned and told me the story.
- photochemsyn 5y agoAny time you see 'conspiracy theorist' in a media context you should stop and remember that virtually every FBI indictment ever handed down includes 'conspiracy to commit mail fraud'. In this context, conspiracy simply refers to two or more people working together to conduct a criminal activity. However, FBI agents are not generally referred to as 'conspiracy theorists' even though their job is to investigate actual conspiracies. The sociocultural use of the phrase 'conspiracy theory' is of course quite different. It's much more like a critique of religious belief - i.e. the notion there's an all-powerful, all-seeing force behind all events. Could it be the UFO aliens? Black helicopter-flying government agencies? The ancient gods and goddesses of Greek and Egyptian and Hindu theology? The more recent avatars of the Abrahamic traditions? Now, today's media probably consists mostly of people for whom (Frank Herbert quote here) "religion is a kind of puppet show to amuse the populace and keep it docile, and who believe essentially that all phenomena - even religious phenomena - can be reduced to mechanical explanations." Even so, it's unlikely that the Guardian would describe the religious beliefs of millions of their readers as 'conspiracy theories' as the phrase is perjorative and intended to belittle or disparage. Regardless, some large-scale 'conspiracy theories' seem to have quite a bit of truth to them. For example, consider the notion that there was a deliberate conspiracy to fabricate evidence of WMDs in Iraq c. 2002-2003 run by the American and British governments in collusion with corporate media outlets from the NYTimes to FOX News and the BBC. Is that a 'conspiracy theory' or a credible allegation that still deserves serious criminal investigation?
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoThe track record on “conspiracy theories” is recently very poor. So the current use of the phrase has an immediate stink to me now. For every vocal “5G causes cancer idiots” there are a thousand silent “well, with my own eyes I am watching a video of Hunter Biden smoking crack sitting on a bed talking to a naked prostitute explaining about how people stole his last laptop during an 18 day bender and are now black mailing him, so, no, I don’t think this whole laptop thing actually “Russian Disinformation””… but it seems the practice is just lump both of those things together now. Something I learned early is that character means the things you do when no one is looking (pay attention here to the reaction). People that still want to hide the Hunter Biden stuff here and elsewhere don’t believe it’s a consultancy theory, they just want to censor it. Still call it the same thing because achieves the goal.
- yeezyseezy 5y agoI’m relieved to see the comments here are not as pro “blindly trust the government” as The Guardian is.
- bobthechef 5y ago[dead]
- guilhas 5y agoFunny how dumb theories are always get attention while actual theories that might affect people lives are ignored, ridiculed, discussion banned, fact checked... Trump Is Right About the Deep State. Thank God! https://slate.com/culture/2022/04/ukraine-ambassador-marie-yovanovitch-trump-deep-state-memoir.html https://slate.com/culture/2022/04/ukraine-ambassador-marie-y...
- PolygonSheep 5y agoWhat actually causes Flat Earth/Qanon/Lizard People/5G coronavirus/whatever? Is it a manifestation of mental illness and therefore some defect in brain chemistry or structure, in which case they need psychiatry more than fact checking? Is this not some kind of schizophrenia variant but maybe a pseudoreligion which fills the hole that in an earlier era might have been filled with fire and brimstone Baptist bible thumping or End Times theology, except Alex Jones got to them before the preacher did? Is it an information problem? Did their fourth grade science teacher just not do a very good job of explaining how Foucault's pendulum works and now they are into Flat Earth and all the rest but they can still be saved if we can just get them to read the Snopes article debunking it? How many are doing this just to be edgy (while possibly attracting some followers in the above three groups in a symbiotic relationship), because it's a pretty easy way to get media attention right now? Come up with some ridiculous stuff about the Flat Earth 5G Dead Internet Bird Hoax and The Guardian/NYT/WaPo/etc will write a bunch of hand-wringing articles fretting about the latest disinformation campaign which has been debunked six ways to Sunday by all right-thinking people. How else can you be transgressive and shocking in the 2020s?
- toomanyrichies 5y agoI keep thinking about the old poster in Fox Mulder’s office from the show “The X-Files”, the one that said “I Want To Believe”. I suspect that the reason it featured so prominently in that film set is because showrunner Chris Carter was making a statement about the mentality of conspiracy theorists. The phrasing of that poster is very specific. These people aren’t objectively and dispassionately weighing the evidence both in favor of and against a certain theory. No, that theory is their pet theory, and whether consciously or subconsciously, their thumb is on the scale in favor of proving it true. The reason being that an implication of most conspiracy theories is that there is a conspiracy of powerful people to keep the truth from being revealed. I’ve come to believe THAT is the important component of any conspiracy. The specific “truth” which is being hidden, whether it’s aliens or lizard people or pedophiles running a pizza shop, is almost a McGuffin. The reason people believe conspiracy theories, and backwards-rationalize their perceived truthfulness, is that it helps them believe in some all-powerful, malevolent cabal whose agenda includes keeping down the “little guy”. It’s a way for them to justify the failures in their lives without having to take responsibility for those failures. It’s the oldest story in the book. It doesn’t help that there are real-world examples of conspiracies that have been proven true, but I suspect it wouldn’t be a deal-breaker for these people even if that weren’t the case.