3 ms·
"Do you have an argument against redistribution that isn't "I disagree with what the public wants"?" I'm a part of the public, and I don't want it. I imagine t
by giantg2 5y ago
"Do you have an argument against redistribution that isn't "I disagree with what the public wants"?"
I'm a part of the public, and I don't want it. I imagine there is a sizable number of others that don't want it too.
We could just force people to do whatever we want because a majority wants it, but that's no different than mob rule.
So far I haven't heard a compelling argument that this approach would solve more issues than it causes. The precise implementation would influence this greatly, but it isn't well defined. If we want to control housing prices in specific locations, I think a better approach is to cap the number of jobs in an area based on its carrying capacity. This would also provide more even distribution thorough out the state/country, reduce infrastructure concerns, and reduce property prices. But good luck convincing the politicians - they already like attracting jobs/companies by offering tax breaks, zoning variances, etc.
- uoaei 5y ago> We could just force people to do whatever we want because a majority wants it, but that's no different than mob rule. That's not mob rule, that's simple majority rule. We have access to other forms of consensus algorithms, but so far simple-majority seems to be the most anyone can stomach. That is very unfortunate. > would solve more issues than it causes. That's not the metric though, right? The metric is: are things better under that system vs this one? We want to measure whether B(enefits)2 - C(osts)2 >= B1 - C1, not whether B2 - C2 >= 0. I strongly agree with what I think you're implying, which is that we need more metropolitan areas, but I think we are not going to get very far with limits. You will get a lot more participation and a lot less tumult (not to mention orders of magnitude less bureaucratic overhead) if you offer carrots rather than sticks. People management is a real consideration: people are not identical particles subject to the continuum hypothesis.