4 ms·
I greatly disagree with the idea that big cities are becoming "increasingly unlivable." American cities, especially downtowns, are in the middle of doing the e
by dangus 5y ago
I greatly disagree with the idea that big cities are becoming "increasingly unlivable."
American cities, especially downtowns, are in the middle of doing the exact opposite of becoming unlivable. I'm not talking opinions here, I'm talking about factual changes in the context of American history.
American city downtowns started as, essentially, the entire city, with a diverse mix of residents, commerce, and industry. As the industrialization progressed, those downtowns morphed into commercial-only zones as most other uses migrated outward. [1]
Residential living was very rare in city centers in America, with only slum living left. Since then, however, American cities are re-introducing residential life to city centers and redesigning them around mixed use and essentially revitalizing them. [1]
So this idea that big cities are "increasingly unlivable" is more of a cynical opinion rather than a matter of historical fact.
Also, in terms of sustainability, cities still win out. Suburban and rural development fragments animal habitats and uses more land per person. More time and miles are needed in your car burning oil to get around. City dwellers who walk and take transit are more carbon efficient than suburban and rural drivers.
Counter-intuitively, water quality is better in cities where more people are connected to a treated municipal water source. Sewage is also better managed in cities. [2]
Now, on to what's my actual opinion...regarding asynchronous work: it's awesome if you're already at a senior level of skill, but to me it seems absolutely horrendous for new graduates and junior level employees. It's difficult to do "apprenticeship" asynchronously. The idea of a future of asynchronous work is also incredibly software-biased. For example, when Apple wants their employees back in the office there's good reason: they design hardware.
[1] https://placesjournal.org/article/downtown-a-short-history-of-american-urban-exceptionalism/ https://placesjournal.org/article/downtown-a-short-history-o...
[2] https://www.treehugger.com/environmentally-responsible-urban-or-rural-living-1203972 https://www.treehugger.com/environmentally-responsible-urban...
- Comevius 5y agoObviously not all jobs are remote-compatible, and obviously you would not do apprenticeship entirely asynchronously. Liveable is a subjective term, but water or air quality, or environmental footprint varies a great deal between countries. Cities consume most of the energy and produce most of the greenhouse gases for obvious reasons. Historically big cities became increasingly liveable, however my opinion is that we are at a turning point, in average big cities will become unliveable, some will improve slightly, and many will falter greatly. However urbanization will go on, people will continue to fill cities looking for opportunities, ironically climate change will even hasten this, eventually turning big cities into death traps.