8 ms·
Wait, if some ETF accidentally exceeds 15%, then what? First of all, that'll screw over a bunch of small investors, right? Second, could Elon swoop in at that
by hedora 5y ago
Wait, if some ETF accidentally exceeds 15%, then what? First of all, that'll screw over a bunch of small investors, right?
Second, could Elon swoop in at that point?
Edit: Also, if Elon is reading this, I'll happily buy 14.9% of twitter, and vote as part of your block. Just pay me enough to cover the sale and taxes, plus 1%.
- friesfreeze 5y agoPoison pills often have exemptions for passive investors such as ETFs.
- anonu 5y agoDon't think that's true. ETF fund managers, when faced with a corporate action decision, will always vote for whatever maximizes their shareholders value.
- friesfreeze 5y agoCourts have upheld poison pills that treat 13D and 13G filers differently. I'd wager most ETFs that hold 5% of major public companies are 13G filers. Vanguard files a 13G for twitter. To be fair idk what the twitter pill will do - maybe it will be more aggressive.
- rosndo 5y agoAn ETF isn’t going to “accidentally” exceed 15% ownership of Twitter. Seriously, do you think funds playing with the kind of money to buy 15% of twitter often make careless purchases? >Edit: Also, if Elon is reading this, I'll happily buy 14.9% of twitter, and vote as part of your block. Just pay me enough to cover the sale and taxes, plus 1%. Such an arrangement would make Elon the beneficial owner of your shares.
- kolbe 5y agoBarclay's literally forgot to register with the SEC to be allowed to issue securities, then issued $15bn of them over the course of years, and lost $600m as a result. If you think "funds with this kind of money" are any better than a pack of chimps, then you should direct that "seriously" back at yourself. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-03-28/barclays-sold-too-many-notes https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-03-28/barcla...
- rosndo 5y agoJust because one tiny fund screwed up once does not mean that it is anywhere near likely that any ETF would screw up in a manner that would trigger this poison pill. $15bn is tiny, presumably we’re talking about big ETFs like SPY here. And anyway, you’re pretty much agreeing with me. It’s absolutely possible for a big fund to make a huge and hilariously stupid mistake, but this twitter poison pill does not meaningfully affect the chances of that happening. In a world where you can shoot yourself in the foot in a million ways, it is utterly pointless to speculate about this one extraordinarily unlikely situation.
- kolbe 5y agoWhat? Barclays is one of the largest financial institutions in the world with $1.9tn in assets. I think we're in agreement that this Twitter thing isn't worth the attention, but we are far from agreeing that large financial institutions are inherently competent because they're large.
- hedora 5y agoI was literally wondering what would happen. ETFs are supposed to be algorithmically traded right? There's a race condition between the poison pill being instated and the ETF updating their strategy. I wonder if a board could maliciously take advantage of that somehow.
- heartbreak 5y agoETFs generally aren’t managed without human involvement, and this poison pill isn’t software either. You’re taking concepts that exist in worlds like Ethereum and applying it to normal finance. That’s not how it works.
- hedora 5y ago> Such an arrangement would make Elon the beneficial owner of your shares. Thanks for explaining why that won't work. Presumably, if Elon has a few rich friends, they could use their own money, vote as a block, and the board would still be screwed. I wonder what other schemes would work. B corp, maybe?
- doldols 5y ago> Presumably, if Elon has a few rich friends, they could use their own money, vote as a block, and the board would still be screwed. But that’s just playing along with the spirit of the rules, not a loophole.
- roughly 5y ago> An ETF isn’t going to “accidentally” exceed 15% ownership of Twitter. No, but an ETF has a defined investment strategy, and if enough money comes into the ETF, it could potentially trigger this.
- rosndo 5y agoDo you think big ETFs just buy shares willy nilly without any due diligence on company charters and bylaws?
- roughly 5y agoI’m curious what happens in that case, then - let’s say hypothetically that SPY has enough cash come into the fund that they’ll cross that threshold if they follow their stated investment policy (“buy the S&P”) - what’s the move, then?
- lalaland1125 5y agoBuy futures or other assets that will mimic the price. The stated investment goal isn't "buy the S&P", it's "match the price of the S&P".
- roughly 5y agoHow far can you go with that strategy? The derivative assets aren’t going to fully move with the price, and can have much higher volatility than the asset you’re trying to avoid buying.
- rosndo 5y agoNo, you aren’t going to have higher volatility like this than you would buy triggering a poison pill like discussed in the article.
- rosndo 5y agoThey will talk to Twitter board and make an agreement with them to not trigger the poison pill, and continue buying shares. Such an agreement would be reached incredibly quickly, there would be no need for stopgap measures. From the article: > Under the new structure, if any person or group acquires beneficial ownership of at least 15% of Twitter’s outstanding common stock without the board’s approval
- mike_d 5y ago> Edit: Also, if Elon is reading this, I'll happily buy 14.9% of twitter, and vote as part of your block. Just pay me enough to cover the sale and taxes, plus 1%. You might want to speak with a lawyer who is familiar with inchoate crime. What you publicly proposed to Elon is a crime, since you intend to conceal beneficial ownership of shares.
- friesfreeze 5y agoLikely wouldn't even get around modern poison pills since they often contain "wolf pack provisions" covering multiple persons acting in unison.
- epicureanideal 5y agoYet another example of something that many people wouldn’t think would be a crime, but would send them to prison for decades!
- PenguinCoder 5y agoFuck with rich peoples money, you're going to jail _for a long time_. Murder someone in a case of 'mistaken identity/residence', go to work tomorrow.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- beaned 5y agoWhere does the concealment come in?
- samhw 5y agoYeah, there's no concealment and no beneficial ownership. "I'll vote as part of your bloc" isn't beneficial ownership. (At most it's delegating the 'control' aspect of the equity, but even that is a stretch - in context, it's clearly a statement of incidental agreement with his opinion on this point, not a total delegation of control no matter what he should choose to do in future.)
- elif 5y agoX AE X-12 buys 15% triggering pill, X sells shares immediately to drop price, elon purchases 42.0% equity by minting new discounted budget shares?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stubish 5y agoI imagine if an ETF accidentally exceeded 15% then the board would go talk to the fund managers and maybe get them to sign some documents. This isn't a computer program that will automatically trigger armageddon. It is just some new rules that mean if you turn up at a board meeting saying 'haha, I just bought your company and you are all fired', the board gets to say 'nope, we just issued a bazillion shares and gave them to all the existing holders except you, and you now own just 14.9%, sorry not sorry for your loss'.
- anonu 5y agoThis happened with SKT (Tanger outlets) which is a high dividend paying stock in SDY ETF. The ETF was approaching 50% ownership stake. The fund needs to report their holdings. Not all companies have a poison pill provision. Not all companies that do have a poison pill will activate it. In the case of an ETF there's usually a discussion between the portfolio manager and the company. They know where they stand. Plus it's not really in a passive fund mandate to go activist.