3 ms·
> Yes, they need to look out for their shareholders but they also need to do right by the company, and companies can be formed for any legal purpose and everyon
by tsimionescu 5y ago
> Yes, they need to look out for their shareholders but they also need to do right by the company, and companies can be formed for any legal purpose and everyone (the company and the shareholders) values things differently
The board has a lot of leeway into how they achieve profit for the shareholders, but all decisions they make must be nominally in the interest of that goal (assuming we're discussing a for-profit company such as Twitter). They can basically claim anything they do is done in the interest of shareholder value and be safe, but if they said "we know the company will lose money on this, but we really like X so we'll spend company money on it", they would pretty clearly be in breach of their fiduciary duty.
- philistine 5y agoYou gave a very clear example of a breach. To add to your point, Elon's offer is both conditional on financing and too low, so we will implement a poison pill would never be seen as a breach.
- tuckerman 5y agoAt least in Delaware law, a board's fiduciary duty involves a duty of care, loyalty, and good faith. While acting to maximize their personal interests or egregiously working against profits could be considered a breach, not trying to maximally make profits probably wouldn't be. All of this would need to be litigated on a case-by-case basis, but many modern cases have found that companies can freely act to maximize the wages of their employees at the expense of dividends or act charitably even when there aren't tax breaks. That said, I'm not sure this really even applies in the case of Twitter---I think its not unreasonable to argue that the innate value of Twitter is so much higher than what Musk is offering that its better for the shareholders to wait even thinking purely in terms of profits (I would probably personally disagree with that, but I don't think its any more unreasonable than plenty of other valuations I see)
- tsimionescu 5y agoYes, they don't have to maximize profits, but they also can't ignore profit to the benefit of other values they deem more important, per the very old but still in force Dodge v Ford. As long as they are not egregiously and obviously acting against that goal, or taking decisions without deliberation, the law would favor them in any trial that only hinged on whether the price offered by Musk was better than the market. Basically the burden of proof to show that it could not have been a good business decision would lie with the plaintiff, and I very much doubt that you could build a solid case of that.
- tuckerman 5y agoI don't think Dodge v. Ford isn't a great case to cite here for two reasons: 1) I think the trend of accepting that corporations can exist for reasons other than to generate profit is a post-ww2 phenomenon and this case is from 1919 2) Perhaps more importantly, Dodge v. Ford was a case before the Michigan Supreme Court and, to my knowledge, has never been used in a case in Delaware.
- madhadron 5y agoI mean, saying "We are concerned about a hostile takeover attempt by a person who isn't allowed to be an officer of a public company anymore because he has show himself either unwilling or unable to be a fiduciary for stockholders, and we are trying to protect our stockholders from him" seems like a slam dunk in court.
- tsimionescu 5y agoMusk is offering to buy out all stockholders, so if the sale goes through, he will be the sole owner of Twitter, and all current stock holders will receive cash. On the other hand, the board can easily say "we don't beleive this deal offered by a person who isn't allowed to be a public officer of a company anymore will ever go through, either because he will retract it or because he will be unable to secure funding; and we beleive attempting the deal will hurt stock prices and profits for current shareholders" and then I agree, it would probably be a slam dunk in court.
- LocalPCGuy 5y agoAchieve profit is not the same thing as provide value or best interest of. It could be. It does not have to be.
- tsimionescu 5y agoA for-profit company is there for profit. There is no other way to interpret shareholder value in a for-profit company, for purposes of discussing fiduciary duty. Now, providing profit/share-holder value need not mean maximizing said profit - it just means that profit must always be considered in any business decision, it can never be entirely ignored in favor of other things. Note that not even shareholders get to decide what kind of value they expect their board to offer them. That definition of value is set in stone by the type of corporation. The board of a for-profit company has a fiduciary duty to the shareholders of the company as pertains to profits. If 100% of the shareholders of Twitter voted to ask the board to sacrifice profit for free speech; and the board decided to ignore this request entirely and publicly announced they would limit free speech at every trun to focus on profits, the shareholders would have no chance of winning a breach of fiduciary duty trial against the board. The board has no legal duty to uphold some abstract values that shareholders hold dear, they only have a legal duty to act in the interest of company profit as they see fit.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> it just means that profit must always be considered in any business decision, it can never be entirely ignored in favor of other things. The word "entirely" is doing a lot of work there. > The board of a for-profit company has a fiduciary duty to the shareholders of the company as pertains to profits. This is a dramatic oversimplification that borders on falsehood, as you noted yourself in your previous paragraph. As a trivial example, the board would be entirely entitled to claim that their goal is very long term profit maximization, and that this will result in decades of losses (effectively Amazon's strategy). We also now have "Public Benefit Corporation" as a codification of a for-profit corporation that does not have profit as its primary motivation (at least in 35 states & DC), but obviously that does not apply in the case of Twitter.
- hajile 5y agoWe are the largest perennially unprofitable company to ever exist. The richest guy in the world offered to invest a fifth of his net worth into the gamble of turning our company profitable while making our shareholders a massive profit. Instead, we poisoned the system knowing that the stock is all but guaranteed to tank massively reducing our market cap and hurting our ability to take out still more loans to continue our unprofitable venture. But we're holding true to our other nebulous values. They'll have a very compelling argument.
- tsimionescu 5y agoTo prove a breach of fiduciary duty, you generally have a very high burden of evidence, unless you can show some conflict of interest or obvious lack of deliberation. Otherwise, the business judgement rule is applied, where the presumption is that the directors acted in good faith, and you would essentially have to prove that it is impossible for Twitter stock to grow beyond the current offer.
- hajile 5y agoWhat answer could they give for their actions that isn't immediately disprovable garbage? Do you really think that discovery would show that this was all in good faith? I'd bet heavily that a lot of ideological discussions would be disclosed. As that is completely contradictory to what Twitter claims is their goal, bad faith would be the only remaining option.
- tsimionescu 5y agoI would bet that no such ideological grounds would be found in discovery, even if it were true, unless the board are complete morons to discuss such things over email. Instead, it is easy to expect they would discuss the sincerity of Musk's offer (the chance that they may accept it only for it to be retracted, as happened with the board membership offer), the plausibility of him having the required financing, the stock price today vs 6 months ago compared to the offer, and similar business discussions. I also don't personally believe this is an ideological battle at all - it's much more likely to be a financial manouever or simple ego-driven ambition by Musk.